Quote:
Originally Posted by Ravveendrra If the district forum had passed an order against the consumer. Would it be fair to expect that the consumer not file an appeal? |
I'm sorry Reveendrra, but I just don't buy that. I know of one too many cases where a tenant has illegally occupied / overstayed property and goes into appeal at the higher courts. Of course, it is every citizen's right to appeal. However, the decision to appeal or not - when you know you are in the wrong - separates the man from the devil. I get the impression that you are yourself from the legal fraternity, thus you will surely know of even diehard criminals who go into appeal. The court had merely asked Skoda to return the Octavia to Harish after bringing it up to perfect standards. Skoda's not doing anyone a favour, it is Harishs right as a customer to have access to a properly functioning car!
To cut straight to the point, NO, I do not think Skoda has been fair in appealing. Pray tell me a reason other than harassing this poor customer that Skoda went into appeal? When we are fully aware that the appeal will take upto 12 months before it comes up for hearing. WHY would Skoda want Harish to continue paying his EMIs on one hand, and have his car impounded in the other? Why would Skoda NOT want this gentleman to atleast be in possession of a car that is rightfully his, even if the said car is now in a deplorable state?
Quote:
A mere accusation (even by the most well meaning citizens) is not proof
|
The case in point is clearly not a mere accussation. It has been well documented and backed up with proof.
Quote:
Unfortunately common-sense often takes a back seat in business and is invariably thrown out the window once a matter reaches the courts!
|
Absolutely agreed. This is a classic text-book case of a Lose-Lose situation (versus a win-win which a smart corporate would work toward). Atleast with its paying customers!
- Harish is in a loss making situation, despite being a premium customer who has paid over a million rupees for a supposedly luxury car. I bet he is still paying EMI's on a car that is not even in his possession. Plus, he has been made to go to the court after being treated rotten by the very Skoda who carries a responsibility to look after him (as their customer).
- Skoda is in a loss making situation since their management is purely incompetent when it comes to customer service, many of their dealers are cheaters, and the resultant bad PR is causing them a serious loss of business.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ravveendrra But, it is still a far cry from saying that every dealer steals parts from every car. |
As I have stated earlier, what we have to gauge is the number of complaints relative to the brand's marketshare:
FACTS :
1. The number of complaints against Skoda outnumber that for any other brand, especially when you consider most of those complaints are of a serious order (inflated bills, interchanged parts, shoddy service, mis-represented estimates, forged signatures etc.).
2. In the Team-BHP ownership surveys, Skoda's after sales received the WORST ratings. This despite Skoda selling only a small number of cars when compared to the big guys (Maruti, Hyundai, Tata etc.).
3. Even on other websites, Skoda's after sales garners the most number of complaints. Consider that consumer website that was linked to earlier. Skoda ranked second in volume only to PAN card issues!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ravveendrra Skoda not only needs to get some new dealers, they also need to get themselves new PR and legal guys. |
Not to mention, a solid management in charge of customer service. Else, the new dealers / PR / legal guys will adopt the exact same culture.
Quote:
It would be real sad if Skoda were to die out in India because of incompetent back office and support guys. If there is a management lesson here - it is that 'cost centres' are as important as 'profit centres'.
|
So true. Well said. I feel sorry for the Skoda brand (at the global level) which does make some nice cars, but has a bunch of incompetent monkeys in India spoiling the show for them.