| || ||Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|24th September 2010, 16:30||#1|
When a movie freak went pocket friendly (My Home Cinema)
To begin with, I am a hard core movie fan. The idea of a home cinema came to my mind a couple of years ago. As always it was Vitamin M which pulled me back every time. However decided to start the project a couple of months ago. No more bluffing, right into the details.
As I said, the cinema hall will be used 90% of the time for movies and another 10% for other live programs like cricket matches, stage shows etc. I am always a fan of big screen movie halls and hence there was no confusion between an LCD panel or a projector. Also I wants to have a decent sound system (rather rich in clarity than butt kicking beats) For me, room acoustics and ambiance make a great combination for a wonderful movie experience. So for sure, a dedicated room also needed for my set up. And all in a tight budget of 2Lakhs.
Budget Break up:
Core Equipments - 60K (Including projector, sound system, cabling)
Supporting Equipments - 10K (Including 1KVA UPS and cooling systems)
Room - 1Lakh (Including plastering and painting)
Interiors - 30K
Selection of Equipments
The main thing is that the budget I am on is infact very tight. 2Lakh is the maximum with not a penny more.
The first thing which I decided to pick up was the projector it self. Then the war of LCD Vs DLP came, both with its advantages and disadvantages. And at the end of the day, it was an Acer DLP which became the winner. The second day from ordering, the item was shipped by the eBay seller. Projector details are as follows
Make : Acer
Model : X110 3D Ready
Type : DLP
Resolution : SVGA (Native), capable of up to 1080p
Brightness : 2500 Lumens
Contrast : 4000:1
Source : eBay India
Amount spent : Rs. 24,250
Amount Remaining : 1,75,750
Screen will be made by projector fabric on MDF panel.
The next one in the list is the audio system it self. I want a 7.1 configuration system, no compromise on that since the room dimension I am thinking of needs a 7.1. Also, my only source will be a HTPC. Therefore I am not much inclined to a AV receiver. The current set up which I am looking for now is as follows.
Sound Card - Creative X-Fi - 6K
Speakers - Creative T7900 - 8.5K
Total - 14.5K
I am a DIY guy, especially in the electronics domain. So I am also planning to set up an audio system my self with following.
Yamaha Subwoofer - 12K (eBay)
Satellite speakers made from car speakers - 14K
Amplifier (DIY 7-Channel) - 4K
Total - 31K
Sound Card - Creative X-Fi - 6K
Speakers - Creative S750 - 34K
Total - 40K
I have no idea about the amount needed for the room set up. My appointment with the engineer will be this weekend. Depending on that I am planning to finalize between the above 3 set up.
Room Set up:
The room I am planning for is a completely dark one with A/C. The design will be done by my self and the idea will be transferred to a local contractor.
Dimension - 20*14 Ft
Interiors - MDF Wooden panelling and carpet flooring
A/C - 1.5 Ton Split
Total Budget - 1.3 L
The major issue I am facing now is regarding the purchase of speaker systems. I was so surprised to see that there are no much options for an entry level 7.1 channel speaker system. I am searching for both T7900 and S750 for the past 1 week for no luck
Keep watching for more updates.
Last edited by bhp_maniac : 24th September 2010 at 16:31. Reason: Grammatical mistakes
|30th September 2010, 23:35||#2|
Join Date: Oct 2005
Thanked: 11 Times
Post deleted by the Team-BHP Support : Please do NOT post one-liners that add little or no informational value to the thread. We need your co-operation to maintain the overall quality of this forum.
Please read our rules before proceeding any further.
Last edited by GTO : 18th October 2011 at 14:23.
|1st October 2010, 00:53||#3|
Join Date: Oct 2005
Thanked: 2,016 Times
This is a great idea. On several occasions I have myself toyed with the idea of buying a DLP to get the big screen experience at home. However yours is nothing short of creating a full fledged mini theater at home! Kudos to you. I will keep tracking your progress on this thread.
By the way I wonder how soon NC and so many other of our movie crazed junta will spot this thread.
|1st October 2010, 08:27||#5|
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Atlanta, US
Thanked: 16 Times
Interesting..!! Please share more info as you proceed on this project. Do share the pics once you are done with the setup.
Have you considered the seating options?
|1st October 2010, 09:01||#6|
Distinguished - BHPian
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Mumbai (but wat
Thanked: 1,454 Times
I think: a 5.1 system will suffice perfectly well in your room. And there are plenty of entry level GOOD 5.1 systems at that price (without source)
I do not think you can get a decent 7.1 system for 35K.
And I am pretty sure those creative speakers will not replicate a theatre-like experience.
If you go for a DIY power amplifier (only 4K? A good transformer for a power supply can cost that much) then please ensure that your HTPC has discrete outputs for each of the 5.1 or 7.1 chanels, otherwise you will have no surround sound.
