Go Back   Team-BHP > BHP India > What Car? > SUVs, MUVs & 4x4s


View Poll Results: Which MPV would you choose?
Renault Lodgy 135 36.89%
Toyota Innova 107 29.23%
Maruti Ertiga 59 16.12%
Honda Mobilio 15 4.10%
Mahindra Xylo 13 3.55%
Tata Aria 35 9.56%
Nissan Evalia 1 0.27%
Chevrolet Enjoy 1 0.27%
Voters: 366. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 10th April 2015, 14:42   #1
Senior - BHPian
 
S2!!!'s Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Mumbai
Posts: 1,811
Thanked: 9,105 Times
Default The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs-untitled.png

Renault Lodgy


What you’ll like:
• An all-rounded & practical 7 seater MPV. 3rd seat row is usable too
• Priced between the Ertiga & Innova. Top variant is 4 lakhs cheaper than the Toyota
• Robust, abuse-friendly build & construction
• 109 BHP diesel is fast, refined & fuel-efficient. 84 BHP variant has superb driveability
• Outstanding ride quality. Comfortable over any kind of road
Car-like to drive. Balanced handling and dynamics
• Features: Touchscreen ICE, cruise control, navigation, adjustable lumbar support etc.
• Boot space of 207 - 1861 liters. Innumerable passenger : cargo combinations possible

What you won’t:
• Limited 2nd row legroom. This seat lacks the fore & aft adjustment of its competitors
• 109 BHP diesel suffers from turbo-lag below 1,800 rpm
• Boxy, unappealing styling (especially the rear end)
• Low 3rd-row seat means you sit with your knees pointing upward
• 185/65 R15 tyres are too small for a people carrier. Same tyre size as the Swift!
• Renault's service network isn't a patch on that of Maruti or Toyota
• Owners of the mechanically-identical Duster have reported the occasional niggles

Link to Official Review (Renault Lodgy : Official Review)

Toyota Innova


What you'll like:
• Indestructible build & durability. The Innova is known for its bullet-proof reliability
• Spacious, flexible interiors. An extremely comfortable long distance commuter
• Segment-best interior fit, finish & quality. Superior to the Xylo, Evalia etc.
• Diesel engine has excellent driveability on tap
• Balanced handling & road manners. Car-like to drive
• Toyota’s fuss-free ownership experience & excellent after-sales

What you won't:
• Price just goes up, up, up with time! Direct competitors are substantially cheaper
• Garish front grille design! The earlier (2012) facelift was far more pleasing to the eyes
• Noisy diesel engine, especially over 110 kph / 3,000 rpm
• Gearing too short for highway runs. Taller 5th gear (or a 6th) would've been preferred
• Service interval of merely 5,000 kms (diesel variant). Inconvenient for those with heavy usage
• The same generation has been around since 2005 in India. Where is the all-new replacement?

Link to Official Review

Maruti Ertiga


What you’ll like:
• A 7-seater MPV at the price of a C segment sedan. The petrol variant, especially, is very well priced
• Car-like ride, handling & driving experience. Effortless to drive in the city and on highways
• Flexible seating & luggage options. Cargo capacity runs as high as 735 liters
• Competent petrol & diesel engines. The latter offers outstanding fuel economy
• ABS available on all variants, except the base petrol. Bigger brakes than the Swift & Dzire
• Maruti’s excellent after-sales service & wide dealer network

What you won’t:
• Not a spacious 5 seater if you fold down the 3rd seat row for luggage. Limited width for the 2nd row too
• 3rd row is best suited to adults for short trips, or kids over long trips. Not really a full-size 7 seater car
• Minimal 135 liter luggage capacity with all 3 rows of seats in place
• Diesel engine carries a hefty Rs. ~1.3 lakh premium over the petrol. On-road difference is ~1.5 lakh rupees
• Even the top-end ZXi / ZDi variants don't get climate control

Link to Official Review (Maruti Ertiga : Official Review)

Honda Mobilio


What you'll like:
• Great choice of engines. Both - the diesel & petrol - are fast and fuel-efficient
• Suspension offers compliant ride quality & neutral handling. 189 mm of ground clearance is a big plus
• Light controls, slick gearshift and easy maneuverability for the city. Effortless to drive
• 1st & 2nd row of seats have ample leg & headroom. Middle row beats most C2 segment sedans
• 3rd-row access is easier than in the Ertiga. 3rd row fold-down doesn't affect 2nd row space (like the Ertiga)
• Practical 223 liter boot with all seats up. 521 liters of capacity with the last row folded away
• Honda's reliability & fuss-free ownership experiences

What you won't:
• Low 3rd-row seat is best for kids or occasional usage only. This isn't a full time 7-seater
• Noticeably more expensive than the Maruti Ertiga
• The Brio's unconventional dashboard & interior design are too basic for this class of car
• Front styling is identical to its smaller siblings. Face should have been differentiated
• i-DTEC isn't as refined or high-rpm friendly as the Ertiga diesel. Also, overall NVH insulation is poor
• Brio-level cost cutting doesn't work at this price (thin sheet metal, slim seats, uneven shut lines, missing insulation & cladding)
• Many practical features missing (seatbelt height adjustment, adjustable front neck restraints, auto-locking doors, bluetooth connectivity, full MID etc.)

