Space and comfort at 4-5 lakhs - Team-BHP

amu1983 · 20th February 2007, 00:35

My Dad (age 50+) wants to buy a car. His first priority is comfort and space in the rear seat. He is willing to spend at most 5 lakhs, but will be happier if something gives more bang for the buck. Somehow he is inclined towards Diesel cars, although, I know he wouldn't be traveling more than 600-800 kms per month.

Maintenance costs is the 2nd priority, and resale value 3rd. The car would mostly be driven by a driver, but I think, getting the WagonR automatic is also a good idea, as if he has to learn / drive occasionally. But, he hates Maruti vehicles, feels that they are all too cramped. Indica Diesel is his dream car, for he's been in it umpteen number of times, and has liked it. But, I feel a TATA vehicle would be too costly to maintain considering his occasional use. Could you help me out here?
Cars short listed -
WagonR, Xeta, Indica, Indigo, Swift

Price range - upto 4-5 lakhs.

I guess, resale isn't too important, as he will keep it for 5 years at least. But, I think, Indica Diesel will die away after 5 years, so getting a newer model like Swift will be a good idea.

mithun · 20th February 2007, 06:31

Get an Indica if Space and comfort is the priority.But I don't think it makes sense to go for a diesel car for this low KMS.

carCrazy25 · 20th February 2007, 06:56

My friends told me that with all the Discounts in bangalore, you should be able to get swift VXi around 4.5 L.
I also believe the back seats are pretty comfortable.
Or else you could also go for Getz, it's supposed to have very good Interiors.

namit · 20th February 2007, 09:38

Going by the cars you shortlisted it gotta be some TATA car but they are not that refined.

And in petrol, SWIFT is not comfortable at rear so strongly consider Aveo UVA .... maintenance is also not much and GM is offering 1 lakh kms warranty free on the car.

GTO · 20th February 2007, 09:39

I faced the same situation a couple of months back; the only difference being that the expected running was 2000+ kms a month and the usage was decidedly rough.

For chauffeur-driven cars with comfort and economy, there is nothing to beat the Indigo. Go for it....your father will be a happy man on the back seat.

goldie_malhotra · 20th February 2007, 10:05

Why not consider the Getz as well - great space and comfort, and quite easy to drive. Maintenance from Hyundai would also be cheap and easy.

sreedotk · 20th February 2007, 10:10

If your folks are not in an immediate need basis (i.e can wait for a few more weeks) the Mahindra Logan may be the right answer too

regards

DCEite · 20th February 2007, 10:13

Go for the Indigo. Or if you are willing to take a little risk take the Logan this April.

benbsb29 · 20th February 2007, 10:48

Since rear seat comfort is a priority, u could go for the Ikon Flair, which comes in at 5.49L on road Bangalore. Among the best in terms of rear seat comfort, dated looks which still manage to thrill and among the best in terms of handling. Since maintenance and resale have been given lower priorities according to you, my suggestion for the same.

Please let me know if u have any further queries on the same. While there are people who advise against Ford, there any people who love their Fords' too.

sumitsingh · 20th February 2007, 11:30

Since according to you, your father is pretty comfortable with the Tata Indica according to the size and comfort. I think going for the Indigo might be a better option given you have a budget for it.

Its Diesel, has good back seat comfort and will be easy to maintain given the cost of the spares plus you get a boot at premium hatchback prices.

As others have suggested, if you can wait for a while, wait for the Logan to launch. If nothing else, it will enable you to get some more discounts for the Indigo since that is the car that might be most hit on the launch of the Logan.

Hope I have added more to your confusion.

-Sumit

Steeroid · 20th February 2007, 11:35

Indigo diesel is a good idea considering his requirements. I wouldnt recommend a Swift for someone who is going to be occupying the rear seat most of the time.

Maintenance costs on an Indica/go are not high at all if the vehicle is well maintained periodically. Ask for extended warranty.

normally_crazy · 20th February 2007, 11:39

Its a no brainer pal, Indigo Diesel - eyes closed.

esteem_lover · 20th February 2007, 11:46

Why not the Ikon flair ? far better than the indigo & certainly not a lottery. It is quite a proven car in India too.

sajo · 20th February 2007, 11:50

Indigo DICOR. Go for the LS/LX. The SX simply costs too much, IMHO. Petrol is not worth buying (unless the DOHC is made available).

benbsb29 · 20th February 2007, 11:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by esteem_lover

Why not the Ikon flair ? far better than the indigo & certainly not a lottery. It is quite a proven car in India too.

Now we're talking.

20th February 2007, 00:35	#1 (permalink)
amu1983 BHPian Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Pune Posts: 144	Space and comfort at 4-5 lakhs My Dad (age 50+) wants to buy a car. His first priority is comfort and space in the rear seat. He is willing to spend at most 5 lakhs, but will be happier if something gives more bang for the buck. Somehow he is inclined towards Diesel cars, although, I know he wouldn't be traveling more than 600-800 kms per month. Maintenance costs is the 2nd priority, and resale value 3rd. The car would mostly be driven by a driver, but I think, getting the WagonR automatic is also a good idea, as if he has to learn / drive occasionally. But, he hates Maruti vehicles, feels that they are all too cramped. Indica Diesel is his dream car, for he's been in it umpteen number of times, and has liked it. But, I feel a TATA vehicle would be too costly to maintain considering his occasional use. Could you help me out here? Cars short listed - WagonR, Xeta, Indica, Indigo, Swift Price range - upto 4-5 lakhs. I guess, resale isn't too important, as he will keep it for 5 years at least. But, I think, Indica Diesel will die away after 5 years, so getting a newer model like Swift will be a good idea.

