Quote:
Originally Posted by Live To Jive Why don't you go for an i10. The price difference is minimal. |
Thanks live to jive. i10 was not considered since it is out of the budget by 55k on road in b'lore.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GTO Want my advice? Go for the Spark. The li'l hatch suits your needs to the T. Plus, its a favorite with women. We bought one for my bhabhi and she is immensely happy with the car. Peppy engine, fun to drive, decent ride and "cute" design. Ask your Mum & Wife to take a spin, then update us. |
Thanks GTO. Test drive update below. I suggested this to my dad as a better option than the alto.
Quote:
Originally Posted by rohan_iitr If lack of power steering is the only problem with your Maruti 800, why don't you consider the option of fitting aftermarket power steering in the Maruti 800 ?
IMHO, Alto is a bit overpriced. I would recommend Spark or K-series Estilo.
Rohan |
yes Rohan. Alto is surely overpriced and we felt the same earlier. But with the current 3.14L on-road price coupled with the engine which has been around for so long, it seemed to be a good deal.
And since the M800 is 14 years old, we dont want to experiment with any after market add-ons. And we are getting a decent price for it hence decided to go for the change.
Quote:
Originally Posted by EssYouWe I think it'll almost certainly be the K10B motor.
Now, the engine is a great one. Very peppy and sprightly! If only non enthusiasts will be driving, the advantage trickles down to nothing.
My advice would be to bargain hard for the existing one, holding the new one as a point.
If you could consider the Spark, then it is a great vehicle and will cover most of your needs. Try and get a 2009 Spark and ask for a hefty discount.
The top end Spark runs on-road for about 3.64 l in Delhi.
Cheers! |
Thanks EssYouWee, the irony is that we get the Spark PS for 3.56 on-road Bangalore.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mohandas Let me explain the -ve points as well. It is a 8V SOHC engine and the chassis is derived from pre-historic daeoo matiz. Not sure, it you want to spend your hard earned money on this old tech stuff. |
Thanks Mohandas. Though its from the old matiz, it seems to be a capable chasis.
UPDATE: Test drives completed this weekend of Alto, A-Star & Spark. Also had a sneak peek and a small drive in the Beat. Opinions as below:
The test drive was mainly done by my mum and wife. Me and dad only did short distances in each car.
ALTO: Very functional interiors. Nothing to write home about or nothing to write off as well. For the price the interiors seem about OK.
We get rolling with the car packed with 5 people. I am not able to fit myself in the back seat along with my wife and the showroom guy. Dad is quite happy in the front passenger seat.
+ves:
1. Short turning radius
2. Very easy to handle in city due to its size
3. EPS which makes it easy to park the vehicle for the ladies.
-ves:
1. Underpowered with AC. My mum & wife were both not happy with the performance with AC. Very difficult to overtake city traffic
2. Blower at position 2 is very noisy and you cannot have a conversation in the vehicle peacefully.
3. Ingress & egress was difficult for my mom and dad both but wife and me were comfortable.
STILL UNDER CONSIDERATION
A-STAR: Interiors better than Alto. Smaller steering which I liked but made no difference to my mom and wife i guess. Both of them were not happy with the appearance of the car. Still after some coaxing they took the drive. The space inside still felt somewhat similar to Alto though shoulder room was better.
Engine very peppy and good for overtaking in the city. Though there was a drop in performance with AC, the difference was negligible. But the high dashboard was a deterrent to both the ladies. Ingress & egress again was a bit tough for my mum due to a low seating.
OUT OF THE LIST - I guess appearance played a major role here than anything!!
SPARK: My mum was happy with the ingress & egress and so was my dad. The LT version we test drove had beige interiors and the cabin felt very spacious and airy. Mum and wife both were confident of the view outside though the dashboard was only a tad lower/same position as A-Star.
They were happy with the way Spark drives and also happy with the performance. They were not able to find any negatives or deal breakers as such.
UNDER CONSIDERATION.
BEAT: Now this was a chance happening. We were just finishing off the TD of Spark when one of my colleagues who had got delivery of the Beat very recently came to the showroom for collection of certain documents. Cutting the story short, me & mum did a quick run in the Beat. It was definitely best of the lot and I was impressed with the performance. Mum was also happy with the driving position and the controls etc. But the waiting period and the price put it off the list. But it was really a fun car to drive and if it were not for a second car, i would have coaxed my dad to go for it.
Now the decision making is happening back home as i am typing out this post in office between Spark and Alto. Will keep you all posted.
PS: GTO, I had read about the Spark decision for your Bhabhi in eagle_bush's spark ownership thread and thought it would fit the bill for my mum as well. And i think the Spark might just push over the alto and make it into our garage very soon!