Which to sell : Palio Gtx or NHC

[Neel]

Hi,

I will soon be relocating outside india, wish to know your thoughts on which ONE of the following two cars i can sell.

1. NHC GXI : June 2004. First owner: Done about 11K KM. Immaculate condition. Still have a loan to payoff.

2. Palio GTX : Dec 2002 : Second owner but just done 17K KM. It was a company owned car which my brother bought it Jan 2006.

We plan to keep one of the two cars, both have their +ve's and -ve's.
Should i sell the GTX and payoff the NHC Loan or just sell the NHC and close liability (loan).

I am not sure how much i would get for my NHC - any guesses??

-Neel

[jkdas]

If you have a family; NHC I guess. Bachelor: GTX
Also, NHC will give you a better resale value in future too and anyway its a new car.

[zulfikar]

sell GTX...
city is always better...
better resale...
and all the Team-bhp members LOVE CITY AND GTX so say 50-50 is what the answer you will get,....


and one more thing how much are you expecting for GTX and whats the FE you got from her...

[mclaren1885]

Suggest u to sell the the city as it will have a better resale value now .. Selling the GTX wont fetch u anything .. A friend of mine sold his 2002 sienna 1.2 for a mere 83k and with the money he couldnt even do up his baleno properly as he wished to in the 1st place .. The GTX will not fetch u anything more than 1.3-1.5L in this part of the world , coupled to it the rumours about the horrendous FIAT service didnt help either .. Now that tata has taken over the service i guess its a wise decision to keep the GTX it being a true enthusiasts car .. Its that car which will always bring a smile on ones face , quite unlike the NHC..

[iraghava]

I completely agree with mclaren you would get a very good resale for the NHC and you could close the liability. If you sell the GTX it simply won't be worth it.

[nitrous]

Ditch the NHC,bro.
Since u'll use the car rarely and FE won't be a concern. Sell the NHC off.
U'll save a lot of money.

[maxbhp]

Originally Posted by mclaren1885

Suggest u to sell the the city as it will have a better resale value now .. Selling the GTX wont fetch u anything .. A friend of mine sold his 2002 sienna 1.2 for a mere 83k and with the money he couldnt even do up his baleno properly as he wished to in the 1st place .. The GTX will not fetch u anything more than 1.3-1.5L in this part of the world , coupled to it the rumours about the horrendous FIAT service didnt help either .. Now that tata has taken over the service i guess its a wise decision to keep the GTX it being a true enthusiasts car .. Its that car which will always bring a smile on ones face , quite unlike the NHC..

, YOur palio has run just 17K and for that you are loosing more than 300000lacs, so keep it .......ditch the NHC coz when it comes to actual driving pleasure I guess...NHC is way way out of Palio1.6 GTX's league. Now if you are trying to be practical again its 50:50 choice.

[devarshi84]

Palio is an extremely good car and you wouldnt really get its worth if you sell it. Additionally you are a second owner.

sell the NHC and get a good resale out of it.

[Minardi]

sell NHC............

[goldie_malhotra]

if u r thinking of selling the GTX to foreclose your NHC loan - forget it, you wont get peanuts for what its worth

you should get around 5-6L for the NHC, compared to just 1-1.5L for the GTX

[v1p3r]

Originally Posted by maxbhp

YOur palio has run just 17K and for that you are loosing more than 300000lacs, so keep it

Now that's depreciation!!!

[dipen]

Whos gonna remain in India from yr family ? anD, who willl be driving the car ?
If its yr mom /dad driving it ? Keep the City. After ALL, ALL That U would except ( for them) is peaceful ownership experiece. Also the city would be more comfortable to drive for your parents. Again by selling off yr city , You would lose close to 3 laks than yr paid MRP. DEPRECIATION

Selling of Palio would fetch you peanuts , but I am sure U too must have bought it for peanuts.