Re: Tata developing a premium hatchback, the Altroz. Edit: Launched at 5.29 lakh. Hello friends and fellow forum members! This is my first post on Team-bhp forum and I would like to share with you all my user review of the Tata Altroz (delivery date, 03/02/2020). The reason I’m sharing this review is because I have been reading up stuff on Team BHP during my research into the purchase of a new car and have been following this thread. Hence, I felt I could give back to this community by posting my review.
My background:
I’m a Bangalore based physician and medical college prof by profession; in terms of my knowledge of cars, I’m not an enthusiast, rather an ‘aam aadmi customer’ who owned a 2009 model Wagon-r vxi until 2 weeks back (purchased from my dad), which served me quite well for day to day purposes, but never drove it inter-city because of its fragility. Hence, I may make errors or commit gaffes in this review. Please pardon me for this, I’m a competent physician, but not competent at this. However, I promise a honest, candid review. I started thinking of buying a new car roughly a year ago and started reading and understanding some technical details to be paid attention to. I decided on a new buy as soon as I noticed that Tata Nexon had scored 5 stars in the global NCAP.
Therefore, my motivation and key considerations while buying a new car can be summed up as follows –
1) Safety - my parents and grandma live in another city and are now old, so sudden inter-city travel frequent of late.
2) Safety - have been tail-gated once and narrowly escaped.
3) Safety - motor accidents are an important preventable public health problem and I believe the market must change it’s mindset with a sense of urgency.
4) Better ride comfort and driving experience – endured too much body roll and getting shaken up on Bengaluru’s dynamic roads in the tallboy.
5) Engine reliability, but not performance in terms of acceleration/speed.
6) Budgetary consideration - < Rs.9 lakh, top-model preferred.
Prologue:
I decided to wait for the Altroz in May last year, when word got out that it would be based on a new, stronger chassis and that it would be a premium hatch (my preferred car design type – frankly, I love the design of the Baleno and the VW Polo). As I waited it out however, I was swayed by the following cars – (i) Tata Nexon – Not a fan of the design and of SUVs, top model beyond budget (ii) Mahindra TUV300 – I rather liked it’s tough tank like looks. However, it wasn’t safety rated and wouldn’t make for a good city ride. (iii) Mahindra XUV300 – wasn’t safety rated at the time, over the budget, (iii) Vitara Brezza – 4 stars, decided to wait for the Altroz. I drove a friend’s VW Polo but was concerned about the poor rear space and poor after sales. Baleno was called a tin can on most forums and so did not fulfil my primary objective. As glimpses of the Altroz were released, I realized that by strength of design and the promised safety quotient, the Altroz should be given a serious chance; it was also my patriotic side speaking.
After checking out all the expert reviews of Altroz on Youtube post December Jaisalmer launch, I was still undecided, since the NCAP ratings were not out. In fact, I posted on the Zigwheels Youtube page that I would go in for the car, provided the crash tests were done and the Altroz scored at least a 4. And then came the 5 star result, I went to the showroom the next day and booked a diesel top end, expecting it to be < 10L. However, when on-road prices for Bengaluru were released, I thought the better (post ‘reasoning’ with wife) and booked the petrol. Since the petrol engine is carried over from the reliable Tiago and petrol BS6 engine tech is less complex, I thought it would also be a better bet in terms of reliability.
Review:
Purchased the car from KHT Motors Domlur. The sales staff were quite enthusiastic and had been adequately trained. They told me the footfalls had increased since the launch, indeed the showroom was full. Got the car delivered within 5 working days of paying the full amount. The car is gold and black dual tone XZ (O).
Now cutting to the chase:
The car has been with me for a week now. Drove for first 4 days and 200 kms in the city, back and forth to work under terrible traffic and road conditions (Koramangala area, imagine the worst since there’s road and plumbing work on-going everywhere, average speed around 9 kmph). Over the weekend, drove 450 kms back and forth to Belur/ Halebeedu in Hassan district on a great highway. Frugal driving, speed mostly between 70 – 100 kmph, topping at 120 kmph. So, kitna deti hai? – 15.6 kmpl over the past week; averaging around 21.5 over the long distance trip and 9.5 in the city. I’m fine with this.
