Incredibly shoddy work & damage by MASS (Chowgule Industries) Horror story with Chowgule Industries Pvt. Ltd., probably the biggest Maruti Suzuki Dealer Workshop in Pune:
Esteem was in need of significant body shop work.
29 Feburary, 2012 – Handed over the car to their driver who had come home for picking up the car. Tipped him in the hope that he will take the car to their Body Shop safely.
Please note that Chowgule have a seperate set up for their Workshop and their Body Shop is in a compound some 100 meters away. The Workshop is relatively better looking overall, while the Body Shop is a huge mess as mentioned below.
Their Service Advisor called in after couple of days with the estimate. I asked for break up, and the break up included cost of a new front bumper. He told me its damaged beyond repair. There was absolutely no damage to the bumper when the car was handed over. I had to go all the way to take a look. Indeed the front bumper had a big crack on the right side. Number plate was damaged too.
Without going into details what followed was complete denial that it happened at their place, accusations and counter accusations, etc. But after all that haggling, showing them the Job Sheet (where existing damages are supposed to be marked/mentioned by their driver) they finally owned up. I was told that the driver admitted that he had an accident on the way (later I was told it happened within their premises). So its anybody's guess on what the truth is. They agreed to replace the upper (cracked) part of the front bumper. . . Lower part will be painted where damaged. Number plate will have to be replaced.
After an interminable delay, the smaller part of it attributed to sourcing parts from MUL, the work started. Despite the long delays, I had emphasized that I expect the kind of work that is expected from an expensive Authorized Workshop. Even then, I had to pay 2 – 3 visits and had to point out several things that were not done properly. Ordinary things like panels not fitted properly, rear view glass not fitted properly, etc., etc. Clearly, shabby work in progress here…
Now the incredible really starts – on one of the above visits, I noticed that they had damaged the front most panel on the right side. Damage was around the top of the front wheel. Again, after the same cycle of complete denials, much wastage of time, allegations, phone calls, etc., they agreed to mend the damage.
By now, utterly bewildered at the 2nd instance of damage, I repeatedly emphasized, even to their Body Shop Manager, that there is something seriously wrong with the way they function or they way they handle things. I also made it clear that I will check every single panel for damage before taking delivery.
On 23rd March, 2012, after repeated reminders and requests to finish the work and deliver the car as it has been with them for almost 1 month, I was again told that they wont be able to deliver it on that day as their drivers were not available. Exasperated, I had to leave work and went all the way to pick it up myself. Unfortunately, after spending considerable time in billing, etc., the it had become dark and the parking area was dimly lit. Despite that, what I saw horrified me further – the headlights had some rough sticky substance smeared all over. Several panels, including two that were just painted by them had what I might call small pitting and scrape marks. Indicator lense had big body paint spots all over it. I pointed it all out to their Workshop Service Advisor, and couple other people who rubbished everything. According to them the marks were exterior marks that would vanish after a wipe/wash. But their theories were amusing to say the least. Some which are really a laugh riot :
1) Car is old, so its bound to happen.
2) Its caused by washing and will vanish soon. They can’t use “mineral water” so its bound to happen (Its obvious that he ment distilled water. They don’t even know the difference between mineral and distilled water?)
3) All cars develop such marks and they can show me. I said show and they went silent on this point and shifted to the next.
4) Its caused due to some substance sprayed while painting and it will vanish in 2-3 days on its own.
Its more than clear that they seem to have sprayed something… maybe like clear coat, by mistake on the lens and the same seems to have reacted with the plastic making it patchy and opaque. Utterly exasperated with their nonsense, and since it was getting really late and I had come all the way in rickshaw with no way to go back, I just took delivery and decided to take care of it later.
On the way, I discovered that the substance was on the windscreen too. Visibility became a serious problem due to both the windscreen and headlight. On running a hand over the screen one can easily feel significant roughness over the glass. Wipers would make weird noise over the glass and the windscreen fluid no longer gets wiped away by the wiper. In short, the screen has become a mess. It seems the substance is on the bonnet too, as you can feel the same graininess if you run your hand over it too.
Next morning, daylight revealed the mess in all its glory – several panels including 2 which were newly painted had several marks which I can describe as “pitting”. Called up the Body Shop advisor and he said it would be rubbing compound. I said I don’t think so as it feels like they are indentations and not protrusions. Drove there all the way the next day itself, where he confirmed that it was not rubbing compound but the paint was either damaged/defective.
Now their solution really made my eyeballs pop – they simply put touch-up paint all ver the marks and rubbed polish paper over the windscreen windows, and headlamps and indicators. I quickly regained my composure and pointed out that doing that may scratch the surface, esp. since all lights have plastic lenses and they will likely become dull and scratched. They did not pay heed and assured me that they know what they are doing and everything will be all right when they finish.
They delivered the car in a dirty condition (milky, dirty water caused by their polish paper) right after their crude work. Needless to say, no problem was solved. Only made worse.
Has anybody ever heard a big authorized service center doing this kind of work? Patchwork painting?
Polish paper over plastic and glass surface?
Observing and probing revealed many other things about this Body Shop. Their floor area is open ground with no tiling. Even otherwise the area they operate in is exceedingly dusty. Even the floor where they work and where parts are opened up does not even have a tiled surface. Doors of paint boots are open even when painting and drying is going on inside. The front office of the Body Shop is as low down as it can get. Cars are parked in their premises with hardly 1 inch gaps between them. Is it possible for anybody to park cars like this without damaging them?
Several other observations, and some shocking insider info, all of which I cannot mention here for obvious reasons.
Question is, how as Maruti Suzuki given them Authorization? That itself seems to be a mystery. Interestingly, I hear they have recently been demoted to a C grade workshop by Maruti.
Needless to say I’m in no mood to take this atrocious work lying down. Will try and post a few pictures, later.
Suggestions/comments/advice on how to proceed against both the Chowgule and Maruti Suzuki will be appreciated.
Last edited by Raccoon : 25th March 2012 at 17:55.
|