Team-BHP

Team-BHP (https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/)
-   The Indian Car Scene (https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/indian-car-scene/)
-   -   The Most Comfortable car/SUV ever in India (https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/indian-car-scene/12446-most-comfortable-car-suv-ever-india.html)

dovin4 19th April 2006 16:11

The Most Comfortable car/SUV ever in India
 
Apologies if this has been asked before, I could not find a question asked quite this before, hence the new thread.

If ride comfort, as in not feeling a thing from the road and not hearing a bit of sound, was the only criteria and nothing else (looks, power, FE) mattered, which would be the best car/SUV available in India under 30 lakhs ?

The ride should feel like you are sitting in a couch in your home.

CRV ? Accord ? Camry ? Endeavour ? E class ?

Would really appreciate some pointers in this regard.

sbasak 19th April 2006 16:13

Comfort is very much subjective matter.
All the cars you stated are among the best.

I doubt if you get a definitive answer of your post.

dovin4 19th April 2006 16:18

what if we define comfort for the sake of this thread very narrowly as

1) Lack of any feedback from the road (bumps, rough surface, big holes etc)
2) Lack of sound

Surely these 2 aspects should be quantifiable and one can pick a winner ?

venkatrx 19th April 2006 16:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by dovin4
Apologies if this has been asked before, I could not find a question asked quite this before, hence the new thread.

If ride comfort, as in not feeling a thing from the road and not hearing a bit of sound, was the only criteria and nothing else (looks, power, FE) mattered, which would be the best car/SUV available in India under 30 lakhs ?

The ride should feel like you are sitting in a couch in your home.

CRV ? Accord ? Camry ? Endeavour ? E class ?

Would really appreciate some pointers in this regard.


Under 30 lakhs......Camry

For under 10 lakhs.....its Baleno

For under 5 lakhs .... its AMBY

goldie_malhotra 19th April 2006 16:31

Quote:

Originally Posted by venkatrx
Under 30 lakhs......Camry

For under 10 lakhs.....its Baleno

For under 5 lakhs .... its AMBY

No limits - RR Phantom (I guess - never got to ride in one :D)
30-50 lakhs - E class
30-10 lakhs - Camry
10-5 lakhs - Optra (believe me, baleno doesnt come close to this gem)
under 5 lakhs - Indigo

venkatrx 19th April 2006 16:36

Quote:

Originally Posted by goldie_malhotra
Above 30 lakhs - E class
30-10 lakhs - Camry
10-5 lakhs - Optra (believe me, baleno doesnt come close to this gem)
under 5 lakhs - Indigo

Hi Goldie,

I have tried Optra once i think it was 2004 LS version (i am not sure). I found that the thigh support was good, but the lumbar support was not so good. I am 5'6", may be because of height people might find different cars better.

Anyways i would like to try out the 2006 version some time.

BUSA 19th April 2006 16:38

Quote:

Originally Posted by goldie_malhotra
10-5 lakhs - Optra (believe me, baleno doesnt come close to this gem)

agree: Many people haven't sat in the Optra and hence are not aware.

Above 30 lakhs - Maybach Saloon
30-10 lakhs - Skoda Laura?? :-| (Is it)
10-5 lakhs - Optra
under 5 lakhs - Palio?? (Is it)

EDIT - The 1.8 LT has Lumbar Support and so does the 1.6LT have. Try them i am sure you will be bowled over by the comfort.

man23ish 19th April 2006 17:51

Most Comfortable Cars

1. Amby
2. Safari
3. Tavera
4. Sumo Victa
5. Corolla

People tend to bring the price factor into the picture, there is a psychological effect that goes as - More the price you pay for a vehicle, more comfortable it must be..

But take my word, the above is the most correct order for comfort levels..


Most Uncomfortable car/SUV.

1. Gypsy
2. Sierra: Ingress and Egress is a major issue for rear seat passengers.
3. Mahindra Jeeps: All of them except for Scorpio and Bolero.
4. Maruti Omni
5. Daewoo Matiz (Cramped Seatings)

Cheers,
Manish

dovin4 19th April 2006 18:15

Corolla more comfortable than Camry ? I read a review by GTO on Camry, his comment was Camry is the most comfy car he has sat in.

I agree Amby is very comfortable. Its noisy and lumbering, but IMO the ride quality in terms of filtering out bumps is much much better than Petra/Accent/Ikon etc.

SLK 19th April 2006 18:38

its totally.. subjective....
lack of sound... and feedback is not comfort.... (think about it)

Comfort is how one feels... sitting/ traveling in one. Even the A/c counts.

For me the most comfortable car would be where I can put my computer chair and sit on it. :)

SLK 19th April 2006 18:43

Quote:

Originally Posted by man23ish
4. Sumo Victa

Man!..... Sumo Victa?... My 84 model maruti 800 was more comfortable.
Last year I was in Bangalore on work.... and I used to look for Qualis... to go home.... Sumo ... Victa or otherwise was a no no.
Yes, Victa is slightly better.... but.....

adya33 19th April 2006 19:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by man23ish
5. Daewoo Matiz (Cramped Seatings)

I disagree to it. They are fine for city drives.
After all that's where Matiz is meant to be used.

Where does Opel Astra fit in comfort car club? :)

goldie_malhotra 19th April 2006 20:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by adya33
Where does Opel Astra fit in comfort car club? :)

I would rate it verrry high in its class, though I find the optra slightly better (or is it the interiors ..)

Sahil 19th April 2006 20:43

Quote:

Originally Posted by goldie_malhotra
30-50 lakhs - E class

The E-class interiors are cramped. For the price you pay the rear seats and even front seats are restricted with space. It cost 15 lakhs more than the C-class and is barely 15% more spacious....Prime reason why we decided to wait for the 5 series instead coz E-class just doesnt provide the comfort level a 40lakh+ car should provide.

The most comfortable cars available in India are:
Amby
Skoda Superb
S-class
And ofcourse the ultimate - Maybach62

goldie_malhotra 19th April 2006 21:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sahil
The E-class interiors are cramped. For the price you pay the rear seats and even front seats are restricted with space. It cost 15 lakhs more than the C-class and is barely 15% more spacious....Prime reason why we decided to wait for the 5 series instead coz E-class just doesnt provide the comfort level a 40lakh+ car should provide.

Strange ... I have travelled extensively in E-class taxis in europe, and space has never been an issue, even though I am around 6ft, and some drivers over there are quite tall as well. Though if you find it cramped, you wont find the 5-series much spacious either - both are more or less the same in interior space.

Moreover, the rear-seat ride is more comfortable compared to the 5 series, which has a slightly stiffer suspension.


All times are GMT +5.5. The time now is 08:53.