| || ||Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|30th August 2006, 17:20||#16|
Join Date: Jan 2005
Thanked: 0 Times
CNG cannot be transported like LPG ..it needs high pressure to store and so the gauge of the metal used for the tanks has to be thick ..it may be cheaper but its not easily available throughout the country.
Morever,the initial investment is about 50 % more as compared to LPG kits .
A 50 liter LPG tank can contain 40 liters LPG (80%) and can easily fit into the boot of a small car ,but for CNG an equally sized tank can hold only 10-12 liters.Due to this its more suited for bigger vehicles
IOC,BPCL ,HP and reliance ...all have LPG filling stations in almost all major cities.
|31st August 2006, 05:55||#17|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Jan 2006
Thanked: 49 Times
|31st August 2006, 11:47||#18|
Join Date: Feb 2005
Thanked: 11 Times
Check the table for maintenance costs. It says CNG causes 30% increase in maintenance vs LPG which reduces maintencance costs by 5%.
"A comparative study of the two gas-based fuels vis-à-vis diesel and petrol shows that LPG gains over CNG on several counts. The impact on greenhouse emissions is considerably less than other fossil fuels when measured through the total fuel cycle. Moreover, for the same volume, LPG requires a tank that is one-third the size of a CNG tank. LPG is a clean burning, high octane, environment friendly fuel. It generates no smoke or fumes and emits extremely low levels of Carbon Monoxide, Hydrocarbons and Nitrogen Oxides. It emits virtually no sulphur oxides and no particulate matter, a highly placed source in the industry said.
Vehicles that run on CNG experience a reduction in engine power by up to 20 percent, primarily due to gas carburettors. On the other hand, LPG can be used in a way similar to diesel, with liquid sequential multi point fuel injection (MPFI), say experts. In a normal CNG tank, with the reduction of quantity, engine power comes down significantly. So, to maintain engine power at optimum levels, pressure-creating systems are installed, which leads to the increase in conversion cost."
"LPG is acknowledged all over the world as an alternate fuel for Automobiles superior to conventional Gasoline/CNG."
|31st August 2006, 14:12||#19|
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: New Delhi
Thanked: 226 Times
Look at price tag please!!! Only 2 cars come with LPG...Omni and WagonR...Why?? Because the target customers are highly price sensitive. What will CNG WagonR cost? 4.25 Lakhs!! the customers will run away as they will have more options to choose from. Also Maruti is aggressively perusing Rural Market where LPG is (or may be "Will be") available.
PS: Dont go into technicals as we have already discussed it many times in other threads. Lets discuss WHY do some Companies choose CNG and others LPG
|3rd September 2006, 14:55||#21|
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: New Delhi
Thanked: 14 Times
@ boom, That site is has inaccurate DATA, suggest you visit Bedini,Landi Renzo or Nugas Websites along with Nugas group run by guys in Thailand,Singapore,Malayasia.
CNG is the most abundant source of fuel available on earth as of now, It is simply Methane Gas. LPG is artifically created and was initially considerd a waste and burned off at refinery..! LPG prices are influenced by Petrol, Since it is created by the same crude oil.
Most manufactures across the globe promote CNG over LPG, For its availability,Economy and Lower emission.
CNG network in India is growing-GAIL,IGL and all are investing crores into CNG. The reason why I feel the Auto company are slow in adopting CNG is that Petrol Consumption will go way down and Oil Companies influence the Manufacturer + Since CNG is a cleaner fuel and enables the Oil to stick on the engine and piston during startups and running, will eventually lead to a lower spares usage. TATA,GM,Hyundai,HM-Mitsubishi,Ford are all moving in the right future...Save for Maruti, which will remain the only odd one out in the Alternate Fuel War.
Maruti's Omni Cargo was intially CNG, But they had some major issues so they went to LPG mode and This is the same now for Wagon R.
Currently-Delhi,Mumbai,Agra,Some Cities in Gujrat are on CNG..Not sure of some more cities.
In Delhi, Auto Gas LPG pumps are hardly 10 or less, compared with CNG stations numbering 30 + all over town, Since CNG was made madatory for All Public Transports in Delhi...You'll find a Pump almost everywhere..3 Pumps in Noida and 2 in Gurgaon. So NCR is fairly covered...this is growing network.
CNG has made the Air in delhi much much better compared with Diesal and Petrol times earlier and stricter emmision norms are improving things.
CNG also qualifies for Tax Concessions in many EU nations. ( I read this on some CNG-LPG site)
Current Rate is CNG-Rs.19.20 / Per Kg, LPG-Rs.27.8+-/Per Ltr.
Last edited by wolfinstein : 3rd September 2006 at 15:04.
|Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Why do pumps mix LPG with CNG occasionally?||chetanthaker||Technical Stuff||19||22nd July 2015 18:06|
|Contrast between Sagar Automobiles, Bannerghatta Road and RNS Motors Hosur Road,Blor||maveric20987||Indian Car Dealerships||9||10th May 2012 16:47|
|Why we don't get factory fitted CNG / LPG kits in India?||mrkanitkar||The Indian Car Scene||21||10th January 2010 22:03|
|Scratches....Why are they always in contrast colors?||visu03||Technical Stuff||18||28th February 2008 09:31|