Quote:
Originally Posted by dhanushs Guys, what will be the purpose of a Thar CRDe 2WD?
Practicality = NO
Utility = NO
Performance = NO
Comfort = NO
Economical = NO
Safety = NO
Service/Maintenance Friendly = NO
Fun to Drive = NO
City Friendly = NO
Highway Friendly = NO
Weather Protection = NO
BLING = YES.
So, is there any point in owning a vehicle just for bling? IMO, it will bring down the value of the product very much.
Also, IMO, the feel good factor now associated with the Thar owners is that, even though 90% of them have never used the 4WD lever, they have a feeling that they ride a very capable machine, and the way their machine performs cannot be matched by any other vehicle in the market, except for some pricey ones(?)..
With the launch of 2WD version of the same vehicle, I think this feel good factor originating due to the exclusivity of the product will be lost. |
First of all, most of the factors that you have mentioned are thrown out the window the moment a buyer decides to go for a Jeep. A Jeep owner like you would know that you don't buy a Jeep for any of the things that you have listed out above. Still, Let me just give my 2 paise on each of the factors you've mentioned.
I think this depends on what you think is practical for you. A big mean looking Jeep with a high, commanding driving position is an enormous advantage in any road, city, highway or a backroad. The Thar is not so big that it is a pain to maneuver either. IMHO that seems immensely practical. As does the idea of not having the suspension/tyres broken to bits from unseen potholes.
Again, it depends. I know several people down here in the south who use their jeeps as daily drives as well as for transporting workers, produce, livestock, machinery, feed, rubber sheets etc. Having seats that can fold down to create a flatbed body is about as utilitarian as it gets, IMO. My uncle does the same run with an ex-military Gypsy, and the only time the 4WD was used was when my cousin and I were having fun with it on a dirt road. Most of the time, RWD, big ground clearance and a nice amount of power will get you through.
How exactly did you arrive at this conclusion? This is one thing that people have never said about the Thar, that it isn't powerful enough. Team-bhp's own reviews state that most of what the Thar loses out in agility, it makes up for by being able to power through. We are talking about the Thar CRDe that makes 100-odd bhp, right?
I think that this is something that most Thar buyers never really put as a priority. I think that most of them are willing to sacrifice comfort for the appeal of the Jeep experience. AC and power steering and doors is a lot of comfort for a jeep, IMO.
When you compare it to say, getting 8-9 kpl on a petrol Gypsy, that too without AC or power steering, the Thar seems pretty good in terms of economy. My uncle would kill for the kind of fuel costs that the Thar has.
Well, there is the inherent safety offered by SUVS by virtue of their height.
Quote:
Service/Maintenance Friendly = NO
|
I'm guessing that a 2WD Thar would be slightly more maintenance friendly than the 4WD model.
This is a matter of personal opinion. My personal opinion is that a 100 bhp RWD vehicle can be all kinds of fun to drive.
Quote:
City Friendly = NO
Highway Friendly = NO
|
Sure the parking won't be as easy as a hatch in the city, but then that is the same for anything other than a hatch. The Thar is a lot more city friendly than say, an Innova or a Scorpio, and it's not as if people don't drive them in the city.
As for the highways, the Thar is certainly powerful enough to sustain 80-100 kph all day, has enough power to overtake, and seem well mannered enough. Depends on what you're comparing it to.
AFAIK the Thar is the only Jeep with a soft top that doesn't leak.
I think that every buyer who considers the Thar will have considered that the ownership experience will not be as easy as owning a Swift or a Vento. So it doesn't even make sense to be evaluating the Thar on these parameters.
Maybe the solution is as simple as offering the Thar 2WD model with a factory fitted removable hard top and forward facing rear seats. Maybe then, we would have something that could fill the niche that the Tata Sierra fitted so nicely into.