Link to Official Review (Honda Mobilio : Official Review)

Mahindra Xylo


What you’ll like:
• A 7-seater UV at the price of entry-level sedans
• Robust, abuse-friendly build & construction. Rough road friendly
• Very spacious! Interior ranks high on practicality
• Diesel engine is fast, torquey & fuel-efficient
• Features include voice control, reverse parking aid, dual front armrests, lumbar adjustment etc.

What you won’t:
• Awkward styling. Design isn't proportionate either
• Bouncy ride quality. Unsettled over any type of surface
• Driving experience marred by excessive body roll and a slow, numb steering
• Lacks the quality & finesse of same-price hatchbacks and sedans
• Mahindra's after-sales service remains a gamble

Tata Aria


What you’ll like:
• Solid body-on-frame construction. Seemingly robust
• Futuristic styling, especially the face. Good street presence
• Spacious 1st & 2nd seat rows. Interior quality a big leap ahead for Tata
• Balanced road behaviour. Strong brakes too
• Premium level of equipment. Many segment firsts, including AWD
• Safety : Traction control, ABS, 6 airbags & all-round disc brakes

What you won't:
• AWD variants are very expensive
• Third row of seats best suited to kids only
• Unsettled ride quality at highway speeds (compared to the Innova)
• Niggling issues & problems persist, as reported by existing Aria owners
• Tata's un-premium after-sales service experiences

Link to Official Review (Tata Aria 4x2 : Test Drive & Review)

Nissan Evalia


What you’ll like:
• Light steering, gearbox and tight turning radius. Easily driveable in the city
• Fuel efficient 1.5L diesel engine is a proven workhorse
• Generous cabin space, very usable 3rd row of seats and a large luggage capacity
• Features include a colour MID, reversing camera, keyless entry/go, 3rd row air-con etc.
• Safety kit : ABS, EBD & BA are standard. 2 airbags on all, except the lowest variant

What you won’t:
• Boxy looks & sliding rear doors give it a commercial van look & feel
• Middle row missing basics like roll-down windows and door armrests
• Small 1.5L engine has mediocre highway performance. Overtaking needs to be carefully planned
• Thin 165/80 R14 tyres are a joke on an MUV of this size
• Nissan's patchy dealer network & service quality

Link to Official Review (Nissan Evalia : Official Review)

Chevrolet Enjoy


What you'll like:
• A well priced 7-seater MPV
• Compliant low speed ride, matched to neutral on-road behaviour
• 1.3L diesel offers excellent urban driveability and fuel economy
• Compact size & light controls make it easy to drive in the city
• Equipment list includes leather seats, dual-airbags, ABS, EBD, dual air-con, parking sensors etc.

What you won't:
• Not as well-rounded as the Ertiga or Innova. Several loose ends that need tying up
• Uninspired interior design. Ordinary part quality too
• Poor NVH insulation. Refinement levels miss the mark
• Underwhelming 1.4L petrol. Weak low end torque
• Missing essentials (MID, dead pedal, steering-mounted controls, tumble-down 2nd row seats etc.)

Link to Official Review (Chevrolet Enjoy : Official Review)

Last edited by GTO : 11th April 2015 at 10:30. Reason: Removing extra [/b] tag
S2!!! is online now   (9) Thanks Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 10:32   #2
GTO
Team-BHP Support
 
GTO's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Bombay
Posts: 47,748
Thanked: 89,395 Times
Default Re: The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

Thread moved out from the Assembly Line (The "Assembly Line" Forum section). Thanks for sharing!
GTO is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 16:19   #3
Distinguished - BHPian
 
smartcat's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Bangalore
Posts: 2,977
Thanked: 11,928 Times
Default Re: The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

Meanwhile, I just realized that this is the only segment in which none of the cars have an AT option.
smartcat is online now   (7) Thanks Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 18:52   #4
BHPian
 
Mahesh Prasad's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: Mangalore.
Posts: 125
Thanked: 133 Times
Default Re: The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

My vote & opinions as follows:
I voted for the Ertiga. Reason being a well rounded competent product from the Suzuki stable with VFM tag. My second pick would be Innova, if budget would permit. There is no question about the quality, performance and reliability of the Innova but for an average buyer it might be considered a bit overpriced. The fact that both Suzuki & Toyota provide excellent After Sales Support & Service would make the choice easy.

