minor accident in my x5. help needed - Team-BHP

x5india · 18th July 2009, 18:16

guys,

i've had a small collision. please see pics here:
Name: x1.jpg
Views: 885
Size: 240.8 KB

bmw said they do not repair but will replace parts. the major parts they said that would be required to be changed are

1. front left fender
2. left headlamp
3. front bumper

The total estimate they had given was Rs 2.13 lac + 6k for labour charges. I find this absurd. Why is this so expensive?

I am insured with ICICI lombard. all the parts that I have mentioned above are plastic. Does this mean that I will have to pay for 50% of the parts myself?

I had also gone to EMW (European Motor Works in Udyog Vihar) and they have said that there is no point getting the bumper and front left fender replaced. They said confidently that these can be repaired. Does anyone know about them? Is Patel Auto better? They said the headlamp will need to be changed because there is a crack in the plastic covering.

Can you guys please advise what I should do? Any help really appreciated.

Thanks!

NOTORIOUS · 18th July 2009, 18:35

Thats indeed a bad crash! What happenned ???

i dont think that the fender will be make up of plastic.

please post some full front and side damage pics.

PS. Where do you stay in delhi

beejay · 18th July 2009, 19:11

Parts of the beamer are relatively less expensive in the gulf.
My friend picked up filters, wiper blades and some more stuff for his 530d and x5.
Find out what parts they need and inquire there, however see if anyone coming home as it does not make sense to incur higher cost for transporting, the lights can be carried by someone, bumper, I am not sure.

akzz · 18th July 2009, 19:24

Patel Auto is definitely good, I rate their workmanship with such cases quite above par. Do check with them.

ImmortalZ · 18th July 2009, 19:34

You'll definitely need to change the headlamp wholesale. Impossible to get the plastic front on it's own. The bumper looks like all it needs is some minor tinkering and a paint job. But the portion near the fog lamp looks like something has broken off - that may have to be jugaad-ed. The fender definitely should be metal. Tap it and see.

x5india · 18th July 2009, 20:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by ImmortalZ

You'll definitely need to change the headlamp wholesale. Impossible to get the plastic front on it's own. The bumper looks like all it needs is some minor tinkering and a paint job. But the portion near the fog lamp looks like something has broken off - that may have to be jugaad-ed. The fender definitely should be metal. Tap it and see.

The fender is plastic for sure.

Please see the pics I have just taken (sorry about the large pics - don't know how to re-size)

BMW had advised me not to go to anyone outside BMW because they say you will loose some body and paint warranty....

spiff · 18th July 2009, 20:22

this is where BMW secure comes in handy

anyway I would recommend you get an eval done by Bird Automotive as well in gurgaon.

x5india · 18th July 2009, 20:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by spiff

this is where BMW secure comes in handy

anyway I would recommend you get an eval done by Bird Automotive as well in gurgaon.

I did. They are the ones who quoted the price mentioned in my OP.

jesal · 18th July 2009, 21:24

Quote:

Originally Posted by spiff

this is where BMW secure comes in handy

anyway I would recommend you get an eval done by Bird Automotive as well in gurgaon.

how does it come in handy ? even if you bang they pay for it ? kind of confused

Parm · 18th July 2009, 21:31

BMW believes in replacing parts and not repairing them!

its better you visit some reputed bodyshops like Pandit & Co in Okhla and get a good advice from the senior Pandit!

spiff · 18th July 2009, 21:40

Quote:

Originally Posted by jesal

how does it come in handy ? even if you bang they pay for it ? kind of confused

Instead of paying for 50% they cover 100%

so you would just pay 6k for the labour in this case.

akshay1234 · 18th July 2009, 22:01

that by no means a small crash. bro if you spent 65l on an x5 be prepared to pay alot if you have to repair it. the headlamp itself will probably be 65k.

yzfrj · 18th July 2009, 22:17

Couple of sites say price for the headlight is approx 200$.
If BMW guys local says more maybe it can be sourced from ebay.

Might be possible to get the bumper fixed, there was a thread which said about quick roadside fix for bumpers that was pretty good.

It was "tested" by one of the mods of the forum, please see link

http://www.team-bhp.com/forum/modifi...ml#post1329801 (Roadside Bumper repair guys. Has anyone seen or tried them? EDIT : Pics on pg 2)

After fixing get it painted by a reputed garage.

2L seems too high. Maybe the higher cost of the car might justify the number of zeros in the spares price tag.

EDIT: There seems to be damage to the fender as well in the first pic, hard to say if its a scratch or serious damage to metal.
That might need a specialized garage to get a perfect fix.

Sahil · 19th July 2009, 01:13

This policy mentioned that BMW doesn't repair is BS. I have got several minor body damages repaired. They urge you to replace but be stern that you are only looking for repair, they will finally fall in place. The headlamp will have to be replaced but the bumper and fender can be easily fixed back with new clips and touch up job which should not cost much. If you want a perfect job paint it but there is no need for replacement.

jesal · 19th July 2009, 01:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by spiff

Instead of paying for 50% they cover 100%

so you would just pay 6k for the labour in this case.

wow so on a 5 series how much would be the secure scheme for. 6k would not be bad at all in this case. damn i pay more than that for my honda.

