View Single Post
Old 9th March 2007, 16:44   #31 (permalink)
salilpawar1
BHPian
 
salilpawar1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Mumbai (MH-01)
Posts: 447
Unhappy Close This Thread

Quote:
I guess now you can udnerstand the difference between "Inspiration or Inspired by" and "Blatant Rip-Of"f
Dear Mods,
I think the thread should be CLOSED now (many would agree). I never wanted this discussion to be a BIG BAD ARGUMENT SESSION.

My personal conclusions from this thread:

1) The Chinese are big fat copycats. I never had any doubt about that.

2) Taking a few bits from here and there = "INSPIRATION"
Complete copying = "COPYING"
So by the same logic, if a scene from a bollywood movie is copied from a hollywood movie, it is "INSPIRATION". If the whole movie is copied, it is "COPYING".

3) If a big manufacturer has a car which has some design cues similar to a successful car, it is Inspiration. If the manufacturer is a smaller one, then it is copied. I can find some examples where a car made by a smaller manufacturer with some famous design elements branded as "rip-offs".

4) I think there is a myth developed that bigger manufacturers can never copy... even if one of their models do appear a bit copy, then it is purely a "coincidence".

5) I still stand by all my views. I am not saying that Chinese are not copycats.

I can still give many more examples with pictorial proof but it is going to be a waste of time...
__________________
Petrol Indicas are rare and those with an EFF EFF EEE are rarer!
salilpawar1 is offline   Reply With Quote