The Lodgy has just been launched and I guess many will be apprehensive about the ASS & the thin dealer network. Lets wait and see the numbers in the coming days.

The mobilio, I would pick third. In my opinion, it is not worth the premium it commands over the Ertiga. I mean the glaringly obvious cost cutting, lack of equipment, thin seats and the Brio/Amaze exterior & interior just does not go down well with me.
The others, well given various parameters, I doubt I would go for them.
Mahesh Prasad is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 19:40   #5
Distinguished - BHPian
 
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Hyderabad
Posts: 9,370
Thanked: 13,345 Times
Default

I compare Innova vs Ertiga vs Lodgy. Not considering the rest. In this I vote got the Ertiga.

One had to own that car to know is value and overall ownership happiness.

I am not getting the Innova in the equation thanks to its price difference versus the competition. If prices do equal out, the winner clearly is Innova.

In the Ertiga, be it Driveability, Comfort, Flexibility, FE, Ride, Space all are great for its price. Been living with the car since 1.4 years and very happy with it. No complaints.
a4anurag is offline   (2) Thanks Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 20:00   #6
BHPian
 
sidharth_j's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Trivandrum
Posts: 129
Thanked: 7 Times
Default Re: The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

Voted for the Lodgy. However, cant help thinking i made a mistake. Seeing the positives and negatives, i think the best bet should be the ertiga, though you compromise on space. But come to think of it, how many times have you really seen large families in these MPVs?

The Innova is definitely out as it is outrageously priced. Doesnt matter if it is top quality. i cant throw away money like that.
sidharth_j is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 20:11   #7
Distinguished - BHPian
 
CrAzY dRiVeR's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Bangalore / TVM
Posts: 8,974
Thanked: 16,769 Times
Default Re: The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

I wanted to vote for Ertiga as it offers the best packaging for urban families at the best price. However, it is the Lodgy that gets my vote due to one reason- Cruise control. That would make the MPV a bliss to drive on the long highways, which would its natural habitat if I purchase an MUV. So it takes my vote.

1. Renault Lodgy- Good Diesel engine, good ride quality and more importantly cruise control.
2. Suzuki Ertiga - Best package for urban families.
3. Toyota Innova - If price is not a consideration and need maximum space.
4. Mahindra Xylo
5. TATA Aria
6. Chevrolet Enjoy.
7. Honda Mobilio.
8. Nissan Evalia.

Last edited by CrAzY dRiVeR : 11th April 2015 at 20:16.
CrAzY dRiVeR is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 20:43   #8
Senior - BHPian
 
carwatcher's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Bardez, Goa
Posts: 1,185
Thanked: 999 Times
Default Re: The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

I voted for Lodgy as it seems to have almost everything Innova has and whatever is left out is more than compensated by price difference between the two.

I personally like the Ertiga esp due to mouth-watering Petrol version price but if we are comparing Innova, Ertiga and Lodgy Ertiga is no match wrt comfort. Its more like pseudo MPV like we are seeing Compact Sedan nowadays.

I somehow not been able to judge the overall design of Lodgy due to the dark colour car in the official review, checked white colour Lodgy on google and now started to like it. Only thing I didn't like is straight rear boot door, it should've been curved atleast by few degrees, would've definitely improved the appeal.

Now it would be really interesting to see Toyota's reaction. Honda has transformed completely after debacle of City due to Verna diesel, so lets see how Toyota responds.

And may be the only segment where none of the cars have more than two airbags, therefore least passenger to airbag ratio.
Quote:
Originally Posted by smartcat View Post
Meanwhile, I just realized that this is the only segment in which none of the cars have an AT option.

Last edited by carwatcher : 11th April 2015 at 20:56.
carwatcher is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 21:10   #9
Senior - BHPian
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: N.A
Posts: 6,834
Thanked: 1,503 Times
Default Re: The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

Within the same review:

Quote:
Originally Posted by S2!!! View Post
Renault Lodgy

What you’ll like:
• 109 BHP diesel is fast, refined & fuel-efficient. 84 BHP variant has superb driveability
AND

Quote:
Originally Posted by S2!!! View Post
Nissan Evalia

What you won’t:
• Small 1.5L engine has mediocre highway performance. Overtaking needs to be carefully planned

Isn't it the same engine in both cars?
Steeroid is offline   (1) Thanks Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 21:14   #10
D4D
BHPian
 
D4D's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Garden City
Posts: 482
Thanked: 327 Times
Default Re: The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

Looks like Lodgy is going to dent the Innova. The first car to do so during the Innova's mighty reign. It's a well engineered product and should prove reliable.

