Quote:
Originally Posted by misquitas I checked up the Tata Motors website and found out that the ex-showroom price of Sumo Gold in Goa is as follows:
Sumo Gold GX (BS 3): 684048.00
Sumo Gold GX (BS 4): 698554.00
Now, is there any significant difference between the two, in terms of performance, FE, etc?
Here in Goa, BS3 vehicles are still being sold and hence, if there is no major difference between Sumo Gold GX (BS 3) and Sumo Gold GX (BS 4).
Now, I know it is a radical comparison, but here goes: For a people carrier with decent (basic) comfort, PS, AC and G-R-E-A-T cabin space within Rs 7.5 lakh (on road), which of the two vehicles would make better sense, the Sumo Gold GX or Maruti Ertiga VXI?
I checked up the specs of the two vehicles and they are similar in the following details: SPECS:
Ertiga: 4265 (L) x 1695 (W) x 1685 (H)
Sumo: 4258 (L) x 1700 (W) x 1925 (H) Ground clearance: Ertiga: 185 mm
Sumo: 190 mm Turning radius: Ertiga: 5.2 m
Sumo: 5 m
The thing is, wife and I have always loved the simple but effective look of the Sumo. Driver's view is awesome and it commands (like other MUVs) better respect on the road as compared to cars. It appears to be a VFM vehicle within Rs 7.5L. We also like the Ertig, which also is a 7 seater, has great space and almost as wide and long as the Sumo.
Now, which would make a better vehicle for personal and general use?
We could even consider the Sumo EX option, which is about Rs 6.35L (ex-showroom), which may work out to about Rs 7 L on road, as we are no sure about the quality of the power windows on the GX variant. In an case, the additions on the GX like fog lamps, central locking, body coloured mirrors/handles, keyless entry and rear wiper are not crucial to us; we would miss the tachometer though. |
Being a Tata owner, I would say taht you should only go for a Tata product if you
want a Tata product, not because it has XYZ features or looks good on paper. The old gen Tata products have had their niggles sorted out and any issues that crop up now are irritances and inconveniences, like the power windows (both my front PW units were changed under warranty, one under extended), ergonomics issues and such. Major mechanical issues are not as common anymore.
If possible, rent a Sumo Gold CR4 for a couple of days, drive it around on your usual routes and maybe on a 100+ km trip, to get the hang of it. This will be enough to get you a proper idea of what you're getting into.
So, if you want a hassle-free product that will serve you well with minimal intervention and TLC, buy the Ertiga VXi. But be prepared to pay the price with the higher running costs. No matter what the ARAI FE figures are, there's no way a 7 seater MPV can return good FE. The simple fact is this: When you own a petrol vehicle, every time you start the car, you think again whether the trip is worth it, because of the fuel cost.
Buying a Tata vehicle is kind of a gamble. You can never have it all. There will be something that you have to forfeit for the lower costs. If you're lucky, it won't be something crucial. Make sure that you follow the TBHP PDI checklist, and be courteous but firm with the dealership staff (bribe them if necessary) and you should have no issues. We have had no major, showstopper issues with our Indigo CS TDI, which has now covered 30K kms. The products are good enough, it's just that the service is mostly abysmal.
We used to have a very frugal M800 before. But here's the difference I found after switching to diesel. You don't really care about the FE anymore. Our car gives between 15 and 20 kmpl, depending on the kind of trip and the way it's driven. I have not calculated the mileage once, because it simply doesn't matter. All that matters is that I seem to be filling up less often. That has remained the same, even after the repeated price hikes. And we find that our two wheelers are being used a lot less.
If you were comparing the Sumo Gold and the Ertiga diesel, I'd have asked you to go for the Ertiga without a second thought. Since this has now become diesel vs petrol, that takes priority, at least for me.
But if fuel costs are not an issue to you, because you have a fuel allowance or are really rich, go for the Ertiga VXi. Else go for the Sumo, since you already like it.