Baleno: Rolling noise what is the truth?

vivek_pinkoo · 18th October 2005, 13:04

Every car will make sound on rough roads. I also hear the sound when i drive on rough road even after upgrading the tyre (185/65 R13)

GTO · 18th October 2005, 13:05

Quote:

The engine gets quite raucous
by the time it reaches 2000 rpm. It is far from silent even
while idling, -- the noise very much intrudes into the cabin
even with the windows rolled up!

Meerkat, This is standard fare with older aluminium engines. They are inherently noisier.

GTO

vivekiny2k · 18th October 2005, 14:38

not just the type of tyre, i think the air pressure in tyre also contributes to the noise.

less air, more noise. seen in in trucks, cars, buses, even on my bicycle in college.
am i right?

imjimmy · 18th October 2005, 15:53

I have only driven my car till 165 Kmph. And that also only twice. Have a black Lxi with stock tyres.

Never seemed to notice this rolling noise as people mentioned it. The stock bridgestones, being inherently hard, do make some noise on patchy roads.But that's totally from the tyres.
Also at speeds above 140 Kmph there wasn't any significant cabin noise.

Read somewhere that Maruti has made some small changes to rectify the rolling noise prob since the Euro -3 cars have started to come. Dunno how true is this..Maybe you can drive the car ureself, push her and then see.

W.r.t the pros and cons, I am sure a lot of people here can comment on the pros(it's definitely a very good car and i am more than satisified). The only significant disadvantage i have noted is that the gear box could have been better. It's not bad, but it lacks the slick gearshift which is common in Japanese cars. But it does get better with use..

Samurai · 18th October 2005, 16:24

I drove with stock tyres for say 45 minutes before switching to Yokos. Besides, I drive with windows up and with A/C on all the time. Can't say I have ever noticed the rolling noise.

Listen, there at least 17 members here who bought Baleno in 2005, and most of us are very sensitive to any kind of car trouble. I haven't heard any of us complaining about rolling noise in Baleno.

xezas · 18th October 2005, 19:59

Quote:

Originally Posted by meerkat

The perception of noise is apparently quite subjective!
I feel my new Baleno is rather noisy, -- and I'm not
talking tyre noise at all. The engine gets quite raucous
by the time it reaches 2000 rpm. It is far from silent even
while idling, -- the noise very much intrudes into the cabin
even with the windows rolled up! And it is not just my car,-
one of my friends bought it a couple of months back, and
his car also behaves the same way, (although he isn't
bothered as much as I am)! Autocar suggests that it is due
to the aluminium engine. However, it is bothersome enough,
since I've driven or seen any no. of cars which are dead
silent in comparison. In the Indian context you could
compare with the Getz to see the difference, and that's a
cheaper car! And Maruti goes to town about 13 so-called
noise-reducing measures! How would it be without those !!!

I have to disagree with you on this one. My Baleno is so silent that a few times I have had to rev a bit to know if the engine has died out on me. And a couple of times, I have jumped back into the car at the petrol pump (when I have forgotten to switch the car off) and turned the key to hear the engine whine...all because I could not make out if the engine was on or not.
Yes, the engine gets a bit edgy after 3000rpm and I do get some rolling noise when the roads are gravelly but otherwise its quite a silent car.

shobhit15 · 19th October 2005, 13:05

No noise whatsover in my new Baleno. One explanation might be that the tools in the boot make the noise on rough roads. This sound is especially pronounced when sitting in the back seat.

filcord · 19th October 2005, 13:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by vivek_pinkoo

Every car will make sound on rough roads. I also hear the sound when i drive on rough road even after upgrading the tyre (185/65 R13)

what make/tread of tyre did you upgrade to? Is there any difference in the noise level or quality after the tyre change?
Trying to nail this down to trace the source, the noise is definitely there.

vivek_pinkoo · 19th October 2005, 14:16

Quote:

Originally Posted by filcord

what make/tread of tyre did you upgrade to? Is there any difference in the noise level or quality after the tyre change?
Trying to nail this down to trace the source, the noise is definitely there.