Cooling systems? I'm confused. Is that for the computer or what?
Last edited by Sam Kapasi : 1st October 2010 at 09:07.
|1st October 2010, 09:14||#7|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Delhi / Agra / London
Thanked: 214 Times
Nice Idea ! I will keep a close watch on this thread. However I feel that this setup will be incomplete without 2 LAZ boy recliners and also wall to wall carpetting which will take care of sound proofing. Correct me if I am wrong.
|1st October 2010, 11:16||#8|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Jan 2008
Thanked: 352 Times
Great idea.. have three inputs:
1. You might want to rethink about speakers.
DIY with Car speakers / Creative speakers might not give you sound that is good enough to match rest of the experience.
Car speakers are made to move small amount of air in enclosed pace.
I would suggest that you look for 5.1 speaker package from JBL (HK) / Onkyo / Yamaha.
You can get a package with a decent active sub starting from 15k.
2. HTPC would cost almost same as an entry-level receiver. A 5.1 receiver from Onkyo/Denon/Yamaha would cost around 20k. And it will do the job of amplification as well till you are bitten by upgradities again
3. OTOH, "building" the HT is as much (if not more) fun than using it. So if DIY is your idea of fun, forget point #1 and #2
|1st October 2010, 11:25||#9|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Apr 2007
Thanked: 1,183 Times
Car speakers should never be used in the home environments. You will ruin your entire experience. Car speakers are designed to have a very wide dispersion and they sound similar whether off axis or on axis.
Home speakers are designed with narrower dispersion characteristics and it is implicitly assumed that you will be in front of them and in such an environment which is the case in almost any room, car speakers will fail miserably.
You can buy a decent 5.1 speaker setup for around 20 grand. Another 15k will get you an entry level receiver. You are good to go from there on.
PS: There's a Mission clearance sale going on by their erstwhile distributor on ebay.in. You can snag a very decent speaker system for 18-19k.
Last edited by reignofchaos : 1st October 2010 at 11:29.
|1st October 2010, 14:48||#10|
Join Date: May 2010
Location: New Delhi
Thanked: 5 Times
Speakers are THE MOST IMPORTANT component of any Home Theatre. So my humble advice would be to go for a good system which is well co-ordinated in terms of driver timbre matching etc. along with a good subwoofer. Take a look at Wharfedale cinema systems, they are affordable and pack a phenomenon punch, a total Value for money system. Again, to really enjoy the sound effects you will need a decent amplifier to drive the speakers, the HTPC option would be lame, as suggested by others look at entry level Yamaha, Onkyo and Denon amplifiers. If your budget is tight, I would say invest in good equipment and divert funds from your Room allocation for the time being and do up the room a little later or just innovate regarding decoration by using cheaper stuff for the room.
|1st October 2010, 16:04||#11|
Regarding the set up, my current plan has some what changed a from what I mentioned above. I am currently inclined to an Onkyo HT-S5300. This will have a 7.1 receiver with speakers and an active sub woofer. Cost will come around 38K if I am importing from US and 53K if I am taking from India. Any suggestions on this?
Regarding the DIY amplifier set up, currently I am running a 5.1 set up at my home on a 600 W PC SMPS. The system is working fine for the past 3.5 years. That entire set up cost me 3K with home made speaker enclosures. If anybody interested, I can put up the detailed amount I spent. So my plan was to add another amplifier and a separate active sub woofer to make it a 7.1. I am a DIY guy, but time is a great issue. Thats why inclined to a ready made system.
Regarding the power setup, UPS is to prevent abrupt power loss especially for the projector. My projector needs around 90 Sec for a proper shutdown. The cooling system will be needed for the equipment enclosure as I am planning to put everything in closed enclosures. You will get a fair good idea when I am putting up the design plan.
2) Acer X110 DLP
3) Onkyo HT-S 5300
I am attaching the front panel design I am looking of. Pour in your suggestions dears.
Latest update on the system is that, I will have an appointment with an engineer this weekend for getting estimates on the room construction. Had an appointment with a carpenter for the wood works and we are estimating a sum of 30K. 80% of the work will be done on MDF.
Last edited by bhp_maniac : 1st October 2010 at 16:05. Reason: grammatical errors
|1st October 2010, 16:24||#12|
Mods, please merge with the previous post if you feel like. I definitely felt like it ruins the readability while multi quoting a lot of posts in one entry. Thats why creating another entry.
Another update on the sound system:
Came to know that Onkyo HT-S5300 supports digital audio only. And guys, I have a problem here. My creative audigy is capable of S/PDIF but it will just pass through the Dolby and DTS signals, no processing from the card's side. I am worried on the effect of this part. Anybody knows a good receiver which can handle analog inputs? I was not able to find one.
