I was confused and the Auto Expo added to the confusion, Swift vdi, Beat or Polo We recently booked a swift Vdi in December 2009 and expect delivery in February 2010. I loved polo and knew that it will be launched soon but Dad's old school thought says not to go with new brand such as VW, reason unknown after sales, unknown reliability, unknown spare prices, questionable resale and unknown price (i have seen sid's thread but would want to wait for the prices from VW itself that are due to come out in March 2010, when the company launches the car.) My dad could be right but I dont think VW can mess up with its hot hatch plans. however, the more important part is that 6 lac rupees is a lot of money for us and we cant risk it.
Now, I love the swift (both diesel and petrol and decided for a diesel as it has our national Fiat DDis engine, which is very good and since I already have a cedia, so thought why not diesel this time). Despite the fact, I am perfectly fine with the petrol (dont mind higher cost and lower FE than Diesel.)
So even till yesterday I was confused whether to stick to Swift Vdi only or to wait for the Polo. After reading Sid's thread, I found the would-be price of Polo very lucrative. I spoke to my dad regarding the Polo and he completely refused. However, I believe that if I wait till March and let my dad have a test drive of polo, he may be convinced, but it will certainly be difficult.
Today, I went to the Auto Expo and got even more confused to see both Polo and Beat in person. I completely fell in love with the RED Polo. The Beat looked good too but if I am to rate the three I have selected, on the basis of looks, it will be Polo, Swift and then Beat. I haven’t driven either the polo or the Beat and deciding which one to buy is difficult till I do so. My knowledge about cars says that Polo will be far better to drive than the swift. The Beat on the other hand will not be as fun to drive as Swift, forget the polo.
However, excellent pricing of Beat has made me think over it. The LT option pack which has almost same features as that of Swift Zxi costs 70k less than the swift Zxi and 60k less than the Vdi (on road price comparison). Lack of safety features, music system, ACC and Alloy wheels in the vdi has made me lean further towards the Beat. I liked the interiors and the car looks Decent.
Our budget is 5.5 with 10% extra if the car has integrated audio system, alloy wheels and better tyres. My dad is the decision maker in this case and not me. If I was to decide, I would have bought a used 2006 civic for 6lac. Further, I any ways bought a cedia last year for myself, so I can only suggest options to my dad for new cars and not decide upon them.
After I came back from the Expo, I spoke to my dad regarding the polo and the Beat. Although, he completely refused for the polo for reasons mentioned above, he did like the idea of Beat (Thanks to the Beat test drive thread from GTO). We will TD the car on Sunday and then decide. Till then I want suggestions from you guys on what to do, stick to swift, wait for polo or go with the Beat.
Also I have no idea about the after sales of Chevy and hence would seek dvice on the same. Since I just came from the Expo, I will read more about Chevy after sales in the next couple of days.
PS: I would request you to suggest from the options I have listed as I would not want to buy Hyundai, Fiat, Tata, Ford or other Marutis due to various other reasons.
I would want to thank everyone who has been updating us on the Polo. A special thanx to Sid for the Polo threads (you rock, Scoop master) and GTO for the Beat Test Drive report.
@GTO, since you have driven both Beat and Swift, which one would you suggest on the basis of driveability.
Summary:
Swift: I love it, dad loves it but the design has gone old, new model expected sometime around diwali 2010. So next year I may feel outdated in the swift. Too common is another reason why I am avoiding it.
Polo: I love it, Dad doesn’t want to go with VW (new brand, almost everything is questionable). Can wait till March 2010.
Beat: I liked it, Dad liked it, Will TD this Sunday and then decide. unaware of after sales, please guide.
Last edited by gaurav_chopra04 : 5th January 2010 at 23:28.
|