Mini Cooper:
Official Review
• Retro-chic styling inside out. Looks super cool
• Solid build & construction. Quality is very premium
• Cooper S' 184 BHP engine offers stunning performance
• Go-kart like driving experience. Immensely direct & unbelievably fun
• Excellent handling, grip levels & high speed stability
• 5 Star safety rating and equipment (6 airbags, DSC, ABS, Brake Assist)
• Steep CBU pricing. ~30 lakh Rupees for what is a tiny car
• Manual transmission and diesel power aren't available in the Indian Mini
• Regular 122 BHP engine (Non "S" variant) has mediocre performance on tap
• Bone-jarring ride quality. Suspension is tuned extremely stiff
• Grip over uneven roads isn't satisfactory. Mini feels skittish on unlevelled tarmac
• Cramped rear seat is best suited to children only
BMW 3 Series:
Official Review
• Great styling & presence. None of the quirkiness of the outgoing generation car
• Superb ride quality in all driving conditions. Ideal suspension set-up for Indian roads
• Fast, competent diesel & petrol engines
• Phenomenal 8 speed gearbox is quick & smooth
• Rear seat space has noticeably improved
• Loaded with features & cutting-edge technology
• BMW's 5 year / 100,000 kms service plan is a USP
• Vague electric steering isn't to an enthusiast's tastes. Not a true BMW steering
• No spare wheel or even space for one! Long-distance touring is a risky proposition
• Back seat lacks under-thigh support for tall passengers
• Rear suspension feels soft under hard driving. E90's back end was more planted
• Top Luxury Plus variant is priced in the vicinity of the BMW 520d & Mercedes E-Class
• Some features missing (folding rear seat, adjustable lumbar support, front parking sensors, height adjustable seatbelts)
• Start-stop functionality is too shuddery & annoying. We kept it switched off
Audi Q3:
Official Review
• Top-notch interior quality is the segment best, and noticeably superior to the BMW X1
• Competent diesel engine is mated to a quick, seamlessly shifting dual-clutch 7 speed gearbox
• Quattro All-Wheel-Drive system offers leech-like levels of grip
• Effortless to drive, thanks to the light steering & compact dimensions
• Loaded to the gills with features, and then some
• 5 star safety rating & equipment (ESP, ABS, EBD, electronic diff lock, a multitude of airbags etc.)
• Over-assisted electric steering system. Stays light at highway speeds, feels vague too
• Stiff ride quality on bad & broken roads
• Limited rear seat space. The Q3 is best suited to 4 onboard (and not 5)
• Compact SUV, just like the X1. You could get bigger 7-seater SUVs for the same price
• Cheaper FWD variant is still some time away from launch
• Inconsistent sales & service experiences at Audi dealerships