Re: Petrol SUVs: Can they make a comeback? First of all, I do not consider the likes of Duster/Terrano, EcoSport etc as SUVs, not even 'soft roaders', 'crossovers' or whatever new names one may invent. They do not have 4WD, and engines and frames strong enough to tow -- a trailer or another vehicle. In an earlier age they would simply be called 'station wagons', cars where the 'dicky' is inside the passenger-cabin. They are simply SUV-pretenders, Like an INDIGO MARINA with slightly taller body and higher ground clearance.
Real SUVs have powerful engines (high displacement 4-cyl, or 6- 8-cyl or even more), 4WD, strong tow hooks and bumpers strong enough to take winches or at least one in the front, and some other features. Whether one needs all that, or whether the owners will ever step off-road, are different matters.
I have been an 4WD driver all my life (except motorcycle) starting with the Willys Jeep, Nissan Jonga, and now Maruti Gypsy. I do not use them as weekend fun vehicles, but ALL THE TIME. So I am also a 'petrol-head' ! I am a reluctant Gypsy driver, as the vehicle is an underpowered toy with almost no torque, but it is the only budget petrol 4WD available in India. I only wish that Maruti-Suzuki would upgrade some features and instruments ( it does not have a trip- meter !)
Having said all that much (phew!) by way of introduction, I agree with most that petrol SUVs may make a comeback only in the TOY segment. For low end torque, AND fuel economy (even if petrol and diesel cost the same), diesel is the winner. For similar grunt, we need a big petrol engine, which our "KITNA DETI HAI" mentality will not accept, or our budget will not allow. My friend uses a FORD EXPLORER as a daily drive in Kuala Lumpur and sympathises that I cannot use a Jonga for shorter daily commute in Calcutta.
Actually I would prefer a NISSAN ONE-TONNER, such a lovely petrol "UTE" it was, with big wheels and four gears !
But the narrowing of the petrol-diesel price gap will have some positive effects : I will be able to take my Jonga or even the Gypsy, to a fuel station without being directed to the diesel pump -- "nehi nehi, udhar nehi" as I head to the petrol filler ! I will not have to stop and explain to everyone why I do not fit a diesel engine to the Silky smooth monster, turning it into a cement vibrator or a tractor ! I have had to explain to so many filling-station attendants that "Gypsies come in petrol only" that now I go to familiar pumps only ! Hope that will stop, and petrol will be accepted as a "grown-up's fuel", and not only for mobikes.
If the government retains the high taxes for plus-4m AND diesel engines, petrol SUVs may find a bigger toe-hold in the market. We need more choices in REAL SUVs, we have so few in the market, and more than half are too costly, loaded with high-tech gimmicks. |