Ride quality, handling, engine:
Positives –
Whatever they said in the video reviews is all true – the car soaks up the bumps. Apart from bad city roads, we travelled on mud roads near Halebeedu, winding roads and modest inclines. The car felt solidly planted and the steering, responsive at all times. Out on the highway, my confidence soared and I took the car few times to 120 kmph, for the first time in my life. The braking was adequately powerful, the car stopping dead in line and steadily. The car is sufficiently agile in the city and on the highway for my liking. In the city, it lets you effectively exploit gaps in traffic conditions. There’s near pin drop silence in the car in city traffic and the engine is pretty silent too (more on this later). On the highway, it could compete effectively with the Duster, Baleno, lower end VW Polo, Toyota etios etc in terms of speed. Overtaking heavy vehicles, never a problem.
Also, much has been discussed about the lack of an AMT. I don’t miss it, neither do I have a preference for it. I have gone all around Koramangala comfortably on the 2nd gear with my feet resting most of the time on the rest pedal (which is a bit too broad though). The clutch, when depressed is also soft. Have not experienced any knee fatigue until now. I have not yet used the cruise control buttons.
Negatives –
Feels underpowered on moderate inclines when starting from 0 in traffic. No visible vibrations, but palpable mild vibrations in the gear lever and foot pedals when giving early throttle inputs on gears 1,2,3. Engine has a very low pitched growl when providing throttle inputs at RPMs upto 3000. This noise, I liked very much and so did my family members. But, between 3k – 4k rpms, the sound keeps getting harsh and > 4k, downright noisy. The noise I felt is a limiting factor while accelerating and attaining high speeds. The sweet spot, IMO, is between 2000 to 3500 rpm.
Interiors:
I’m in love with the interiors, in fact much more so than the exterior. I love the spartan, utilitarian interior dash design; people who checked out the car had the same opinion. All the buttons and levers are where they should be and the buttons have great tactile feedback. The storage spaces are helpful and the 15-L cooled glovebox is a boon. The armrest on the left side of the driver is very useful while cruising on the highway. The rear space is generous and made the long journey comfortable. The rear seat incline we felt was not an issue. Overall, the thoughtfulness of the designers is very evident on the inside. The only negative is that the material used on the glovebox and inner surfaces of the doors gathers dust imprints quick. The fit and finish in the glovebox area could be better. Contrary to reviews, I really like the tachometer display; its just that the fat RPM display button should have been on the outer aspect than merge with the meter. AC is powerful and not noisy at low fan speeds. The space and comfort levels in the back seat are more then adequate.
Exteriors:
Much has already been said. It is indeed a striking and original design. The advantage with gold is that the hues change as the day gets along and the color can be surreal in the evenings. The piano black could have been subtle and it is an unbelievable dust magnet. Love the ALTROZ badging on the rear though. The reactions of passersby are illustrative –
1. At Belur we parked the car opposite the police station – 3 cops came out, admired the car and asked for all details. At the famous Chennakesava Temple, a family again enquired about it. They could not believe the price and thought it cost upwards of 15L just going by it’s design.
2. At Hassan, we stopped by at the largest restaurant at lunch time. Post meal, the manager walked out, requested if he can sit inside, then said it looks superb, but was a little disappointed that it did not have AMT.
3. In the city too, it’s a head turner.
4. My extended family who have driven the car, have given it a big thumbs-up.
Trouble is, though I’m a sucker for good design, I can do without the attention, it embarrasses me.
Verdict:
To me the Altroz represents a fine confluence of the maturation of original Indian auto design and sensible (if not spectacular) engineering. It is a triumph, in the sense, that the Altroz promises a safe ride, at great comfort levels and good mileage while being packaged in a beautiful, aerodynamic, nature inspired design. In the words of Faisal (Motorbeam), it’s a practical car with the introductory versions tailor made for the mass market and I endorse this view. I’m sure the TaMo engineers will think of a way to address enthusiasts ad if well done, we could have an auto icon in the making.
Conflict of Interest – I’m in love with my new ride.
Last edited by Aditya : 19th February 2020 at 17:02.
Reason: Spacing, mention of overspeeding
|