Quote:
Originally Posted by Rtech It started off with certain members saying that Skoda India was a company with a bad attitude because they mandate the use of synthetic oil and then do not subsidise its cost. So that makes them a company that is not pro-active. |
Absolutely. When you are the only one requiring a consumable that is 5 - 10 times more expensive than what the competition requires, you better work at making it more cost-effective. Last I checked, there is a huge difference between paying 400 bucks and a 1000 bucks for a product.
Quote:
Then the topic on localization came up. Skoda should localise their parts and buy oil in bulk to sell at a cheaper rate to their customers. I agree. I for one would love to buy oil for cheap and genuine spare parts for the same price as parts of a M800.
|
I would like to pay
less for everything that I buy and am a known cost-master at work. However, this is an *exclusive* situation....where there is only one manufacturer in that price band who *exclusively* requires a consumable that is 5 - 10 times more expensive that that of its competition. And that’s not once in a blue moon. It’s at every scheduled service.
Quote:
Yes, diesel advantage. Granted. But they do finally compete in the same market.
|
Correct. But then, Skoda is not the only one to offer a diesel either in the 8 - 10 lakh segments. There are alternatives, and which do not cost 7000 - 9000 a service.
Quote:
But then shouldn’t the Mercedes C class also be included? It is the same size and a diesel too! It just happens to be priced a tiny bit higher. How much does a service cost there? |
It didn’t take a debate or a poll to call a spade a spade, nor am I biased toward the cars that I own. Do have a look at this
thread (Maintaining a Mercedes-Benz in India) that was created by me within the first 3 months of Team-BHPs inception, lambasting Mercedes for their expensive servicing costs. Heck, it could have been the first thread on Team-BHP that actually discussed service costs.
Similarly, in
My C220 review I have openly accepted and described the service costs as "exorbitant".
Quote:
We then went on to say that Skoda dealers are the pits.
GTO says that this is rubbish and ….
So I did a quick search on this very forum. Let’s see what popped up:
|
As another member has commented, I could argue that:
Quote:
The statistics on the number of Honda and Skoda links probably should not be considered to arrive at any conclusion. Quite a few of those links relate to Honda City incidents. There a loads more City owners on the forum than Skodas.
|
Simple statistical research function on considering the sample sizes. I have myself lambasted Honda for their poor and arrogant dealership attitude on several threads in the forum and openly accept that their service quality is certainly not in the league of a Maruti / Hyundai / MBenz.
However, I would like to add that of the 20 Skoda owners that I personally know from Bombay (including you, Monkey, My Jiju, Monkeys neighbour who is my cousin etc.) only 3 are actually happy with Skodas service. Navin, N_Crazy and a neighbour friend.
Unfortunately, we cannot add absolute numbers to dealership quality as we can to service costs. So until then, it will be my word versus yours. But maybe even that can change with a Team-BHP “rate your dealership” survey (made a to-do entry in my palm).
Quote:
We have all heard horror stories about the prices of Skoda spares. I personally have had the shock of my life on seeing the bill after my accident.
|
Me too since I had come with you to drop the Octy off. If I remember correctly, your repairs cost you about 65% of what the cars market value would have been at that time. IMHO, it really wasn’t
that major a crash.
Quote:
So it seems that Honda too like to take their customers for a ride.
|
Not just Honda, but every car manufacturer has a certain set of parts that are exorbitantly expensive. Someone mentions that a Baleno air-con compressor costs 22 grand.
Butttttttttttttttttttttttttt that spare part comparison post from this thread clearly shows that Skoda has the most expensive spare parts in *MORE* categories (by sheer number) than any other of its competitors.
Quote:
The facts above are quite clear. Moral of the Story:
Costs:
Skoda costs more to maintain than the Magnum.
Skoda services cost more than other cars in its segment.
|
Exactly. Several times more than its competition. That, and the fact that its spares are more expensive in *most categories* simply makes the Octavia TDi the most expensive diesel car in its class to own. Ditto for the petrol.