Team-BHP (https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/)

-   The Indian Car Scene (https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/indian-car-scene/)

-   -   Maruti XA Alpha Compact SUV : Auto Expo 2012 (https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/indian-car-scene/113692-maruti-xa-alpha-compact-suv-auto-expo-2012-a-11.html)

I don't see it either. The Ssangyong has a little bit of Renault in front and a little bit of Swift in the pillars the XA Alpha looks like a more focused design. Remember it isn't a Maruti product. It's Suzuki and you must admit that all their new products are bloody good.

The Ssangyong resembles the Evoque.
And IMHO the XA Alpha does not seem to be a copy of Ssyangyong.

No, it isn't true and please learn to observe cars more keenly before making such baseless statements. The similarities can be called mild at best, and are limited to the clam-shell roof, suicide doors(?) and blacked out A pillars, which incidentally happen to be quite popular and hence common design elements these days.

Apart from that, these two are as different as chalk and cheese, and I think the illustration below can clear the air for good.

The looks are different for a critical eye - and either doesn't seem a copy of the other.

But the general SUV/crossover concept design philosophy these days is followed by both - coupe like body with rising window line and sloping roof towards the rear, aggressive wheel arches that bumps into the headlight area, blackened A-pillar. Hence the similarity. Even if you compare all the SUV or crossover concepts you have seen recently, (including those from LR) these similarities will be there. Whereas the Suzuki is more Jeep like in profile, Ssangyong is more car like

They are different, but not as different as chalk and cheese - it's just that designers are going with the flow of design themes and not thinking original

Both are "inspired" from the Evoque.. Its simply natural :)

Is the news of Mahindra actually launching this SUV in India, real? if yes, when?

Without any disrespect - I do not think the cars differ like chalk and cheese. But please do remember that when you have a copy - they cannot make an exact carbon copy for legal reasons. Hence the inspired looks. In this case, please do note the rear view mirrors, door handles, the roof, etc. If this is not an inspired copy, I wouldn't know what it?

Blatant outright copy!

Maruti wouldnt be able to defend it in any court of law! (I'm a lawyer)

I am not sure who copied whom but there is definitely a close resemblance. Of course the front nose is very different on both cars but the side profile, shoulder line, way both door handles seem integrated, treatment of C pillar etc etc.

They both do look quite similar. (except from the front - but that is just a case of face design going as per the their own future family look) Both could be inspired from a common third vehicle though. :)

Would be good for us customer if both came to India through.

There is a difference between shameless copying and graceful copying. Nowadays, except Chinese manufacturers, all others try to do the graceful copying, or, the so called bench marking. In earlier days, manufacturers like Hyundai were doing shameless copying of others like Jaguar.

In this case, just remember that any car whose A-pillar is blackened will look like a Mini, and any SUV whose A-pillar is blackened will look like an Evoque!

Well copying is cheating whether you do it gracefully or shamelessly, stupid:... isn't it @romeomidhun.

But, I do not feel this is a case of copying. Suzuki wanted a brand new small SUV platform which is modern, as well as rooted to/ resembling its Gypsy/ Jimny/ Vitara heritage. They made the XA Alpha... :thumbs up.

The A Pillar-less design would immediately make it resemble the Evoque & there could be n similarities with other SUVs but that does not mean we can take credit away, before it proves it worth.

I would request @Naetik30 to provide more analysis of his or someone else' study for the forum to reach a definitive conclusion.

Yes, indeed. I was not justifying anyone. My point is different - that designers have to use some of their creative ability in making the car unique at least in some aspects than exactly copying the 'parent'. I don't think all the designers in the world are capable of creating cars which are unique and good looking in every aspect.

But, at the same time, they should not go overboard also - Some made A-pillar black (Mini Cooper, Swift, Fabia, Evoque), some made B, C and D -pillars black (XUV, Xylo), and some others made A and C -pillar black (Yeti). Some made the entire top section black, while some made only the top portion except pillars as black (Vista special edition). Now, what these designers will do? There is not much left to blacken! So, in some way or other, the cars will be a copy of another.

I think with the Evoque coming after Swift, its difficult to talk about inspiration with Mini being kind of inspiration for all these designs.
Hyundai should be blamed for this more than Suzuki.

RIP XA Alpha if Rushlane is right.

http://www.rushlane.com/maruti-will-...a-1295047.html

Here is a report on XA Alpha quite contradictory to Rushlane's - Cardekho reports,

http://www.cardekho.com/india-car-ne...2014-11652.htm

But IMO, the launch would be in 2015 - but knowing Maruti , hope they could surprise with the 2014 launch.

Cheers!