Last edited by bhp_maniac : 1st October 2010 at 16:26. Reason: Reason for two entries.
|17th October 2011, 12:42||#13|
Re: My High-End Home Cinema
For the past couple of months, I am raring to put an update on the install which I had done some 3 months back. So here it goes, straight into the matter. And apologies for not updating the thread for one full year!!! Sorry for a long post
To cut story short, I had finalized the equipments around an year back. The list goes as
1) Acer 3D Ready DLP X110
2) AMD X4 powered server/projector driver
3) Creative THX certified S750
4) Ceiling mount
5) Custom rack and a 120” screen.
6) Remote control
I was pretty much particular about the equipment list, and my requirements were baselined Started hunting around for the equipments. Oh man, running around sourcing the organs for your dream is really an awesome experience.
The first one to arrive was the projector. I tried sourcing this from local projector stores. Most of them quoted around 32K for X110 with 1 year warranty on lamp. I was almost there when I saw a listing for a box packed X110 at 23K then. Without even a second thought I clicked “Buy this item”. Everything after was seamless. It came within 3 days of purchasing. Everything was box packed and I was happy with the purchase after trying it our on a couple of HD content.
The speakers came at a final quote of 31K from one of my friend’s PC store back at my home town. Almost everyone there were yelling at me like are you crazy shelling out these much for a “speaker”? Oh dear, convincing those desi guys on how much movie freak I am was a difficult part to handle. But believe me, the purchase was not so problem free as it went for the projector, The first set of speakers had a satellite with tweeter not working. The distributor replaced the satellite promptly. After setting up, noticed that the subwoofer has a disturbing hum. It was so difficult to convince them this. I told them I don’t expect such a performance from a THX certified sound system. Had to shell out some diesel to get things sorted out. Finally they agreed upon replacing the entire system. So it took around 3 weeks time for me to get a satisfactory sound system.
I am always a fan of DIY thing. So decided to assemble my PC on my own. After not so much hectic research, I decided upon the following.
ASUS M4A 78 LT-M LE
AMD X4 @ 3.1 GHz
KINGSTON 4GB DDR3
A BASIC IBALL ATX CABINET
Building the PC was a relatively easy process. Everything was up and running without any issues. It took only around an hour for me to complete the assembly.
So, I had everything ready to start the movie experience of my dreams.
It was a sunny Saturday, when I fixed my second appointment with the engineer and a contractor he suggested me. With lots of glory on face and dreams in mind, I started my Swift and flied to engineer’s place 15km away from my home town. He and the contractor was waiting for me. We discussed and decided upon the final plan. Contractor gave me an estimate of 1.5L for the entire work. I had a bit of bargain and everything was fixed for 1.25L so that my initial plan of 2L total budget will be respected. He promised me a completion date within 25 days. I was so happy that the afternoon, I went partying hard Going to temple daily is a part of my Mom’s life. Every time she comes back, she used to have a refreshing smile and “Prasadam” in her hands. But this sunday, she came back with a dull face. When I asked, she told me that the poojari (pandit) at the temple told her, not to start any construction in another year at our place. I was like stunned and I had everything from frustration to depression to sorrow on my face My heart said, what a pitiful end to those enchanting dreams. Anyway I wanted to start the work only with my parents’ satisfactory approval.
So the projector, S750 and the PC was sitting idle in the corner of my bedroom back at home town. My wife one day said what a waste of money!!! With all sort of confidence I decided to go for a plan B
I thought of the possibility of having a temporary install of the system somewhere and decided upon doing it in my apartment back in Kochi. Space constraint is a definite issue in most of these budget apartments. Same is the situation here. I can’t even think of a dedicated HT room there. My mantra was simple, invest bare minimum and get the system up and running. After an year, if enthusiasm still holds on, relocate the same to home town. I already had one air conditioned room (my master bedroom). So after some arguments with wife, finally she agreed upon installing the same there. So it was a seigh of relief on my face which got me a ray of hope at the other end.
I decided to do a DIY install this time. Estimated time was one of those lazy Sundays. Only took help of a carpenter to drill me the ceiling mount for projector. Everything else including wiring was my part. I decided to go the casing-caping way to do the wiring. Two things made me decide upon this. I am still not fully convinced whether I will get that movie experience which I was seeking in such a small room. So I should be able to undo the entire installation with minimal damage to the walls and paint works. At the end it was not a very bad decision.
Mounting the projector:
I wanted to have at least a 90” diagonal projection with a 16:9 aspect. Had done some calculations for my projector and found that I can get a decent 120” projection within my room, provided I place the projector to the extreme back side. I used this calculator.
