Quote:
Originally Posted by giri1.8 Sad to see so many people bashing Maruti without even owning one! Our garage has had vehicles from multiple brands
Chevy,Hyundai,VW(among cars), Hero Honda, Yamaha, KTM and Suzuki(bikes)
Of all these brands Maruti seems to be easiest to own for an non-enthusiast,I am very passionate about my cars, just sharing my POV! They deliver what they promise
-Decent A.S.S.
-Amazing resale value.
-Availability of parts in the open market.
-Warranty claims were easier.
-Extremely reliable(most important factor). |
I guess someone who has owned Marutis for more than two decades has the right to comment.
Someone who has driven a lot of European and American cars can pen down his thoughts.
Someone who has owned cars from the market leaders for most of his life and now owns one from the laggards in the Indian market can voice his opinions.
No offence meant to any Maruti owners but unless we as customers start taking safety seriously we will keep getting tin cans from various manufacturers.
Maruti service being the best or the cheapest is a myth. Same goes for any other manufacturer in India. All of them are equally good or bad. Maruti and Hyundai having a wide network helps finding at least one service center nearby who are less unethical than others.
I have owned Maruti 800 and Swift and had chance to use a Wagon R and Omni within my family.
Currently I own a Fiat GP 90 HP and my costs as well as service experience has been cheaper as well as much better than what I had for Swift. My Swift was serviced at an FnG towards the latter part of its life (total 1.2 L kms on odo) and my Fiat (total 60 K on the odo currently) is still being services at FASS. Like to like comparison I would spent equal or more on my Swift during the first 60 K. One of the main reasons they do not allow you near your car is MASS where as in FASS not even a single service has happened without my supervision. It helps root out unnecessary expenses that these service folks try to push down the customer throat.
It’s been more than 5 years since I last visited a MASS so am not sure if things have changed now. Same goes for Hyundai service. Close friends who own Hyundai’s have costs which are equivalent over the course of vehicle's life as European cars have longer service intervals.
Not getting into which car is better one doesn't need to be an engineer to figure out that the build quality of a Fiat or a VW or a Skoda is way better than Maruti. We can keep denying the fact pointing to various articles on Maruti's crash worthiness. But the truth is that a Swift or any other Suzuki sold in European countries itself are much better built than its Indian counter parts. Look at the kerb weight and one doesn't need to be genius to figure out that the Indian Suzuki's build quality is compromised.
I have read lots of posts here in TBHP as well other such automotive forums with folks jumping to defend a Maruti saying safety is not only the sheet metal thickness. Well-designed crumple zones, structural rigidity and what not are equally important. Yes I agree whole heartedly to this point. What everyone misses out is with all parameters remaining same a heavier car will have better crash worthiness than a lighter car.
I am pretty sure that my chances of surviving in a European/American car in case of a crash is much more than the made for India cars from other manufacturers who strip the cars of build quality before dumping them here. With all other parameters remaining same a heavier car has more chances of withstanding a crash than a lighter car. You can't really change laws of Physics. Can you?
Good that Europeans sell less cars which doesn't justify extensive R&D to make structural changes. No manufacturer is a saint but at least our car buying public is making sure that some of these manufacturers sell so less that they have no option but to sell cars which are same as the European/American counter parts.
Till the time Maruti focuses on build quality (not by providing balloons in lower variants) I will give it a skip. Till then I am thankful to Marutis and the Tatas and every other manufacturer who uses Fiat engines. They are giving us Fiat owners a chance to enjoy our cars.
I will not point to any links to prove my point. Drive a vehicle from the same manufacturer in any of the European or American countries. It won’t take much time to figure out what all we miss here in India.
Till such a time when Maruti focuses on "Kitna Bachati Hai" instead of "Kitna Deti Hai" I will live in my own bubble and enjoy my Fiat.