Maruti SX4 or Honda Civic - Team-BHP

coolmob · 11th June 2007, 15:36

hi everyone

first of all i would like to say that this is the best car forum i have found on the net. the information on it abt the indian car scene is simply awesome

now to my question..

i know i am trying to compare a C segment car with a D segment car but still i would like your views on my problem

i am planning to buy a new car and my max budget is around 10-11 laks. i have selected two cars ie Maruti SX4 and Honda Civic. now the two of them are ploes apart in price and category but still i am considering SX4 as it offers quite a lot of features that are available only in a D segment car.

my daily driving is around 60-70 kms and i mainly drive in congested areas. so i am confused between the civic and sx4 on the issue of ease of handling in congested areas and the fuel effiiency. i know my driving is not much but since its gonna be in a lot of traffic so if the fuel efficiency turns out to be quite low, it wont be feasible for me to drive the car daily.

i currently have honda city zx, maruti esteem and hyundai santro and they all give me above 10 FE in these conditions

so guyz please help.....

Jaggu · 11th June 2007, 20:05

sx4 for better peace of mind (cheaper car ok with scratch and dents) and better fe when you drive in a crowded area as you mentioned, civic anyday otherwise no comparison here lol

suman · 11th June 2007, 20:07

Since you've chosen two that are poles apart in price & category, add to the fun and bang in a third one here - try the new Optra Magnum Diesel

mclaren1885 · 11th June 2007, 20:08

Why dont you request the mods to add a poll? That way you will have a clear cut answer.

BUSA · 11th June 2007, 20:09

I would say Civic, its in a different category alltogether and quality is much better then the SX4

scarlet.fever · 11th June 2007, 20:16

Its a no brainer Civic is miles ahead of SX4.
Although since you will driving in congested areas sx4 would suit you better between the two of them.
Since you will be driving 60-70 km daily why don't you consider buying a diesel car like Fiesta etc.

shankaranand · 11th June 2007, 20:17

Why not try Optra Diesel.

It has excellent torque. Great safety features. Good Handling and above all great fuel efficiency/ status factor and all.

60/70 km in a day is lot of driving and I suggest you try out Octy/Optra Diesel.

supremeBaleno · 11th June 2007, 21:14

Man, a comparo between the SX4 and the Civic. Hmmm.

While I love Suzuki cars, if I were planning to spend 11-12lakhs on a car, I dont think i would be even thinking of the SX4 - ICE controls on the wheel and bigger wheels be damned. I would think no further than the Civic. Not because its a costly car, but because its an awesome car for the money spent - no wonder you see scores of them on the street.

And yes, I would take it only in black (the pain of keeping it clean be damned) - that car is one hell of a looker in black.

OT: Dont know why, but I kind of have this gut feel that this is not a genuine "what car?" query. I might be wrong too.

rdas45 · 11th June 2007, 21:23

Ofcourse the Honda Civic, AT paddle shift. Great Car with great resale value and plus looks better than the SX4

1100D · 11th June 2007, 21:24

I read your query more as a question regarding what segment car you could buy rather than a choice between SX4 and Civic.

If I read it wrong, can you say what attribute of the SX4 makes it appear to you that it is a competitor to the Civic?

coolmob · 11th June 2007, 22:28

well as i mentioned in my post the reason i choose sx4 for comparison with civic was that with sx4 we are geting a trusted brand(maruti), and features that are present only in the D segment cars.

now when it comes to comfort fi and finish.... we all can judge that by lookin at the segment itself. there would be a difference but then we have to compromise somewhere or the other. both cars have their +ve n -ve points.

dont know why since civic is my first love

i am still inclining towards getting a sx4(strange)!!! i change cars at around 2 yrs interval and somehow after buying civic my family wont allow me to buy another for another 4-5 yrs!! on top of that from the 4lac that i will save by buying a sx4 i can mod it to my hearts content which wont be a possibility for me to do with civic.

another thing i have heard from 2 of my frnds who have civic is that if u drive it in real congested areas or at extreme high speeds, it wont give FE of above 8!!! if anyone can confirm it then im gettin sx4.

and mods i request you to please add a poll between sx4 and civic

1100D · 11th June 2007, 23:53

Civic (just by virtue of it being a D segment car, as compared to C segment that SX4 belongs to) is a better car , period.