Projection Calculator Classic - Throw Distance and Screen Size
Carpenter came in and drilled the holes on the ceiling. Projector install was pretty much easier than I thought. It was done in 15 minutes time. I did a dummy connection to my laptop and fixed the mounting place so that I can get the desired image size.
Wiring the projector & speakers:
This didn’t went so easy on me. I misjudged the size of the bunch of wires it had to hold. I had to run the VGA cable, 7 channel surround everything in a 2” casing-caping. It was hard, but finally succeeded. I won’t say the install was top notch, but it works The projector was wired by a 10m VGA cable which I sourced locally. I was worried about the noise part, but to my surprise, running 10m on VGA didn’t make any noise on the image (at least to my eyes) For speakers, the set of wires which came with it was enough. The entire wiring phase took around 2-3 hours to complete including fixing the speakers.
Fixing the rack:
While doing furnishing of my apartment, I had designed a rather “practical” rack. It should handle the double role. One as the rack for my HTPC and also a normal workstation desktop. I had decided upon going the dual monitor way. The reason was two. One was that I have a lot of SD quality content in my collection which are not at all worth to burn my projector’s valuable lamp life. So I wanted a cheap alternative. Second was that I needed a monitor for the workstation part. I decided to use my retiring 24” LCD to work as the monitor. I had replaced the 24” in my living room with a 32”. So the 24” definitely needed a new assignment and he was more than happy to be my workstation buddy. The 24” is a Full HD panel from Onida.
I love the networking part of it. My ADSL modem is residing in my other room. So I decided to go wireless for networking. Initially I was using a Netgear WG311V3 adaptor, and to be frank it’s a piece of sh**. Low speeds, dropped connections, bluescreen errors and finally I sourced an Asus N150 for 650 bucks from eBay. This server is also networked to another HTPC in living room and also serves broadband connectivity to my work/personal laptops.
I wanted the system to be focusing completely on the entertainment part of it. So installed a Windows 7 with bare minimum services running. After doing some research, decided upon using XBMC as the media center software. Everything went perfect and the installation was pretty easy. I set up XBMC to use the second display (projector) for display. Believe me, if you’re a hard core movie freak, XBMC is the way to go. It will sort your collection, automatically download all those details including imdb rating, fanart, thumbnails, storyline, plot give it anything about movies under sun and xbmc is capable of getting it for you. I am a die hard fan of XBMC now. Plus that the famous uTorrent for all those heavy downloads.
By 7 in the evening, I was done with the installation and the system was ready to have the first boot. Thankfully there were no unforeseen issues this time, and everything worked out of the box. Dual monitor set up was running seamlessly and I am loving it.
Video of system running on XBMC
My own review:
I never expected such a decent performance from this entry level SVGA projector. The image quality is pretty decent if the content is anything above 480p. And HD contents give excellent reproduction. For movie lovers, DLP is the way to go. Minimum screen door effect, excellent color reproduction and decent contrast much superior to LCD. Above all, its relatively cheap for the performance it gives.
I am having mixed response to this. I won’t say it’s a value for money purchase. At 31K it should have a better center channel and more controlled bass. Being said that, the speakers perform very well for movies but not so good for music. The 210W subwoofer is a serious kicker and the everytime we need to minimize its volume to balance with the satellites. The satellites do a pretty decent job barring center channel. The center definitely lacks power.
Oh boy, its such an inevitable part of any HTPC set up. Far better than the windows MCE and with an open source licensing, lot of add ons to blow your needs
The Cost Factor:
The entire set up all inclusive was done within a budget of 75K
Currently I am using the wall itself to project the images. Its not bad provided the projector has a wall color correction available. But I want to go for a better custom built fixed screen. I am planning to do the same in a month or two.
My ADSL is a 54Mbps WiFi access point. I am planning to upgrade to a 300Mbps wireless N system so that I can stream 1080p content from my server to any of the clients.
Am I happy after all these?
Oh dear, a big YES !!! Its an awesome experience to watch your favorite movies on a decently big projection with snacks.
Note: Mods, please change the title of the thread to a more meaningful one. As the "High end home cinema" is now a "Budget home cinema", I think something like "When a movie freak went pocket friendly" will be more meaningful!!!
Radeon HD 5450:
Last edited by bhp_maniac : 17th October 2011 at 13:01. Reason: Adding link to video
|Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|"pure Cinema"||tifosikrishna||Shifting gears||335||13th March 2013 16:10|
|My funny experience(s) at PVR-Phoenix cinema, Mumbai||Sam Kapasi||Shifting gears||47||11th August 2009 15:07|
|Pocket Bikes and Pocket Bike racing||Edmund||Motorbikes||28||13th December 2008 17:25|