Re: Eicher introduces AMT gearboxes in commercial vehicles Quote:
Originally Posted by i74js I am not sure about its success in trucks as Indian trucks tend to run with excess load, and access to good mechanics outside city limits is relatively difficult. This is certainly a good move for buses.
The TC based AT in Tata & Leyland buses have seen mixed success (from my experience in Delhi) as transmission system fails regularly along with other issues on these buses.
AMT, though not as good as TC, yet it may prove to be successful in buses because of its simplicity.
A good move ! |
What happened in Delhi is is more towards improper power train design. With limited boundary condition those were developed and hence the issue. Other big trouble was with Tata Marcopolo in BMTC and all the 100+ buses supplied were scrapped because of poor performance. Here also its attributed to inferior design. Otherwise Volvo has AT's and no issues reported so far.
In trucks when you look at anything beyond 6 speed GB, we don't have fully automatics in the range upto 16 speed. Even if someone develops, it will be twice as expensive as a regular AMT and size of GB will make it virtually impossible to pack it. All over, trucks and buses with more no of gears are with AMT only and India will move towards it. Volvo will make it standard in coming days to offer FH, FM range only with I-shift AMT's. Similarly Scania is moving towards Opticruise.
In India its since 5 years, Ashok Leyland introduced 'Leymatic' AMT in their buses. All their tarmac coaches are with 'Leymatic' as standard and 12M front engine buses are with option. 'Boss' was the first truck to feature AMT and its on sale for almost 3 yrs from now.
GoI is pushing these features in buses through Urban Bus Specifications, as buses should have either AT or AMT to qualify. Infact Eicher is the last to join this AT/AMT club as without this Eicher will not be qualifying. Quote:
Originally Posted by abhishek46 Yes, but how would it fare on gradients like steep flyovers in traffic and stop go situations in ghats?
AMT struggle to handle them in normal passengers & the system take help from brakes to keep vehicle from rolling back. Imagine this punishment on the brakes of a Bus/truck.
I, personally, would be wary of sitting in one, on ghat sections. |
AMT's need to be bundled with hill hold to over come this issues. This is not a complicated one and can be done easily and relatively simpler as well.
Last edited by Ashley2 : 26th March 2017 at 22:06.
|