| || ||Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|6th December 2009, 15:47||#46|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Aberdeen, UK
Thanked: 1,127 Times
China is a cheap manufacturing destination, no doubt. When one buys an ipod or a SonyEricsson thats made in China, one relies on the brand and not the nation to provide back up. People place trust in the manufacturer, their experience, their technology, and not the Chinese army to come and get things fixed. There are reputed Chinese brands no doubt but largely China is the worlds production line.
When Tata bought JLR, they kept faith in the company, assured they will try to retain as much workforce as possible, invested in the firm, brought out the like of the brilliant XF, XJ and soon the LRX. There was a lot of discomfort when they did take over, but Tata have now earned the trust of JLR fans worldwide.
The Chinese have also purchased foriegn car firms:
This gave the Chinese makers a free reign to photocopy established car designs (literally copy them as they are, not inspiration), spend nothing on R&D, make them in huge volumes to a huge protected car market and sell them cheap.
The likes of Tata, M&M, Bajaj, TVS spends a huge part of their income into R&D and fight tooth and nail with global car giants on equal footing in the Indian market and globally. They are not directly or indirectly owned and supported by Communist patrons and neither do foreign car companies have to rely on local collabrations to make and sell cars in India.
Open up the Chinese car market, ensure strict copyright laws, lets see who runs for cover then. The Chinese have been trying to export cars since the late 80s and since then there has been a lot of ball talks about how they are the next Japan or Korea of cars. Almost quarter of a century later I am yet to hear about any Chinese brands in any of the established car markets.
Tata and Mahindra are still novices in the global Auto industry, but have made huge strides from the Indica to the Manza, from the Commander to the Scorpio and soon the next generation of vehicles like the Indicruz will be comparable to the best out there.
We are today an export hub especially for small cars and quality auto components for almost all MNCs worth tehir salt. Heck we even export more cars than the Chinkies, despite having a far smaller market than them.
So all that talk about Chinky quality being always better than Indian ones especially in the Auto sector is bull crap.
Our Auto Industry is booming, it employs a huge part of our population, not just in production lines, but thousands of engineers and scientists involved in thorough R&D. They compete on equal footing with the best in the world. What I do not want is our Car market to be a dumping ground for cheap Chinese $h1t.
|7th December 2009, 00:39||#47|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Mar 2008
Thanked: 436 Times
As far as being illogical is concerned, I would like to see you come up with the name of a single (1) Chinese car manufacturer who invests in R&D.
Read the post I have also quoted above. It pretty much explains it all.
|7th December 2009, 08:23||#48|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Feb 2005
Thanked: 686 Times
China's exchange-rate policy: A yuan-sided argument | The Economist
"After developing this kind of highly complex technology, one could no longer regard China as a backward country."
link: Shanghai Y-10 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
|2nd May 2010, 09:44||#50|
Join Date: Mar 2010
Well, I can see that this national rivalry evokes some strong emotions from people on both sides of the debate.
I'm posting an update on the GM-SAIC story since I did not see it come up in a search of the forum.
Chinese carmaker SAIC muscles into GM India board-Automobiles-Auto-News By Industry-News-The Economic Times
A joint MD, equal board representation and more say in operations in GM India. SAIC have made their intentions very clear.
Looking back at the posts, I see a comparison made between this and the JLR-Tata combine. I only differ with the comparison in one respect: GM India is not an iconic brand that is falling to the brash newcomer with bags of money.
This news evoked a fairly strong emotional and patriotic response from me. As previous posters have pointed out - given that China is a manufacturing hub of the world, why should that be the case? I haven't given up buying other products that are made in china, so why now? Is the west any different in how they view India? I didn't restrict my choices to "desi" brands only, but now I feel compelled to exclude GM from the mix.
I have no clear answers. Its not a logical response, but nonetheless, it gives me pause when considering Chevy in my "what car" decision.
The only thing I can say is - all other buying decisions are made with the head, but the car is bought with the heart . "phir bhi dil hai hindustani."
|Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Mahindra acquires 35% stake in Finland's Sampo Rosenlew (manufacturer of farm harvesters)||darklord||Commercial Vehicles||0||31st March 2016 14:54|
|Mahindra acquires controlling stake in Pininfarina||dark.knight||The Indian Car Scene||21||8th February 2016 11:23|
|Hummer brand sold to Chinese manufacturer||Nitin||The International Automotive Scene||4||10th October 2009 07:58|
|MG Rover Sold to Chinese Auto Company!!||Stratos||The International Automotive Scene||6||23rd November 2004 16:52|