Whatever advantages you are thinking SX4 has over Civic is due to the fact that the SX4 belongs to a smaller segment (and hence dont count). So first finalize what category of a car you want to buy (or is it that you want help regarding choosing the category itself)..

TRANSAM · 12th June 2007, 11:17

civic for looks & status, for practical purposes and a few lacs stashed away in the bank, the sx4 zxi

Dippy · 12th June 2007, 11:23

Poll added to the thread

toiingg · 12th June 2007, 11:40

Civic all the way. Theres just something about Hondas which make you fall in love with them.

View Poll Results: Which to buy
Maruti SX4	20	21.28%
Honda Civic	74	78.72%
Voters: 94. You may not vote on this poll

11th June 2007, 15:36	#1 (permalink)
coolmob Newbie Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: New Delhi Posts: 29	Maruti SX4 or Honda Civic hi everyone first of all i would like to say that this is the best car forum i have found on the net. the information on it abt the indian car scene is simply awesome now to my question.. i know i am trying to compare a C segment car with a D segment car but still i would like your views on my problem i am planning to buy a new car and my max budget is around 10-11 laks. i have selected two cars ie Maruti SX4 and Honda Civic. now the two of them are ploes apart in price and category but still i am considering SX4 as it offers quite a lot of features that are available only in a D segment car. my daily driving is around 60-70 kms and i mainly drive in congested areas. so i am confused between the civic and sx4 on the issue of ease of handling in congested areas and the fuel effiiency. i know my driving is not much but since its gonna be in a lot of traffic so if the fuel efficiency turns out to be quite low, it wont be feasible for me to drive the car daily. i currently have honda city zx, maruti esteem and hyundai santro and they all give me above 10 FE in these conditions so guyz please help.....

11th June 2007, 20:05	#2 (permalink)
Jaggu Team-BHP Moderator Join Date: May 2004 Location: Bangalore Posts: 3,633	sx4 for better peace of mind (cheaper car ok with scratch and dents) and better fe when you drive in a crowded area as you mentioned, civic anyday otherwise no comparison here lol __________________ The strength to change what I can, the inability to accept what I can't, and the incapacity to tell the difference. -Calvin

11th June 2007, 20:08	#4 (permalink)
mclaren1885 Senior - BHPian Join Date: Jul 2005 Location: Bangalore (the city of modded cars) !! Posts: 3,796 View My Garage	Why dont you request the mods to add a poll? That way you will have a clear cut answer. __________________ I am proud of you, binzy boy !!! Keep up the good work.

11th June 2007, 20:09	#5 (permalink)
BUSA Senior - BHPian Join Date: Aug 2005 Location: Bombay Posts: 5,066 View My Garage	I would say Civic, its in a different category alltogether and quality is much better then the SX4 __________________ thecarsandmore.blogspot. com

11th June 2007, 20:07	#3 (permalink)
suman Senior - BHPian Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Gurgaon Posts: 2,093 View My Garage	Since you've chosen two that are poles apart in price & category, add to the fun and bang in a third one here - try the new Optra Magnum Diesel

11th June 2007, 20:16	#6 (permalink)
scarlet.fever BHPian Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: New Delhi/Gurgaon Posts: 72	Its a no brainer Civic is miles ahead of SX4. Although since you will driving in congested areas sx4 would suit you better between the two of them. Since you will be driving 60-70 km daily why don't you consider buying a diesel car like Fiesta etc. __________________ My Heart Will Die, My Soul Will Fly AND I Will Live FOREVER

11th June 2007, 20:17	#7 (permalink)
shankaranand BHPian Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Bangalore Posts: 100	Why not try Optra Diesel. It has excellent torque. Great safety features. Good Handling and above all great fuel efficiency/ status factor and all. 60/70 km in a day is lot of driving and I suggest you try out Octy/Optra Diesel.