Against the segment leader,

Lodgy vs Innova: Looks good. Can dethrone the segment king.
Ertiga vs Innova: Ertiga was smaller. Other than that, it's a wonderful product.
Mobilio vs Innova: Way to expensive for a car with bad quality inside out. (Relative to Honda's standard)
Xylo vs Innova: Xylo was too crude, and the bouncy suspension. (Older ones)

Enjoy, Evalia and all are only Taxi cars according to me. (No offence intended)
When the new Innova comes, I think this comparison could be irrelevant as I think the price gap will widen a whole lot.

Last edited by D4D : 11th April 2015 at 21:15.
D4D is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 21:23   #11
Senior - BHPian
 
shankar.balan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: BLR
Posts: 8,027
Thanked: 5,326 Times
Default Re: The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

The Lodgy's proven and frugal engine and its lovely suspension will undoubtedly make a dent in the Innova.
I can't understand Toyota India - they are charging us nearly 22 Lacs for a decade old vehicle, which has lousy specs and very few safety aids etc. Compare the price in South East Asia and I shudder to think what a premium we in India are forced to pay!
shankar.balan is offline   (2) Thanks Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 21:49   #12
BHPian
 
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Chennai
Posts: 393
Thanked: 110 Times
Default Re: The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

Quote:
Originally Posted by S2!!! View Post
[center]
Hi s2!

Gonna try my luck once more! Requesting you to add the xuv500 and scorpio to the comparo!

Last edited by GTO : 13th April 2015 at 13:42. Reason: Strictly no SMS language on this community please (e.g. "u")
acidkill is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 22:30   #13
Team-BHP Support
 
Vid6639's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Bangalore
Posts: 14,471
Thanked: 19,384 Times
Default Re: The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

Quote:
Originally Posted by Steeroid View Post
Within the same review:
AND
Isn't it the same engine in both cars?
I drove both so let me clarify.

Both have same engine, indeed.

Evalia is 85bhp only and not available in 109BHP. Secondly only 5 speed.

Also, Evalia is 50-60kilos heavier than even the Lodgy. Evalia drivability is good but just like the Duster 84BHP and probably even the Lodgy 84BHP it will not be that relaxed on the highway.
Vid6639 is offline   (3) Thanks Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 23:33   #14
Senior - BHPian
 
S2!!!'s Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Mumbai
Posts: 1,811
Thanked: 9,105 Times
Default Re: The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

Quote:
Originally Posted by acidkill View Post
Hi s2!

Gonna try my luck once more! Requesting u to add the xuv500 and scorpio to the comparo!
Interesting. Won't the Storme feel left out? And what about the Duster and Terrano? The point here is to compare MPVs with each other and not with all options available in the same price bracket, even though buyers will give the SUVs and/or sedans a look too, during their purchase process. The poll here can give a lot of prospective MPV buyers an idea of what are the best options available to them and that can save on a lot of repetitive threads in the 'what car' section.

Hope that clears my point
S2!!! is online now   (1) Thanks Reply With Quote
Old 11th April 2015, 23:49   #15
Senior - BHPian
 
coolboy007's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: New Delhi
Posts: 1,717
Thanked: 1,440 Times
Default Re: The Renault Lodgy vs other 7-seater MPVs

Voted for Lodgy as it is a very good package at a decent price point. There is good space on offer and as per the review, it offers outstanding ride quality with handling. If the ride is so good, i don't think the passengers will ever get tired on our poor roads. The interiors are a bit let down but the pros outweigh cons here. Really wish this car is a success.

My next choice would be the Ertiga, very good car again but the there is significant turbo lag and the ride quality is nothing to boast about.

This should hit Toyota and then they should understand that Indian lives are not cheap, equipping 20L MUV's and 30L SUV's with 2 airbags without any electronic aids, without rear disc brakes is astonishing. Reliability and resale is not everything.
coolboy007 is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
The Renault Lodgy swiftnfurious The Indian Car Scene 221 9th April 2015 14:05
Rumour: Renault badge-engineering the Nissan Evalia, instead of the Dacia Lodgy? JayPrashanth The Indian Car Scene 8 29th September 2013 12:06
Is India not a good market for MPVs? vb-san The Indian Car Scene 39 19th June 2011 15:46
Weird Looking UV's & MPVs !! Xinger The International Automotive Scene 57 26th July 2009 20:06


All times are GMT +5.5. The time now is 16:46.

Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Team-BHP.com
Proudly powered by E2E Networks