SWIFT DZIRE v/s INDIGO v/s ACCENT v/s LOGAN, - Page 2 - Team-BHP

reignofchaos · 26th March 2008, 13:58

The side profile of the Dzire looks yuck. However if it can retain the swift driving dynamics, my vote would be the dzire.

srishiva · 26th March 2008, 14:03

For the equipment level and driving, its dzire for me.

karanraheja · 26th March 2008, 14:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by reignofchaos

The side profile of the Dzire looks yuck. However if it can retain the swift driving dynamics, my vote would be the dzire.

Totally agree with you ! From side angle its weird. But i guess we will get used to it. From the reviews i heard rear seat comfort in Dzire is improved but not enough for a sedan so that could be one of the drawbacks . But all in all Dzire wins hands down!

speedzak · 26th March 2008, 14:10

My preference would be as follows.

1. Swift dZire. (Everybody knows why!)
2. TATA Indigo.
3. Accent.
4. Logan.

Logan looks the worst of the lot according to me. Dzire is just a matter of time before we get used to the boot design.

Good that this poll closes on April 2nd. Because, there'll be soon an avalanche of discounts in the entire car scene below 8L. Then we should start a fresh visit to the market again.

nitinchawla · 26th March 2008, 14:14

This poll is not right. You are trying to compare 3 proven cars against one which has only looks to show for it and maybe a couple of test drives. Obviously, the newness of the Dzire or say the curiosity associated with the Dzire will make it the poll leader. Rightfully, wait for 4-5 months before this poll is done. That will be fair comparison when all parameters can be compared.

I am still keenly following the Logan vs. Accent vs. Indigo debate

rockyheights · 26th March 2008, 14:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by speedzak

My preference would be as follows.

1. Swift dZire. (Everybody knows why!)
2. TATA Indigo.
3. Accent.
4. Logan.

Logan looks the worst of the lot according to me. Dzire is just a matter of time before we get used to the boot design.

Good that this poll closes on April 2nd. Because, there'll be soon an avalanche of discounts in the entire car scene below 8L. Then we should start a fresh visit to the market again.

You stole words from my mouth ..err..keyboard! Fully agree!

Eddy · 26th March 2008, 14:22

Quote:

Originally Posted by speedzak

Dzire is just a matter of time before we get used to the boot design.

I still think that it is the front that will need getting-used-to. The rear is fine. The front does not match the sedan looks

tez · 26th March 2008, 14:29

dzire gets my vote for sheer VFM. Nitin, there is nothing changed in dzire except addition of a boot. The handling, engine etc are of Swift which is tried and tested. Looks get the last priority IMHO

supremeBaleno · 26th March 2008, 14:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eddy

I still think that it is the front that will need getting-used-to. The rear is fine. The front does not match the sedan looks

I agree. I like the way the rear has come about. Was expecting it to be a disaster like the Indigo, which fortunately it isn't.

mezereo · 26th March 2008, 14:35

My vote for the DZIRE. They did a good job with the rear

.

mjothi · 26th March 2008, 14:56

Voted for DZire. 2 good reason is - proven DDiS engine & ofcourse Maruti A.S.S...

revved_up · 26th March 2008, 15:14

Voted for Dzire, only because of it is VFM.
Looks, I think people will get used to.

But yeah, if Logan sees a price cut and Mahindra throws in some goodies (like ABS and all) , then its going to be a tough fight.

Swaroop77 · 26th March 2008, 15:24

VFM Logan will definitely take a beating, heard that they are planning to or have announced price cuts.

CrAzY dRiVeR · 26th March 2008, 15:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by speedzak

My preference would be as follows.
1. Swift dZire. (Everybody knows why!)
2. TATA Indigo.
3. Accent.

Mine would be-
1. Swift DZIRE.
2. TATA Indigo CS (CS specifically as i feel indigo may be taken off when new one comes, and only CS may continue in the market)
3. Logan.
4. Ford ikon/ Accent.

Quote:

Originally Posted by nitinchawla

This poll is not right. You are trying to compare 3 proven cars against one which has only looks to show for it and maybe a couple of test drives.

The mechanicals are all proven in the hatch. What is there to test in the sedan? (Other than whether the boot would fall off!