11th June 2007, 21:14	#8 (permalink)
supremeBaleno Senior - BHPian Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: Weekdays at DetroitOfIndia (Chennai) & Weekends at VeniceOfTheEast (Alappuzha). Posts: 1,927 View My Garage	Man, a comparo between the SX4 and the Civic. Hmmm. While I love Suzuki cars, if I were planning to spend 11-12lakhs on a car, I dont think i would be even thinking of the SX4 - ICE controls on the wheel and bigger wheels be damned. I would think no further than the Civic. Not because its a costly car, but because its an awesome car for the money spent - no wonder you see scores of them on the street. And yes, I would take it only in black (the pain of keeping it clean be damned) - that car is one hell of a looker in black. OT: Dont know why, but I kind of have this gut feel that this is not a genuine "what car?" query. I might be wrong too. __________________ Give time a break - be a part of the Chennai-tbhp drive to Pondy. Check out the "Rendez-vouz at Pondichery" thread for details.

11th June 2007, 21:23	#9 (permalink)
rdas45 BHPian Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Mumbai Posts: 70	Ofcourse the Honda Civic, AT paddle shift. Great Car with great resale value and plus looks better than the SX4

11th June 2007, 21:24	#10 (permalink)
1100D Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: Calcutta Posts: 2,332 View My Garage	I read your query more as a question regarding what segment car you could buy rather than a choice between SX4 and Civic. If I read it wrong, can you say what attribute of the SX4 makes it appear to you that it is a competitor to the Civic? __________________ ________________________ Every Ferrari is always a Fiat

11th June 2007, 22:28	#11 (permalink)
coolmob Newbie Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: New Delhi Posts: 29	well as i mentioned in my post the reason i choose sx4 for comparison with civic was that with sx4 we are geting a trusted brand(maruti), and features that are present only in the D segment cars. now when it comes to comfort fi and finish.... we all can judge that by lookin at the segment itself. there would be a difference but then we have to compromise somewhere or the other. both cars have their +ve n -ve points. dont know why since civic is my first love i am still inclining towards getting a sx4(strange)!!! i change cars at around 2 yrs interval and somehow after buying civic my family wont allow me to buy another for another 4-5 yrs!! on top of that from the 4lac that i will save by buying a sx4 i can mod it to my hearts content which wont be a possibility for me to do with civic. another thing i have heard from 2 of my frnds who have civic is that if u drive it in real congested areas or at extreme high speeds, it wont give FE of above 8!!! if anyone can confirm it then im gettin sx4. and mods i request you to please add a poll between sx4 and civic

11th June 2007, 23:53	#12 (permalink)
1100D Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: Calcutta Posts: 2,332 View My Garage	Civic (just by virtue of it being a D segment car, as compared to C segment that SX4 belongs to) is a better car , period. Whatever advantages you are thinking SX4 has over Civic is due to the fact that the SX4 belongs to a smaller segment (and hence dont count). So first finalize what category of a car you want to buy (or is it that you want help regarding choosing the category itself).. __________________ ________________________ Every Ferrari is always a Fiat

12th June 2007, 11:17	#13 (permalink)
TRANSAM BHPian Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: MUMBAI Posts: 194	civic for looks & status, for practical purposes and a few lacs stashed away in the bank, the sx4 zxi

12th June 2007, 11:23	#14 (permalink)
Dippy Team-BHP Moderator Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Mumbai, India Posts: 4,495 View My Garage	*Poll added to the thread* __________________ My name is Adrian Sutil. You can call me ADDY - Force India dippy@team-bhp.com

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
TD of SX4, Civic, Octavia, Cedia and Verna-D	rrnsss	Test-Drives & Initial Ownership Reports	47	6th January 2008 23:34
Maruti SX4 ZXi or Honda City GXi	yousivakutti	Sedans	63	17th December 2007 09:07
Did AutocarIndia intentionally lie about august sales of the Honda City/Maruti SX4	rahul_intlad	The Indian Car Scene!!	8	27th September 2007 08:08
Maruti launching SX4?	directinjection	The Indian Car Scene!!	58	21st March 2007 12:14

12th June 2007, 11:40	#15 (permalink)
toiingg BHPian Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: Calcutta Posts: 332 View My Garage	Civic all the way. Theres just something about Hondas which make you fall in love with them. __________________ Sarvagya