20th February 2007, 06:31	#2 (permalink)
mithun Senior - BHPian Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Cochin/B'lore(Land of Speed-breakers) Posts: 1,564 View My Garage	Get an Indica if Space and comfort is the priority.But I don't think it makes sense to go for a diesel car for this low KMS. __________________ Hold fast to dreams, for if dreams dry, life is a broken-winged bird that cannot fly.

20th February 2007, 09:39	#5 (permalink)
GTO Team-BHP Support Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Bombay Posts: 18,786 View My Garage	I faced the same situation a couple of months back; the only difference being that the expected running was 2000+ kms a month and the usage was decidedly rough. For chauffeur-driven cars with comfort and economy, there is nothing to beat the Indigo. Go for it....your father will be a happy man on the back seat. __________________ GTO Work backward from your imagination, not forward from the past! Please don't PM for support. Use the Contact Form instead. Please read the NEW Team-BHP FAQ section for all your queries.

20th February 2007, 10:05	#6 (permalink)
goldie_malhotra BHPian Join Date: Nov 2005 Location: New Delhi Posts: 686	Why not consider the Getz as well - great space and comfort, and quite easy to drive. Maintenance from Hyundai would also be cheap and easy. __________________ Too much work, too less play - seems like I need some BHP

20th February 2007, 10:13	#8 (permalink)
DCEite Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Sep 2004 Location: Gurgaon Posts: 2,185 View My Garage	Go for the Indigo. Or if you are willing to take a little risk take the Logan this April. __________________ *A public-opinion poll is no substitute for thought.* - Warren Buffett

20th February 2007, 06:56	#3 (permalink)
carCrazy25 BHPian Join Date: Nov 2005 Location: Bangalore Posts: 76	My friends told me that with all the Discounts in bangalore, you should be able to get swift VXi around 4.5 L. I also believe the back seats are pretty comfortable. Or else you could also go for Getz, it's supposed to have very good Interiors.

20th February 2007, 09:38	#4 (permalink)
namit BHPian Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Delhi Posts: 267	Going by the cars you shortlisted it gotta be some TATA car but they are not that refined. And in petrol, SWIFT is not comfortable at rear so strongly consider Aveo UVA .... maintenance is also not much and GM is offering 1 lakh kms warranty free on the car.

20th February 2007, 10:10	#7 (permalink)
sreedotk BHPian Join Date: Dec 2006 Location: Hyderabad Posts: 105	If your folks are not in an immediate need basis (i.e can wait for a few more weeks) the Mahindra Logan may be the right answer too regards

20th February 2007, 10:48	#9 (permalink)
benbsb29 Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Bans-galore Posts: 3,631 View My Garage	Since rear seat comfort is a priority, u could go for the Ikon Flair, which comes in at 5.49L on road Bangalore. Among the best in terms of rear seat comfort, dated looks which still manage to thrill and among the best in terms of handling. Since maintenance and resale have been given lower priorities according to you, my suggestion for the same. Please let me know if u have any further queries on the same. While there are people who advise against Ford, there any people who love their Fords' too. __________________ "You can discover what your enemy fears most by observing the means he uses to frighten you." - Eric Hoffer

20th February 2007, 11:30	#10 (permalink)
sumitsingh BHPian Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Noida Posts: 123 View My Garage	Since according to you, your father is pretty comfortable with the Tata Indica according to the size and comfort. I think going for the Indigo might be a better option given you have a budget for it. Its Diesel, has good back seat comfort and will be easy to maintain given the cost of the spares plus you get a boot at premium hatchback prices. As others have suggested, if you can wait for a while, wait for the Logan to launch. If nothing else, it will enable you to get some more discounts for the Indigo since that is the car that might be most hit on the launch of the Logan. Hope I have added more to your confusion. -Sumit __________________ " For Some, Its a Wheel, For me, Its the World "

20th February 2007, 11:35	#11 (permalink)
Steeroid Senior - BHPian Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: N.A Posts: 6,029	Indigo diesel is a good idea considering his requirements. I wouldnt recommend a Swift for someone who is going to be occupying the rear seat most of the time. Maintenance costs on an Indica/go are not high at all if the vehicle is well maintained periodically. Ask for extended warranty. __________________ It is no measure of health to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society. - J Krishnamurti

20th February 2007, 11:39	#12 (permalink)
normally_crazy Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Mumbai Posts: 3,768 View My Garage	Its a no brainer pal, Indigo Diesel - eyes closed. __________________ In the end there are 3 things that last: faith, hope and love; and the greatest of these is love.

20th February 2007, 11:46	#13 (permalink)
esteem_lover Senior - BHPian Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: Madras Posts: 6,266 View My Garage	Why not the Ikon flair ? far better than the indigo & certainly not a lottery. It is quite a proven car in India too. __________________ "Keep your friends close, Keep your enemies closer"

20th February 2007, 11:50	#14 (permalink)
sajo BHPian Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Pune/Memphis Posts: 970	Indigo DICOR. Go for the LS/LX. The SX simply costs too much, IMHO. Petrol is not worth buying (unless the DOHC is made available). __________________ Its big, slow, thirsty and American - but love is strange!

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
100 BHP+ Diesel Sedan under 10 lakhs - Booked Verna CRDI SX (ABS), now under 9 lakhs	newcoolgadgets	Sedans	84	16th September 2009 22:28
Statistics! Wheelbase, Rear seat legroom and boot space of all Indian cars <25 lakhs	jessie007	The Indian Car Scene	33	11th July 2009 01:04
Do bigger wheels mean better comfort	ritz830	The Indian Car Scene	25	13th December 2008 14:06
Santro vs. WagonR - only on comfort/space	Neeraj Dabake	Hatchbacks	59	25th February 2008 19:15
Handling & Comfort	LandCruiser	The Indian Car Scene	16	14th June 2006 09:45