Sorry I can not tell u the diff since I got my tyres changed immediately after taking the delivery of the car. Other wise I tell u there is no such sound. All the souns are normal.

I upgraded from Bridgestone to Apolo Accelre.

Ganzzz · 19th October 2005, 18:37

I bought a new Baleno recently. I haven't come across the rolling noise so far. But, I had upgraded the tyre right at the time of purchase to 185/65 R13 of Michelin make. So, can't say if this is the reason for no noise. In fact, I find it very silent once i roll up my windows.

Otherwise, the car is great and may be the only issue is looks. But, that again is relative and depends on individual tastes.

Buffetfan · 21st October 2005, 03:44

yu should have gone for 185/70 R 13..185/65 R 13 will reduce your ground clearance by 9 mm comparerd to original tyres

18th October 2005, 13:04	#16
vivek_pinkoo BHPian Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Gurgaon Posts: 194 Thanked: 5 Times	Every car will make sound on rough roads. I also hear the sound when i drive on rough road even after upgrading the tyre (185/65 R13)
	() Thanks

18th October 2005, 14:38	#18
vivekiny2k Senior - BHPian Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: cincinnati, jabalpur,chennai Posts: 1,264 Thanked: 209 Times View My Garage	not just the type of tyre, i think the air pressure in tyre also contributes to the noise. less air, more noise. seen in in trucks, cars, buses, even on my bicycle in college. am i right?
	() Thanks

18th October 2005, 15:53	#19
imjimmy BHPian Join Date: May 2005 Location: Chd Posts: 289 Thanked: 6 Times	I have only driven my car till 165 Kmph. And that also only twice. Have a black Lxi with stock tyres. Never seemed to notice this rolling noise as people mentioned it. The stock bridgestones, being inherently hard, do make some noise on patchy roads.But that's totally from the tyres. Also at speeds above 140 Kmph there wasn't any significant cabin noise. Read somewhere that Maruti has made some small changes to rectify the rolling noise prob since the Euro -3 cars have started to come. Dunno how true is this..Maybe you can drive the car ureself, push her and then see. W.r.t the pros and cons, I am sure a lot of people here can comment on the pros(it's definitely a very good car and i am more than satisified). The only significant disadvantage i have noted is that the gear box could have been better. It's not bad, but it lacks the slick gearshift which is common in Japanese cars. But it does get better with use.. Last edited by imjimmy : 18th October 2005 at 15:59.
	() Thanks

18th October 2005, 16:24	#20
Samurai Team-BHP Support Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Bangalore/Udupi Posts: 25,813 Thanked: 45,435 Times View My Garage	I drove with stock tyres for say 45 minutes before switching to Yokos. Besides, I drive with windows up and with A/C on all the time. Can't say I have ever noticed the rolling noise. Listen, there at least 17 members here who bought Baleno in 2005, and most of us are very sensitive to any kind of car trouble. I haven't heard any of us complaining about rolling noise in Baleno.
	() Thanks

19th October 2005, 13:05	#22
shobhit15 BHPian Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Noida Posts: 208 Thanked: 0 Times	No noise whatsover in my new Baleno. One explanation might be that the tools in the boot make the noise on rough roads. This sound is especially pronounced when sitting in the back seat.
	() Thanks

19th October 2005, 18:37	#25
Ganzzz Newbie Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: Bangalore Posts: 2 Thanked: 0 Times	I bought a new Baleno recently. I haven't come across the rolling noise so far. But, I had upgraded the tyre right at the time of purchase to 185/65 R13 of Michelin make. So, can't say if this is the reason for no noise. In fact, I find it very silent once i roll up my windows. Otherwise, the car is great and may be the only issue is looks. But, that again is relative and depends on individual tastes.
	() Thanks

21st October 2005, 03:44	#26
Buffetfan Senior - BHPian Join Date: May 2005 Location: Hyderabad Posts: 1,128 Thanked: 195 Times	yu should have gone for 185/70 R 13..185/65 R 13 will reduce your ground clearance by 9 mm comparerd to original tyres
	() Thanks