Team-BHP - View Single Post

Bridge · 23rd June 2008, 18:00

I Want to ask the same age old question - Xeta or Alto

But now after the launch of Xeta LPG this question is with different perspactive.

Currently I want to decide between Xeta GLS and Alto Lxi. I had a Maruti 800 which I sold recently. Then I thought of alto as FE was the most important thing. But now my family is fed up of small space. So I thought of Xeta LPG. GLS is 26k costlier than Alto Lxi in Pune. I dont mind spending 26k more but the FE of Xeta with LPG should be nearly same as of Alto
with Petrol.

I have gone through the running cost comparision given in this thread. So to make more sense, I am revising the comparision with latest data.
Petrol in Pune : 56 Rs.
LPG : 36 Rs.
I run approx. 12000 Km/year
If Xeta LPG (GLS) gives me a milage of 12Km on LPG then too its more economical than Alto with 17Km milage.
The cost comes on Alto is (56 Rs x (12000 km / 17Km/ltr)) = Rs. 39529
And with Xeta on LPG is (36 Rs x (12000 km / 12Km/ltr)) = Rs. 36000

So, if Xeta FE is 12Km/ltr then its more economical than alto. And even if its 11 Km/ltr the cost comes as Rs. 39272 which is nearly matching the Alto's FE.

I gone through almost all related posts on Xeta to find out the FE of Xeta LPG. The new posts dont have the FEs and other posts are as old as of 2006.

Can anybody help me finding out the FE and help me decide between Xeta GLS and Alto Lxi ?

23rd June 2008, 18:00	#99 (permalink)
Bridge Newbie Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: Pune Posts: 11	Xeta LPG GLS or Alto LXi ? I Want to ask the same age old question - Xeta or Alto But now after the launch of Xeta LPG this question is with different perspactive. Currently I want to decide between Xeta GLS and Alto Lxi. I had a Maruti 800 which I sold recently. Then I thought of alto as FE was the most important thing. But now my family is fed up of small space. So I thought of Xeta LPG. GLS is 26k costlier than Alto Lxi in Pune. I dont mind spending 26k more but the FE of Xeta with LPG should be nearly same as of Alto with Petrol. I have gone through the running cost comparision given in this thread. So to make more sense, I am revising the comparision with latest data. Petrol in Pune : 56 Rs. LPG : 36 Rs. I run approx. 12000 Km/year If Xeta LPG (GLS) gives me a milage of 12Km on LPG then too its more economical than Alto with 17Km milage. The cost comes on Alto is (56 Rs x (12000 km / 17Km/ltr)) = Rs. 39529 And with Xeta on LPG is (36 Rs x (12000 km / 12Km/ltr)) = Rs. 36000 So, if Xeta FE is 12Km/ltr then its more economical than alto. And even if its 11 Km/ltr the cost comes as Rs. 39272 which is nearly matching the Alto's FE. I gone through almost all related posts on Xeta to find out the FE of Xeta LPG. The new posts dont have the FEs and other posts are as old as of 2006. Can anybody help me finding out the FE and help me decide between Xeta GLS and Alto Lxi ?