Re: Range anxiety issues! Can lightweighting help combat it? Quote:
Originally Posted by anjan_c2007 "Every ounce of that weight reduction improves range," says Andrew Poliak, US chief technology officer of Panasonic Automotive. The company says it has developed components – such as the speakers and audio system used in cars – that not only weight between 30-60% less but also draw 60% less power from the car without affecting performance. At the currently ongoing Consumer Electronic Show (CES) at Las Vegas, Nevada, US, Panasonic Automotive revealed a 5 cm speaker that can replace a 15 cm one, with an equal audio output, that can be fitted to the car's doors. Optimising the car components with the"lightweighting" concept, both the car and its component makers are vying to resolve the weight riddle for EV's.
Link:
BBC News - Electric vehicles: Can 'lightweighting' combat range anxiety? https://www.bbc.com/future/article/2...-range-anxiety |
While it is true that lightweighting should help in range, it is instructive to see what are the situations where the mass of the car matters. Here are some points to consider
1. At high speeds (highway driving) wind resistance is the biggest range killer and obviously is not dependent on mass but the shape (aero or not) of the car
2. Efficiency during steady cruising on flat highways should not depend on mass. Yes it takes energy to build up the speed and this is proportional to the mass but once you have attained the cruising speed mass has very less role. This means a heavy car will do significantly worse for lots of short drives but will be fine for long highway drives.
3. Loss due to acceleration-deceleration cycles are proportional to mass. This is because KE = 1/2 m (v^2 - u^2) and a portion of it is lost due to the regen efficiency (if regen efficiency was 100% then no loss)
4. Same argument with Cruise control on undulating terrain (proportional to mass).
5. Bad roads can really kill range and mass of the car makes a significant wastage. Think of it as a lot of small undulations that wastes a lot of energy as well as energy lost in the suspension system (No possibility of regen here I guess).
What does that mean when designing and driving cars ?
1. Aero design is very important if you want good high speed range. Saving on few grams here and there by tweaking the music system is not worth it.
2. When driving making sure that we do not indulge in Acceleration-Deceleration and when ever possible indulge in regen 0 driving on highways. This can mitigate a lot of the problems with heavy cars.
3. I would believe that the same car with two different batteries (Nexon LR vs MR) would roughly give the same Wh/Km figures as long as we do steady driving. One more reason to get the LR model of a given car if budget works out.
4. Better HVAC systems as well as radiation protection. Say no to sunroof  . This will be a big energy sink. Even in moderate climate of Kerala it looks like about 9-10% power is taken by the AC system. |