| || ||Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|31st January 2009, 17:39||#166|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Alleppey, Kerala
Thanked: 13 Times
Length x width x height x wheelbase (mms)
4520 x 1850 x 1895 x 2760 - Xylo
4580 x 1770 x 1775 x 2750 - Innova
Space utilisation inside the Xylo is good.
It is a little difficult to get in and out of the vehicle, though!
Observations from my wife:
The second row bench seat is not as comfortable as the 2nd row bucket seats. The second row captains chairs are more comfortable than in the Innova (the reason for selling it, and I was not comfortable with the driver's seat).
She liked the lime green colour a lot!
|31st January 2009, 21:01||#167|
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: New York
Thanked: 56 Times
Saw this vehicle running on Hosur road today. It looked really like i'm-happy-and-bumpy kind of vehicle through the massively broken road. I would imagine the ride will be similar to the one in a first gen Sumo or Scorpio.
Last edited by BurningHeart : 31st January 2009 at 21:04.
|31st January 2009, 21:13||#168|
Join Date: Jun 2007
Thanked: 158 Times
Safety is out of a combination of well designed crumple zones along with a rigid cage. And I guess in case of quite a few of the Jap/ Korean vehicles do not necessarily meet the second criteria. I repeat that it is a guess/ observation from accidents/ reading from unvalidated sources.
And the ratings which a lot of cars get in NCAP are with all the active and passive safety features included in their overseas versions. There is no necessity that all these features are included in the Indian variants. So these ratings may not be applicable in India.
Having been involved in two big accidents, one in an Armada and another in my own Indica, I do not have reason to believe that either of these vehicles are too inferior in safety as compared to other vehicles available at their price point
Lastly, the Xylo has undergone enough testing in the development cycle to ensure that it is road worthy. To be available in the market, it also has been attested for road worthiness by government agencies. It might have some handling issues (I say might because I haven't seen it or driven it), but that is no reason to call it unsafe. Remember that the speed limit on most Indian roads is 80 kmph and I have a sure belief that the Xylo is safe for speeds much beyond that
|1st February 2009, 00:11||#169|
Distinguished - BHPian
Some good impressions, some not so good, nothing too bad.
A. Great and comfortable cabin with wonderful seating comfort.
B. HVAC works well for even last row.
C. DDAS is a nice touch, even the E6's limited function DDAS. Showed variations beteen 8 km/l and 16(!) km/l during the drive. Let's average it to 12 km/l.
D. Reversing sensor and display in mirror make reversing a snap.
Not so good:
A. Huge swing on the gear lever on startup (can cause a dislocated finger), thereafter the lever settles down into vibratory mode - I have this bad habit of resting my left hand on the gear lever (I know it's not advised), and my palm was slightly sore after 10 km.
B. The engine screams after 2800-3000 r/min - very intrusive.
C. Lost sight of the odometer once I'd settled in. Need a tilt adjustable steering wheel.
D. Brakes are under-servoed, need a determined push to get them to bite - this is in comparison to what I am used to, on my Accent & Swift. But they do bite well. Matter of getting used to the extra pressure required.
Body roll is as much as expected for a tall vehicle like this. Wife was happy with the ride comfort in all rows.
Give me a smoother engine and ABS, and I'll buy this.
Last edited by khan_sultan : 1st February 2009 at 08:24. Reason: Removed Duplicate post
|1st February 2009, 07:34||#170|
Join Date: Mar 2007
Thanked: 23 Times
TD of Xylo
Yesterday i got a call from Mahindra's regional office in Pune asking if i was available for a TD. It was 3 in the afternoon and i was almost off to my afternoon siesta . Still I mustered some courage and agreed . They got the vehicle to my doorstep for the TD/ An E8 version I sat in the middle and rear seats and was driven for a couple of kms before i drove it myself.
1. Engine noise - outside and inside -- minimal -- as good or better than innova
2. Spacious -- very spacious even in the 3rd row -- doesnt feel claustrophobic as in other SUV, MUV ( Sumo, Safari, Scorpio. even Innova). Rear window can be opened.
3. Rear wiper defogger -- separate unit for filling in water as mentioned by Raj
4. Looks way better than its made out to be in the brochures.
5. Feels planted on the road -- drove till speeds of 70-80 and did not find braking to be a problem.
6. Body roll not very stated at above speeds; havent tried high speed cornering so cannot comment on it.
7. Gear knob huge and wierd. The vehicle i drove had a problem with the gearshift from 2nd to 3rd and 3rd to 2nd. I asked the M&M technician and he said its due to runin period -- i disagreed saying the gearshifting is not effortless( Car had run only for 130 kms). I told him i have an indigo ( 2003 model) and i expected the gearshifting to be smooth.
8. I complained about missing ABS for a vehicle so new.He mentioned about E10 probably being out sometime by mid year with ABS-Airbags.
no mention of optional abs for other models -- but he mentioned that it can be retrofitted.