18th July 2009, 18:16	#1 (permalink)
x5india BHPian Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: delhi Posts: 35	minor accident in my x5. help needed guys, i've had a small collision. please see pics here: bmw said they do not repair but will replace parts. the major parts they said that would be required to be changed are 1. front left fender 2. left headlamp 3. front bumper The total estimate they had given was Rs 2.13 lac + 6k for labour charges. I find this absurd. Why is this so expensive? I am insured with ICICI lombard. all the parts that I have mentioned above are plastic. Does this mean that I will have to pay for 50% of the parts myself? I had also gone to EMW (European Motor Works in Udyog Vihar) and they have said that there is no point getting the bumper and front left fender replaced. They said confidently that these can be repaired. Does anyone know about them? Is Patel Auto better? They said the headlamp will need to be changed because there is a crack in the plastic covering. Can you guys please advise what I should do? Any help really appreciated. Thanks! Last edited by v12 : 19th July 2009 at 02:36. Reason: Pics resized and hosted on Team-BHP

18th July 2009, 18:35	#2 (permalink)
NOTORIOUS BHPian Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Delhi Posts: 397 View My Garage Infractions: 0/1 (4)	Thats indeed a bad crash! What happenned ??? i dont think that the fender will be make up of plastic. please post some full front and side damage pics. PS. Where do you stay in delhi __________________ Bajaj Pulsar 180 DTSI 22 oct 2008 Hyundai Verna VGT Sx 8 Jan 2009 Maruti Suzuki Alto Lxi 11 Nov 2009

18th July 2009, 19:11	#3 (permalink)
beejay Senior - BHPian Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: Coonoor,The Nilgiris. Posts: 1,009 View My Garage	Parts of the beamer are relatively less expensive in the gulf. My friend picked up filters, wiper blades and some more stuff for his 530d and x5. Find out what parts they need and inquire there, however see if anyone coming home as it does not make sense to incur higher cost for transporting, the lights can be carried by someone, bumper, I am not sure. __________________ I am going to pursue Galileo Galilee`s philosophy: my world is also round." Luigi Colani

18th July 2009, 19:34	#5 (permalink)
ImmortalZ Senior - BHPian Join Date: Jan 2008 Location: Trivandrum Posts: 1,729 View My Garage	You'll definitely need to change the headlamp wholesale. Impossible to get the plastic front on it's own. The bumper looks like all it needs is some minor tinkering and a paint job. But the portion near the fog lamp looks like something has broken off - that may have to be jugaad-ed. The fender definitely should be metal. Tap it and see. __________________ Honda - Providing the least Kilo per Lakh since 1948.

18th July 2009, 20:22	#7 (permalink)
spiff BHPian Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: Mumbai Posts: 103	this is where BMW secure comes in handy anyway I would recommend you get an eval done by Bird Automotive as well in gurgaon. __________________ 1993 Mitsubishi 3000GT Twin-Turbo 2009 BMW 530D Highline 2002 Honda Accord Coming Soon - 2010 Range Rover Sport TDV8

18th July 2009, 19:24	#4 (permalink)
akzz BHPian Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Dubai Posts: 32	Patel Auto is definitely good, I rate their workmanship with such cases quite above par. Do check with them.

18th July 2009, 21:31	#10 (permalink)
Parm Senior - BHPian Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: NOIDA/DxB Posts: 1,229	BMW believes in replacing parts and not repairing them! its better you visit some reputed bodyshops like Pandit & Co in Okhla and get a good advice from the senior Pandit! __________________ Go with the Flow.....Free Flow!

18th July 2009, 22:01	#12 (permalink)
akshay1234 Senior - BHPian Join Date: Dec 2006 Location: Mumbai Posts: 3,992 View My Garage Infractions: 0/1 (4)	that by no means a small crash. bro if you spent 65l on an x5 be prepared to pay alot if you have to repair it. the headlamp itself will probably be 65k.

18th July 2009, 22:17	#13 (permalink)
yzfrj BHPian Join Date: May 2008 Location: Cochin>Chennai Posts: 360 View My Garage	Couple of sites say price for the headlight is approx 200$. If BMW guys local says more maybe it can be sourced from ebay. Might be possible to get the bumper fixed, there was a thread which said about quick roadside fix for bumpers that was pretty good. It was "tested" by one of the mods of the forum, please see link http://www.team-bhp.com/forum/modifi...ml#post1329801 (Roadside Bumper repair guys. Has anyone seen or tried them? EDIT : Pics on pg 2) After fixing get it painted by a reputed garage. 2L seems too high. Maybe the higher cost of the car might justify the number of zeros in the spares price tag. EDIT: There seems to be damage to the fender as well in the first pic, hard to say if its a scratch or serious damage to metal. That might need a specialized garage to get a perfect fix. Last edited by yzfrj : 18th July 2009 at 22:20.

19th July 2009, 01:13	#14 (permalink)
Sahil Senior - BHPian Join Date: May 2004 Location: Bombay Posts: 3,073	This policy mentioned that BMW doesn't repair is BS. I have got several minor body damages repaired. They urge you to replace but be stern that you are only looking for repair, they will finally fall in place. The headlamp will have to be replaced but the bumper and fender can be easily fixed back with new clips and touch up job which should not cost much. If you want a perfect job paint it but there is no need for replacement. __________________ ______________ __________ ______ __

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Minor accident - Major scare - My Swift	emkay456	Street and Travel Experiences	33	22nd July 2009 00:11
Pointers needed - Blore accident (minor)	lazy	Street Experiences	5	11th November 2008 10:40
Bentley Accident in Mumbai(Minor Dent)	mikem	Super-Cars & Imports in India	9	16th September 2008 12:18
What to do in case of a minor car accident	shekharlele	Indian Car Loans & Insurance	16	7th August 2007 00:48
minor accident	rahulv	Street Experiences	5	28th February 2006 09:51