Quote:
Originally Posted by hondadude If rear seat comfort is your first priority, Swift is probably not the right choice for you. Whatever you choose, it isn't really worth paying that much extra for a diesel. Running of 1500 kms per month isn't enough to cover the high initial cost for diesel.
Any reason, why you aren't considering Getz ? It probably satisfies your requirements more than Swift or U-VA considering Hyundai a.s.s. is fantastic. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by ravibhat Except for Rear seat comfort Swift is good, Swift is cramped car, Getz, UVA, Palio better ones among hatch, Or wait for 2 months Logan is great car, it has great space for family like 4 people Logan is great car!
Regards,
Ravi. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by benbsb29 I would advise against the Swift, as rear seat comfort is a bother. Would have sufficed if it was just you, and ur family, but with ur parents also being a part of the bandwagon, wudnt recommend Swift.
Getz wud be a much better option, and Hyundai A.*.S. shud be satisfactory. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by ronline Even I'd prefer Getz over Swift any day. Swift's rear seats are fine only for kids not for adults. And I feel Getz is also better to drive in the city conditions as it requires fewer gear shifts than Swift. The only negative thing about Getz is its incorrect pricing which has almost killed the brand. |
On the contrary, among Alto, Wagon R, Zen Estilo, Esteem.... Swift has the best rear seat comfort as compared to any body else. In others you feel something is missing under your thighs, on long journeys, you will feel strained, but not in a Swift. Swift has got big seats to drown you in them. There is less space behind that agreed but you'll get accustomed to it.
Look at this link -
Cover Story SUZUKI SWIFT
It mentions -
The rear seat deserves special mention for the comfort it offers. Like in the front, the cushioning is spot-on, not too hard and not too soft. But what makes it truly stand out is the fantastic under-thigh support it offers, thanks to a deep seat base. This is a tribute to the Indian engineers who developed the Swift's back seat. No one knows back seat comfort the way Indians do!
Personally even I found the rear seats of Swift quite comfortable with excellent under thigh support and allows one to relax comfortably for all the hours of driving. You can relax pulling yourself behind properly. It's seats allow you to sink properly inside. the width of the seats is also large, and 3 people can sit comfortably together. What else are you looking at? It's AC is also quite powerful enough. In all you feel comfortable during the journey and that's what matters. The back may be a problem for people with good height but for normal people, it's fine.
Baleno is a class apart though. It's got the best seats and rear seats for a fine car like that. But the recent price hikes of Rs. 12,000 on it will affect the sales to a good extent and that too for a model which is going out and for which the production is closed down. They will not likely be able to clear their inventories as good as they could have. It appears that Maruti folks have read the opinions about the Baleno from Team BHP to arrive at the conclusion to hike the prices of Baleno by the highest amount.
The diesel is quite costly initially (1 lac+) but if the running is more than 1500 km to 2000 km or more then the cost can be recovered quickly. Moreover in 2007 all companies are going to focus on Diesels. So there is going to be lots of competition and Diesel cars will hold their value good. Swift Diesel being a new car will also hold it's value very tightly and you'll be able to recover the investment cost to a great extent if you sell it off later. It will sell off better than Petrol at least as far as % of investment recovered is considered considering all cars are actually depreciating assets.
In my opinion, Swift Lxi Petrol and converted to CNG from an authorized convertor dealer (also keeping in mind the safety points vital for running a CNG vehicle to prevent from mishaps) immediately after buying a new Swift is also a very good option. Warranty lost may not affect much as it has a tried and tested Esteem engine. Moreover petrol cars run properly for 3-4 yrs initially. So for 4.5 lacs on road for Lxi with CNG, your running costs stay below 1500 - 2000 bucks per month for 1500 km + or so. Also the down payments are also very less. Add to that the road taxes are also lesser by almost 15,000 Rs when purchasing the car. You can spend all the money saved on frilling it up with K&N filters and mods, good stereos and DVD players, spice up and color the interiors with beige color and good leather or soft comfort feel seat covers also and make it hotter than even the Swift Vxi.
Getz is a stylish car also, however it's Fuel efficiency is a bother. It will return 8-11 kmpl on an average. Even 2-3 kmpl lower in efficiency and a high usage of 1500 km or so makes Getz eventually costlier by around 22 - 25,000 Rs per year. So during a 5 yr span you'll eventually spend over 1 lac extra just in Fuel ??? Why not spend that 1 lac on a good quality Diesel initially and save the money and invest in good Japanese technology combined with an award winning 1.3 Fiat Diesel multijet engine? Add to that the higher resale value and increased torque, quicker performance on highways increased fuel efficiency of 22kmpl + ( as reported on NDTV Car and Bike show) and Think about it !
However Getz Diesel when launched may fill in the shortcomings of Swift Diesel and then they can have a winner in their hands if priced properly. Besides how the market reacts to larger cars like the Logan Diesel in the same price range of 5.5 lacs, It could be that eventually the consumer will be tilted towards the Logan as a big car is any day big and the Indian consumer will definitely think as to why to spend the same amount on a hatch when I can get a proper sedan at the same price. But then come to think about it, Logan is a new player, so nobody knows how it will do. And to play safe, probably the Swift may ultimately be a better and a safer buy. But the mind is never satisfied and it always thinks what if I had got a bigger and larger car !
So it's your call ultimately. What do you want today ?