9 The feedback form was a 4 page affair detailing all likes dislikes and suggestions for Mahindra team . Since this was direct from the M&M itself, there were no dealer folks involved. he did ask me about the timeframe i would wish to buy it. I said not so soon. I would wait for the abs airbags thing to be sorted out before i make a call. I did mention this in my feedback too.( hope they are listening)
|1st February 2009, 10:24||#171|
Distinguished - BHPian
Gearshift problem in Xylo
|1st February 2009, 12:09||#172|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Jan 2008
Thanked: 2,071 Times
|1st February 2009, 13:59||#174|
Distinguished - BHPian
Tilt steering in Xylo
|1st February 2009, 18:21||#175|
Join Date: Feb 2008
Thanked: 225 Times
Raj that was a neat & crisp TD review with most wanted picture showing the negligible luggage space with third row seats up!
If M&M considers to offer 60:40 split seats for the third row seating in Xylo this will be a sensible value addition improving prospective family buyers migrating toInnova on this feature!
Also providing optional ABS / airbag safety on all trims will place xylo much better in its position. Hope M&M is listening.
Overall resonable effort by Mahindra.
|2nd February 2009, 09:28||#176|
Join Date: Oct 2006
Thanked: 283 Times
Really detailed ,meticulously crafted review there Raj.Just felt as though i myself went for a test drive n came back. cheers
|2nd February 2009, 11:52||#177|
Join Date: Mar 2005
Thanked: 59 Times
so, to sum up the thread this far :
1. Initial reports were extremely critical of body roll / swinging.
2. Later, the reports toned down, and body roll was not a complaint at speeds that are appropriate for this class of vehicle.
So can we say that :
As long as this vehicle is not thrown around like a sedan (notwithstanding M&M's positioning and marketing tag line), and if driven with a reasonable load (as is expected of a family / people mover), the vehicle settles down and is acceptable at speeds of upto 90/100 kmph.
It was very difficult to glean the above from the various posts, what with the thread "swinging away" in various directions, but if the above is a fair precis, can we proceed from here on with the objective of some more clarity on the vehicle ?
|2nd February 2009, 12:13||#178|
Senior - BHPian
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: New Delhi
Thanked: 253 Times
The only little contradiction seems to be that M&M are not currently targeting the fleet owners. I feel individual buyers might wait for ABS & Airbags. It's largely the fleet operators who'd pick up the base versions.
|2nd February 2009, 15:06||#179|
Join Date: May 2007
Thanked: 8 Times
I got a chance to TD Xylo for ~15KM. In a nutshell, this is what I experienced :
Accelaration: Pretty good (I took it upto 100).
Braking: On braking hard (floored pedal) the vehicle stopped in a straight line (100-0)...quite impressive...unlike Scorpio (read CRDe - never tried this on an mHawk) third row occupants are no more thrown forward when braking hard.
Body roll: Some amount of roll is there (esp on maneuvering while accelerating) which is acceptable of a 2 tonne MUV.
Comfort: All 3 rows have got excellent leg and head room....seats are very comfortable...individual AC ducts chill you in no time.
Looks: Quite surprisingly front and side look better than rear . M&M must immediate get rid of Bunny Rabbit's Silver Tooth on the grill.
All in all I found it a good VFM vehicle...I admire M&M for improving on vital things like handling & braking, though it can (must) be improved further.
Last edited by deepgautam_qa : 2nd February 2009 at 15:11.
|2nd February 2009, 21:21||#180|
Distinguished - BHPian
Xylo E8 - and a look below
TD'd another Xylo today, this time an E8.
Common problems to both this and the E6 driven a few days ago:
- The gearshift sticks on shifting from 2nd to 3rd. At least two attempts required.
- The gearshift takes a huge swing when the engine starts or shuts down; this is perhaps because of the gigantic engine mounts which reduce NVH in the cabin while driving. The engine itself rocks and rolls while idling, but as reported earlier, the cabin's quiet.
- The full spec DDAS has the temp and relative humidity screen (pic below) plus alarm - to wake your driver up. Also an overspeed alarm which can be set easily.
- Brakes on this car also needed a good shove to get them to bite.
Also took a look under the car. Engine sump sits neatly between two front cross-members, out of any harm's way, but I'd have still liked a steel protection plate/bash plate below it. Should be easy to fit.
The diesel tank is a strange affair, long and flat, sitting under the body along the left side and extending quite a way forward - a really big bump or rock can perhaps put a dent or hole in it. The exhaust/silencer is routed along the right side. Would have liked the tank to be between the rear wheels as is usual.
Diff tubes and propshaft are nice and stout. Seem built to last.
Overall, lots of space all round from a mechanic's point of view - easy to access all the areas requiring attention during service.
|Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|M&M launches Xylo variant - Xylo D2, with new Engine||H3LIOS||The Indian Car Scene||61||11th November 2010 22:34|
|Countdown to new Xylo 'Happy legs' TV ad.. Will they launch a new Xylo?||Finject||The Indian Car Scene||19||19th May 2010 18:28|
|Comparision test: Scorpio 2.2 VS Xylo 2.5||sidindica||Test-Drives & Initial Ownership Reports||8||7th August 2009 16:02|