Re: The dilemma Polo Comfortline 1.5 TDI vs Punto Evo 93 ps Quote:
Originally Posted by D4D If you want experience of Maruti ASS, forget these cars.
Buy the i20 for hassle free maintenance. |
Thank you. I did try out the Elite i20 just yesterday. I found the fit and finish and paint quality excellent. The space in the car too is great. But (just my personal opinion) it felt like I was playing a video game. Not sure if I am making sense. The steering felt like a simulator. I like some road feedback from the car. Also, the top end diesel is expensive! Quote:
Originally Posted by IshaanIan Fiat Punto -ves
Driving position is slightly off Volkswagen Polo -ves
*Ridiculously cramped rear bench
To make things a little more interesting, do consider the Ford Figo. Arguably the best to drive if a bit dated. You could even choose to wait for the launch of its replacement. |
The rear space of the Polo is the unsettling factor as long drives will mean three people in the back seat. I also found the hump to be bigger than the average molehill and tried sitting in the centre. For long drives, it looks uncomfortable.
The Figo for some reason never figured on my list. I think I will try it out after checking its features. thank you. Quote:
Originally Posted by Zigor
1. You will never feel under-powered, whether you are climbing a hill road or going through traffic. I mean never !
2. Some phrases that you used were nifty car for city, strong safe family car, good climbing ability, a good AC, decent luggage space. Some traits that describe a Polo.
3. Polo ages well and never looks bored or over the top. It maintains the classic lines and the design is inspiring.
Biggest drawback for a Polo is rear space which is really inadequate. The bump in the middle doesn't help either.
If we compare a Punto :
3. With so much chrome and over-designed look, it might age faster than a Polo.
Biggest plus for a Punto is slightly better ride quality than a Polo.
Please have back to back test drives.
Zigor |
Absolutely right in all your points above which even I observed. Its the rear space of the Polo that is putting me off. And the ride quality being a little better in the Punto. Frankly, I am not a fan of the new Punto looks. The old Maserati front is just so dignified. Why couldn't VW just offer some more legroom. They give so much power and so little seating space. Quote:
Originally Posted by auto_enthusiast If you have your heart on the punto, you can also go for the avventura. |
Yes, I will check this car out also. As you said, the higher GC is good. But we need to strictly keep this car for only long drives or non-mall visits int he city as every security guard will need special training to open the Avventura's boot. Quote:
Originally Posted by ghodlur Would suggest you to rank the two cars on the 0-10 scale for each characteristic and come up with an overall score, will help you to decide clearly. |
Unfortunately, each car scores well on different points. Hence the confusion. I will need to think about this a bit more. Quote:
Originally Posted by extreme_torque I will side with the Polo primarily because it has got better engine and better quality interiors and find it better looking too. A lot of my close friends own a Punto and I feel it will cost less to service than the Polo. |
Agreed totally. The Polo's interiors will impress the better half. You mentioned a lot of friends own the Punto. Are they generally happy owners? Quote:
Originally Posted by tabrez
1. Old school HPS steering is tuned to enthusiast's taste compared to Polo
2. I find Punto's suspension slightly better suited for our pothole ridden roads
do keep us posted on the side you choose to drift. |
Yes, The HPS is what I noticed too. Some things are just better left unevolved. the character speaks. Quote:
Originally Posted by fiat_tarun I suggest you check with fellow Fiat owners in Hyderabad how the service is. Service quality is very city specific and support in your city is the most important. I see your location is Hyderabad - IIRC bhpian 'Hilram' has a big collection of Fiat's and even picked up the Avventura.
On them moving out of India, I do not see that happening. With the Chrysler merger done, emerging markets is the next priority for FCA, with plans to make India a production hub for Jeep already underway. |
Thank you very much for this info. I will contact Hilram for sure. On another note, yes, I have been shamelessly walking around in my colony and knocking on Fiat owners' doors (complete strangers) and talking to them about their cars. Every one them is very happy. I have spoken to 7 owners till now. And 2 have done 80000+ kms. But then, the Polo owners are also happy Quote:
Originally Posted by StepUP! Handling, steering and dynamics wise Figo is a strong contender. I would say better than Punto and Polo.
Also if I may suggest wait for TATA Bolt. |
Really? The Figo handling and dynamics is better than an Punto? I will take a TD of the car and the showroom is just walking distance from my house. |