| || ||Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|4th May 2009, 02:07||#16|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Nov 2006
Thanked: 60 Times
They are expensive but they also carry a lot of resonance in it if not build properly. Also, get one air tight would be a difficult job. But, there some who use in the box for a view of the magnet. It does look cool. But, still MDF are the best way to go, sound wise. I use to get my boxes build in High density fiber-particle board years back. They are stronger than MDF but are not easily available and was twice the cost of MDF. The advantage was it was stronger than MDF and one can go .50" of it against the .75" MDF. Building a box is an art, better you build better the results.
Last edited by Invinsible : 4th May 2009 at 02:08.
|4th May 2009, 10:39||#17|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Mar 2006
Thanked: 294 Times
The Aluminum is stiffer and does not flex like MDF that is the reason I choose it. MDF is the best and cheapest alternative for a enclosure material. Even I use it and I am satisfied with it.
Last edited by low_bass_makker : 4th May 2009 at 10:43.
|4th May 2009, 11:18||#18|
Join Date: Mar 2004
Thanked: 4,286 Times
2. MDF is not compressed ply wood. Ply wood is compressed "plys" of wood sheet bonded together with some phenolic compound such as "Urea Melamine Formaldehyde". UMF is made using Benzene and Polyproplene which is then decomposed in a controlled manner (using Hydrogen rich acids). A by prodct of UMF is Acetone - the kind your wife/GF uses to remover her nail polish.
3. thickness for thickness ply can bend more than MDF but if both are prestressed ply can infct withstand greater bending moments than MDF and is hence able to made much stiffer (if prestressed).
4. As far as alternate materials are concerned there are some I have tried.
a. Aluminum - resonant. you can damp Aluminum using rubber compunds which is what JBL did for it Pro III (now called the Control 1)
b. Stainless Steel - resonant but not as bad as AL. However SS is 3 times as dense as AL and hence the whole structure can become very heavy. Weight is not good (unless it's presennse can be justified by the material's ablity to be damped or stiff) as it stores more energy which is relased later
c. Fiberlgass - diffcult to work with. Needs some special tools to make it thick enough and not de-laminate under long term use.
d. Carbon fibre - expensive. Not WAF friendly in looks. This might be the best material for car subwoofers though.
e. Glass and Ceramics - stiff but resonant. Must be used along with a second non resonant material
f. Plexiglass - too much flex but can be used in small panels (20cm-30cm square) for looks.
g. Bitumen (tar) - used primarily as a damping compund for ceramic tiles but horribly messey to work with in liquid form. You can get Bitumen sheet (or bitumen soaked sheets) and many roofing companies use the same (in corrugated form).
Guys this might look authoritative but it is not. I am willing to stand corrected but what I have stated above is only from my personal experinces.
My choice of materials today is a laminate of MDF-FRP-MDF-FRP-Ply. MDF layers are 4mm, FRP 3mm, Ply 6mm. This gives me a total thickness of 20mm. This gives me a limited degree of mess, easy to DIY (no special tools required), and adequate stiffness, damping and weight. I am sure that using more modern techniques and materials can lead to better results.
|The following BHPian Thanks navin for this useful post:|
|Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Spider Diesel Tuning Box VS. Pete's Tuning Box - Spider Box feedback on pg 2||Endeavour333||Modifications & Accessories||130||11th September 2017 01:24|
|Fiberglass Vs Mdf Enclosure||DjNik||In-Car Entertainment||13||29th April 2011 18:16|
|Custom Sub Box - Your Views Please||vigsom||In-Car Entertainment||11||6th February 2009 17:42|
|Custom MDF enclosures : Install / Cost info needed (pics enclosed)||s0uljah||In-Car Entertainment||74||13th February 2008 02:44|
|For sale: MDF Subwoofer Enclosure||nitrous||Shifting gears||4||11th September 2007 13:05|