Indica or Santro/WagonR ? - Team-BHP

DCEite · 29th January 2005, 20:30

Hi.
One of my uncle is planning to buy a new B segment car... he has shortlisted the following:
Hyundai Santro
Maruti WagonR
Tata Indica (diesel)

daily usage: about 55 km (city+highway)

Being an owner of a WagonR myself i have actually recommended him the Indica... since after using the wagonr for about 1 year i dont think that its performance is miles ahead of Indica/Santro....
Also Indica has the advantage of having a diesel engine and its spacious and comfortable inside..(with lots of tiny little features like internally adjustable OVRM etc. etc.)...

but the flip side of Indica as far as i have heard is its high maintainance....(after all, how many pre-v2 indicas you see on road)...
is it true that engine life of WagonR/Santro is way ahead of Indica??..
And if at all Indica is better, which model is the best in terms of value for money?..

lamborghini · 29th January 2005, 20:56

well i would sugest an indica for your uncle
he drives enough to justify a diesel. the indica is a bit problematic but nothing too much.. the usual. besides i had a pre V2 indica and it gave no problem and tatas is improving its quality too ..
i suggest you wait for the indica turbo.
not only will your uncle be saving the environment, he will enjoy the experience

normally_crazy · 29th January 2005, 20:59

well as you say Indica has better space inside and is a diesel . and if ur looking for FE as a parameter then the Indica makes sense. maintainence i dont know maybe some indica owners mite help out.

but the car i suggest wud be the santro . i have lived with it for 3 years and believe me the car is the most comfortable and sensible city car available today. it is a bit cramped compared to the indica and the rear seat comfort isnt that great. FE is arnd 12 kmpl and hyundai service is absolute peace of mind .

and abt wagon r - well u have recommended the indica inspite of owning a wagon r , so i guess thats out of the question !

cheers

sridhar24 · 29th January 2005, 21:25

I would also suggest him to wait for the CRDi Santro if it is going to be launched soon.

SLK · 30th January 2005, 04:16

Quote:

Originally Posted by dceite

Being an owner of a WagonR myself i have actually recommended him the Indica... since after using the wagonr for about 1 year i dont think that its performance is miles ahead of Indica/Santro....

ok.. not miles ahead of santro... but i guess its a few light years ahead of a diesel indica!

though Indica makes more sense in this scenario for other reasons!

Stratos · 30th January 2005, 10:40

As u asked about the model.. going for the diesel version of the Indica... u can go for the DLS or the DLG...in the DLG u get front power windows where as u dont get them in the DLS. These is no point in paying 20-30 thousand more for the topend model.

Secondly..I had an Indica V2, 2002 model DLE. I dont understand..why many people believe diesels need heavy maintainence. If you drive properly, dont mess up with the car...there is no way it will ever let u spend unecessarily from ur pocket.

DCEite · 30th January 2005, 10:46

so when is the Indica Turbo coming??.. sure that would equal santro/wagonr in terms of performance....
and how come a Turbo Charger make it more eco friendly..??.. i thought CRDI was the only way for diesel cars to fight EIII norms....

29th January 2005, 20:30	#1 (permalink)
DCEite Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Sep 2004 Location: Gurgaon Posts: 2,187 View My Garage	Indica or Santro/WagonR ? Hi. One of my uncle is planning to buy a new B segment car... he has shortlisted the following: Hyundai Santro Maruti WagonR Tata Indica (diesel) daily usage: about 55 km (city+highway) Being an owner of a WagonR myself i have actually recommended him the Indica... since after using the wagonr for about 1 year i dont think that its performance is miles ahead of Indica/Santro.... Also Indica has the advantage of having a diesel engine and its spacious and comfortable inside..(with lots of tiny little features like internally adjustable OVRM etc. etc.)... but the flip side of Indica as far as i have heard is its high maintainance....(after all, how many pre-v2 indicas you see on road)... is it true that engine life of WagonR/Santro is way ahead of Indica??.. And if at all Indica is better, which model is the best in terms of value for money?..

29th January 2005, 20:56	#2 (permalink)
lamborghini Senior - BHPian Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Mumbai/RI, USA Posts: 3,064 View My Garage	well i would sugest an indica for your uncle he drives enough to justify a diesel. the indica is a bit problematic but nothing too much.. the usual. besides i had a pre V2 indica and it gave no problem and tatas is improving its quality too .. i suggest you wait for the indica turbo. not only will your uncle be saving the environment, he will enjoy the experience __________________ ¢нєєяѕ ℓαмвσ

29th January 2005, 20:59	#3 (permalink)
normally_crazy Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Mumbai Posts: 3,768 View My Garage	well as you say Indica has better space inside and is a diesel . and if ur looking for FE as a parameter then the Indica makes sense. maintainence i dont know maybe some indica owners mite help out. but the car i suggest wud be the santro . i have lived with it for 3 years and believe me the car is the most comfortable and sensible city car available today. it is a bit cramped compared to the indica and the rear seat comfort isnt that great. FE is arnd 12 kmpl and hyundai service is absolute peace of mind . and abt wagon r - well u have recommended the indica inspite of owning a wagon r , so i guess thats out of the question ! cheers __________________ In the end there are 3 things that last: faith, hope and love; and the greatest of these is love.

29th January 2005, 21:25	#4 (permalink)
sridhar24 BHPian Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Bengaluru Posts: 858 View My Garage	I would also suggest him to wait for the CRDi Santro if it is going to be launched soon. __________________ Bajaj Pulsar 200 DTSi Hyundai Verna SX ABS

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
First car - Santro/WagonR/Alto/Estilo/Indica/Getz Prime/Spark/Palio 1.1/i10	simonkayar	Hatchbacks	191	13th June 2009 13:21
which one is better santro or wagonr	zenopio	Test-Drives & Initial Ownership Reports	9	14th August 2007 01:24
Used WagonR or Santro	nicejits	Modifications & Accessories	0	14th April 2007 15:37
WagonR v/s Santro v/s Indica	DCEite	The Indian Car Scene	96	12th February 2007 16:43
Used Car : Santro or WagonR	winlotwin	Hatchbacks	21	29th November 2006 11:20

30th January 2005, 10:40	#6 (permalink)
Stratos Team-BHP Support Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: San Jose, CA - Mumbai, MH Posts: 1,937 View My Garage	As u asked about the model.. going for the diesel version of the Indica... u can go for the DLS or the DLG...in the DLG u get front power windows where as u dont get them in the DLS. These is no point in paying 20-30 thousand more for the topend model. Secondly..I had an Indica V2, 2002 model DLE. I dont understand..why many people believe diesels need heavy maintainence. If you drive properly, dont mess up with the car...there is no way it will ever let u spend unecessarily from ur pocket.

30th January 2005, 10:46	#7 (permalink)
DCEite Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Sep 2004 Location: Gurgaon Posts: 2,187 View My Garage	so when is the Indica Turbo coming??.. sure that would equal santro/wagonr in terms of performance.... and how come a Turbo Charger make it more eco friendly..??.. i thought CRDI was the only way for diesel cars to fight EIII norms....