I have been employed for a couple of years now and have decided to take the plunge and book my first ever car next month.
Budget:
5.75 Lacs (not stretchable)
Contenders :
-------------- Swift LDI, (5.76 Lacs on road) Figo TDCI EXI, (5.65 Lacs on road) Punto MJD Active (5.72 Lacs on road).
I have already ruled out the figo, although it is the most VFM proposition for me since most in the family are not too fond of its looks. And I am not too crazy about the ICE and central locking that i would get as a bonus in the Figo. I can manage to install these aftermarket within a couple of months of the purchase in the other cars too. However, I am having a keen ear towards suggestions and justifications in favour of the figo as well.
Well, now, the confusion is mainly between the
Swift LDI and the
Punto MJD Active.
Let me sum up my requirements and the detailed thought process behind narrowing down to the above 2 options.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. I am a little tight on budget during the purchase so looking at base models of both cars. I am not too bothered about the features but having a few is a bonus.
2. 70% of the time the car would be occuppied by me and my girlfriend (will be my wife after another six months
). Rest of the time my parents/friends would also be along.
3. Ride quality and comfort over long journeys is important since my father has lower back pains.
4. I intend to keep the car with me for a long time. I am looking forward to atleast 6 years.
5. The car would be used for office commute on weekdays (30 Km daily in all) and a little more on weekends. But whenever I get a long weekend, I plan to go out on drives and tours to nearby tourist destinations.
(I love touring and this is one of the main reasons behind the purchase).
Thus average monthly running may not be more than 1000-1100Kms and may not warrant a diesel. But still over a 3 yr period,
{the EMI + fuel cost
} figure will be same for both and I would be happier with no need to worry about hefty fuel cost before a suddenly planned weekend getaway. So please do not suggest petrol alternatives.
With the above requirements in mind I did a comparo between the two. And findings are:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. I felt that Punto suits my requirements much better than the swift does in terms of comfort.
2. For the swift, i would have to shell out an additional amount on tyre upgrade soon after the purchase. Wheras in the Punto I could comfortably use the stock ones for their lifetime and then go for better ones. Would have to additionally purchase LHS mirror and wheel caps for swift. And the wheel caps, even from MGA, are not of the same quality as the ones that come from factory with VXI/VDI.
3. With the swift I would sorely miss the tacho. The punto offers some other goodies on this front like realtime FE indicator, etc.
4. I would get front power-windows in punto but not in swift.
5. The interiors of the 2010 punto appear to have with better quality plastics, and even though it is nothing to write home about, it atleast has a better look and feel good factor than the interiors of the swift.
6. I like the looks of both the cars, but i am totally sold off to the elegance and the beauty of the Bossa Nova White Punto.
I guess, I am giving an impression of having made the choice already !
Well, That is true.
But the reason behind posting this query is Swift has a great peace of mind associaced with it. It has proven itself and above all it comes from the Maruti stable. There is a promising A.S.S backing it up.
Since this would be my first car, and even my parents never owned or purchased a car, the experience would be totally new. There could be many areas about which, I may not have any idea at all and the dealers could take me for a ride.
Based on these facts my head is advising my heart to be calm and settle for the swift, resting assured that not even a newbie could go wrong with a swift.
I do not want to regret my choice from any aspect at all, after investing such a hefty amount so early in my career.
Could you
pour in your expert advices that as a first time buyer, should i risk going in for a punto, or I would be safer sticking to the swift.
Thanks in advance!