Although there is overlap between these three siblings from the Hyundai stable, there are also
significant differences that should make choosing one (among the three) quite easy for those who know exactly what they want.
-------
The
Grand i10 has a big advantage over the other two in terms of affordability, without compromising in terms of premium feel/features. The lower variants (both petrol & diesel) are also very well priced and have adequate features, though I would recommend the Asta(O) for its 2 airbags & ABS.
The second advantage of the Grand i10 is its shorter length (over the Xcent & i20) and shorter turning circle radius (compared to the i20). It should be easier to navigate through extremely congested lanes and park in very tight spots. The shorter length has a relative disadvantage in terms of boot volume, though the Grand i10's boot is pretty good for a car of its size. Hyundai missed a little trick here by not providing 60:40 split folding rear seats, which would have greatly increased flexibility. However, one must note that the Grand i10 does offer a little additional load carrying capability, thanks to its sturdy integrated roof rails with mounting points- fixing a roof rack or a Thüle box and removing it (when not necessary) should be quite easy indeed!
Lest I forget, the Grand i10 is the only one among the three to come with a factory-fitted alternate fuel option (albeit with a smaller engine) in the form of the 1.0 Kappa LPGi Magna variant.
Hyundai's biggest miss with the Grand i10 happens to be their stupidity in providing 2 airbags and ABS only on the top Asta(O) variant and worse, not offering the 4-speed Automatic in this trim level. A Grand i10 1.2 Automatic with safety features would have been an almost ideal choice as a refined, feature-laden hatchback for the self-driven urbanite which can also carry more passengers and do highway duty whenever required.
This is a huge missed opportunity on the part of Hyundai. I hope they correct this soon, and offer a better spread of safety features across the range, including on the Automatic variants.
-------
The
Xcent also has its advantages over the other two. The biggest of course, being the boot - a capacious and well-shaped 407 litre one. This makes it the best choice for those who travel with plenty of occupants
and luggage. Then there is its image as a sedan or a three-box car. One also gets some additional features in the Xcent compared to the Grand i10 - reverse camera, electrochromic rear view mirror, rear arm-rest with cup holders, automatic climate control etc. in addition to the larger boot. Compared to the i20, the Xcent has a higher seating position, easier ingress/egress (especially for the rear) and a rear arm-rest. This would give it an edge over the i20 for elderly people and the chauffeur driven.
The Xcent's Automatic variant is its trump card. The i20 does not have an autobox yet, and the Grand i10 Automatic does not have airbags or ABS, which both the Xcent Auto variants do - the S(O) gets ABS and the SX(O) gets the recommended 2 airbags and ABS. Xcent has a better spread of safety features across the range (when compared to Grand i10) for the manual variants as well.
-------
Coming to the new
i20, it does feel larger, more spacious (especially in terms of width) and a little more premium compared to its two overlapping siblings. It is also a solid improvement over the old i-gen i20 in almost every aspect that one can think of, except two {i.e. Asta(O) variant & illumination}. I was pleasantly surprised when I sat in the rear seat of the new i20. It has significantly more headroom & legroom at the rear, and even the under thigh support and seat contours have been improved by a good margin over the old one. The rear A/C vents are a big plus when compared to the (almost useless) foot level A/C vents on the i-gen i20. The front centre armrest is another solid improvement in terms of comfort (I wish they had provided a rear centre armrest too). There is no missing the premium feel offered in the new i20's cabin - it feels like a quality hatchback meant for the European markets. It looks like one as well!
The i20 is also the only one among the three to offer height adjustable front neck restraints (standard) and 60:40 split folding rear seat (Asta only), which is a good way to increase practicality. The boot is sufficiently large at 285 litres and well shaped too.
The trump card of the i20 is its larger, 90PS diesel engine with the 6-speed gearbox. This makes it the best choice for highway mile munchers and turbo addicts. The petrol engine is exactly the same among the three siblings, so the lighter Grand i10 and Xcent would be quicker than the petrol i20. The Asta, Sportz & Sportz(O) variants of the i20 are recommended because of the airbag(s) and ABS on offer.
The new European i20 also gets a new 1.4 Kappa dual VTVT petrol engine (100PS & 134Nm) mated to either a 4-speed torque converter or a 6-speed manual. I hope Hyundai launch
both of them here in the near future!
-------
So in the end, it all depends on what one is looking for in a car, the kind of usage it would be subjected to, one's choice of powertrain and of course, the budget. Whether the choice is easy or confusing, for Hyundai it can mean only one thing -
The more, the merrier!