)

kpbhatt · 26th March 2008, 15:43

have an Indigo for the last 1 year and have found it pretty good in all respects that matter most to me as a user -- have voted for it -- the Dzire is not on my wishlist

View Poll Results: swift dzire v/s indigo v/s logan v/s accent
accent	13	8.02%
indigo	17	10.49%
dzire	109	67.28%
logan	23	14.20%
Voters: 162. You may not vote on this poll

26th March 2008, 14:10	#19 (permalink)
speedzak Senior - BHPian Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Ernakulam, Cochin. It'll soon be at the Deserts! Posts: 3,457 View My Garage	My preference would be as follows. 1. Swift dZire. (Everybody knows why!) 2. TATA Indigo. 3. Accent. 4. Logan. Logan looks the worst of the lot according to me. Dzire is just a matter of time before we get used to the boot design. Good that this poll closes on April 2nd. Because, there'll be soon an avalanche of discounts in the entire car scene below 8L. Then we should start a fresh visit to the market again. __________________ The squeaking wheel doesn't always get the grease. Sometimes it gets replaced!!

26th March 2008, 14:14	#20 (permalink)
nitinchawla Newbie Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: New Delhi Posts: 28	Not the right poll This poll is not right. You are trying to compare 3 proven cars against one which has only looks to show for it and maybe a couple of test drives. Obviously, the newness of the Dzire or say the curiosity associated with the Dzire will make it the poll leader. Rightfully, wait for 4-5 months before this poll is done. That will be fair comparison when all parameters can be compared. I am still keenly following the Logan vs. Accent vs. Indigo debate

26th March 2008, 14:35	#25 (permalink)
mezereo BHPian Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: AP29, AP36 Posts: 95 View My Garage	My vote for the DZIRE. They did a good job with the rear . __________________ Devil in Disguise

26th March 2008, 14:56	#26 (permalink)
mjothi BHPian Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Bangalore Posts: 737	Voted for DZire. 2 good reason is - proven DDiS engine & ofcourse Maruti A.S.S... __________________ Sometimes I Win; Other times I Learn, I NEVER loose. --- Aveo 1.4 LS Special Edition Honda Activa Zen LXi, RX100, RX135 (Sold)

26th March 2008, 13:58	#16 (permalink)
reignofchaos Senior - BHPian Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Bangalore Posts: 1,008 View My Garage	The side profile of the Dzire looks yuck. However if it can retain the swift driving dynamics, my vote would be the dzire.

26th March 2008, 14:03	#17 (permalink)
srishiva BHPian Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Bangalore Posts: 707	For the equipment level and driving, its dzire for me.

26th March 2008, 14:29	#23 (permalink)
tez BHPian Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: pune Posts: 227	dzire gets my vote for sheer VFM. Nitin, there is nothing changed in dzire except addition of a boot. The handling, engine etc are of Swift which is tried and tested. Looks get the last priority IMHO

26th March 2008, 15:14	#27 (permalink)
revved_up BHPian Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: New Delhi Posts: 299 View My Garage	Voted for Dzire, only because of it is VFM. Looks, I think people will get used to. But yeah, if Logan sees a price cut and Mahindra throws in some goodies (like ABS and all) , then its going to be a tough fight.

26th March 2008, 15:24	#28 (permalink)
Swaroop77 Newbie Join Date: Jan 2008 Location: Mumbai Posts: 22	VFM Logan will definitely take a beating, heard that they are planning to or have announced price cuts.

26th March 2008, 15:43	#30 (permalink)
kpbhatt BHPian Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Pune\ Mumbai Posts: 143 View My Garage	have an Indigo for the last 1 year and have found it pretty good in all respects that matter most to me as a user -- have voted for it -- the Dzire is not on my wishlist __________________ ------------------------ 1991 Ford Taurus 1992 Honda Accord 1999 Plymouth Grand Voyager 2004 Tata Indigo

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Swift Dzire - Short test drive and some pictures	Eddy	Test-Drives & Initial Ownership Reports	262	25th July 2008 16:46
Swift DZire prices!	iTNerd	The Indian Car Scene!!	140	31st March 2008 11:51
Maruti Swift Dzire Website is Online!	newcoolgadgets	The Indian Car Scene!!	3	25th March 2008 10:40
Petrol Vs. Diesel (Swift Dzire)	sudhirlp	Hatchbacks	12	24th March 2008 17:25
Renault Logan or a SWIFT	Vicks	Hatchbacks	21	5th September 2007 14:48