Team-BHP - Indica Vista MJD vs Palio MJD vs Swift DDiS

Quote:

Originally Posted by sushantr5 (Post 1301419)

Yesterday I had a chance to drive brand new Swift VDi. I felt something is missing from this New Swift. I am not sure but the experience was different compared to Swift which was one year old. I just had a feeling that Plastic Quality has been reduced. It was not having that upmarket look and feel. I am not sure about this. Lot of plastic cracks were coming from dashboard and doors. Can anybody confirm whether I am right or not?

After 2k kms in new swift evreything is changed now. Engine is very smooth and All plastic parts like dahsboard and door panels are not making sound now...

Quote:

Originally Posted by vsh (Post 1293324)

hi
i own swift dzire. as already discussed rear space in swift is cramped. i just solved that problem by going for dzire. i have already clocked more than 11000km, and many times with my family and found it very easy and confortable. my family now looks for a reason on weekends to have a ride. i rejected indica because of the same old looks and maintenance.

vsh:That's a lot of KM that you have clocked in such a short span of time :thumbs up Are you constantly on the RUN! ;) What are the FE figures (For City / Highway run) that you are getting NOW? from your Dzire VDI, since its run up quite a bit. What was the FE when it was new i.e.before / after the 1st free service and likewise for the 2nd and 3rd as well?

regards
Smooth Sailing

i have voted for the swift.
i like the vista a lot for its spacious cabin & i have heard its got a good ride too. but in some other thread, i have mentioned that my bigger priority is styling, practicality comes next. so the swift...
though the vista looks good, its not a head turner in any way. the huge wheel arches & puny tyres are an eyesore. and the rear is very similar to the thousands of indica taxis i see on the road.
the swift on the other hand looks fabulous. its very sporty & a swift with just good alloys & fatter tyres looks amazing. its the best vehicle to modify, both in performance & looks.

Always we talk about brand image and all that stuff. I would like to share my Vista owning experience for last three months.

Everybody purchases car and wants to show off. I mean you would love if you see anybody peeps into your car and asks about your car. That is great moment. In January I purchased my Vista and coincidentally in other team in the company one of my friend purchased swift Vdi. Let me clear I am not comparing two cars by specs and performance.

When I bring my car into company parking then I always have very different feeling. Even after three months I could see somebody is peeping into car during lunch breaks. They are just curious to new car. Their curiosity makes me feel very good.

But what happened to my Swift friend... apart from first day and apart from his few friends nobody is interested in looking into car. That is obvious because swift is quite old and vista is very new.

But for me what matters is my feeling. My purpose of showing off is fulfilled by owning a vista. Now days more than half of company knows me because of my Vista.

After few months there will not be such buzz about Vista also. But I don't care because you know my one purpose of owning a car is fulfilled.

And in last three months I can see no added swift in company parking but I could see 6 Vista's in my company parking.

@ sushantr5: if you apply that logic, then you need to buy an i20 now, you will get more peeps. then the grande punto... then the jazz... then the...
what you have talked about is just the curiosity of your office staff. how does it imply that the vista is better than the swift?

Quote:

Originally Posted by raj_5004 (Post 1317073)

Yeah, whats the measuring scale? More peeps per rupee? Otherwise, there are a lot of options :D

Guys, I am sure sushanth dint mean it that way i.e, literally" More peeps and more satisfaction".

@sushant: I am happy that your vista has generated curiosity to your liking and has made your ownership experience worthwhile.

One thing is for sure, the vista wont see volumes the swift has seen and in a way the exclusivity will be there.

The car as a product is fantastic value for money at the time you have bought it and will serve you well for years(reliability has improved).

To me vista means a mature decision not based on the herd mentality.

Indica badging/ Delibrate Indicaish looks( Not substantial resemblance though) has let the car down a bit.

Honestly, I would not buy any car that comes with that crappy engine built by Fiat & Suzuki. For those harping about common rail diesels, they ought to go check out the engines Hyundai is dishing out in the same price range. Oh! Before everyone gets on my throat, I own a diesel swift and I HATE IT for two reasons. Crappy engine & crappy build quality. I wish I had picked up a Getz Crdi instead.

All those vouching for the swift for its looks, the Palio for the passion & emotion its built with, the Indica for its space etc have either not TD the getz or are plain anti-korean. Or are just blinded by their love towards a brand.

Quote:

Originally Posted by greenhorn (Post 1317217)

I've driven the getz CRDI, and will not deny its sheer awesomeness. If you drive an indica every day, then the swift might not feel as bad :p
But, unfortunately, nobody gives you an entire lakh for free. if they did. I'd be the first proud owner of a getz CRDi :D

I would not rate SWIFT better either( We have a SWIFT and Vista in our family so am keeping the bias out. Both are not saintly though:D)

The getz does feel better but for a lakh more the indica/swift would offer the same as the getz if not more if priced same be it engine, build, comfort etc.

The sheer Awesomeness does not matter/ count to many and honestly the multijet aint that crappy.

Quote:

Originally Posted by muni (Post 1317256)

The sheer Awesomeness does not matter/ count to many and honestly the multijet aint that crappy.

Like I said, to have a fair comparison one must drive a car with a better engine. I would love to explain how the engine behaves in detail, but right now I need to pack my bags to head to Goa. So I shall do the needful once I am back.

Quote:

Originally Posted by raj_5004 (Post 1317073)

Please read through post. I am not comparing two cars by specs. I am only sharing my experience. And to this logic, after fulfilling my exclusivity factor need why should I go for new car. The purpose has been completed.

If I would have bought any other vehicle which is in market quiet some time then I would have to look for your option.

What I am desiring from car (show off) is very small part of ownership.