Quote:
Originally Posted by thedreamcatcher Good topic. As a metter of fact I was also thinking about the pracitcality of collecting the toll a few days back and was thinking of starting a thread on this, not to mention the time lost at these toll gates (have suffered at tolls like the Delhi-Gurgaon one as well)
Ok, here goes, and my main intention with this post is to also get some idea on this topic and need people to offer the correct opinion. I am using some scenarios like toll paid for by pass roads etc and not limited to actual highways. further, since I am not too aware on many aspects, this will serve as knowledge to me and many of us as well.
First, lets look at road tax on a car. Now, with road tax, are we paying this tax just to ply within city roads or is it for the whole state. If it is for the state, then arent good roads a basic necessity? We have pathetic roads, and the second we have a nice clean stretch of highway or bye pass road, they have a toll set up.
For examples, the NICE corridor connecting Banerghatta Road to Mysore road and then there is also the Hebbal to Airport stretch. Why should we pay a toll, when this is suposed to be given to us. If i have to go to the airport, as a basic necessity, i would expect the road to be good and what is the need for a toll here. Same case for the other nice juntion. Doesnt this come under the gambit of road tax? Why should I pay money to use a good strethc, which the state should have provided in the first place
Would love to get answers to these questions and to get a better understanding |
Road tax goes to the state. In many other western countries, this is same. Road tax goes to the canton/state.
National highways, or Motorways as they are called there, are maintained out of common pool.
Vehicles who want to travel on them need to have a vignette affixed.
there is random checking. For example, an unmarked cop car will pull alongside you.
Most highways in India are by NHAI. Only a few, such as Worli Sealink, DND flyway, and some others are by private-state patnership.
We can have toll gates there.
But the main lifeline routes of the country, such as golden quardilateral, north south NH1, NH2, other National highways etc., all are under NHAI.
So there could a a hologram sticker which could be bought for 1 year, valid from Jan-December to keep things simple.
Of course if you buy a car in November, you are at loss, but then you lose some, you win some.
Otherwise you could buy a 2 month sticker, and then as January comes buy the yearly sticker.
Thats all the nitty gritty.
The main idea is the one which will benefit all
1. No fuel wastage at Toll gates. When I drove to Gujrat, almost 2 hours out of 10 was spent from Krishnagiri to Gurgaon on toll gates. At gurgaon 90% of driving time is at the toll gates
2. Manpower saving- Imaging no need for constructing gates, manning them etc.,
3. Time saving
Quote:
Originally Posted by amitwlele 1. I don't quite agree that smart cards won't work. If we can have a common vignette why not a common smart card? Why doesn anyone have to buy separate cards for separate states? Don't we use the same debit/credit card all acorss India or for that matter outside India?
2. Regarding fake Passport and Pan Card - How often do we use Passport or Pan Cards? We travel on roads more often. Hence more the incentive to have fake stickers. But i do agree that honesty is what is needed which is in short supply. |
Smart card still requires a gate.
This means from 100kmph you slow down and pass through a narrow lane.
This is how bottle necks are created. Moreover you waste money in gates, electronics, reader systems. When one gate malfunctions you have mile long traffic jams. Even in Europe, the 2 toll roads of switzerland(Gotthard and St. Bernard) often see 10-15 mile long traffic jams, even though people do not break rules there.
German border had 1 mile long jam just because one lane out of three was closed due to road works.
Even a small bottleneck can create jams lasting for hours.
Vignette is like your number plate.
Nobody checks it. you could probably drive without one and not be caught for a few days, or drive with a fake one for years, and not be caught unless you do a traffic offence.
Its like a pollution check sticker. there are not gates, just random checking. Huge fines will ensure enforcement, and even if we can get 80-90% compliance, it will be a success
Moreover the taxi and the segment of people who do highways regularly will anyways buy it, because they anyways spend 200-300 on tolls on every trip, and also waste lot of fuel.