Quote:
Originally Posted by airbender I do not read each and every thread. But if I am right you did post on Manza test drive thread by GTO. Your post wrote off manza even before you could see the car leave alone test drive. I don't know if you are a fanboy or not |
I do not seem to have a very good memory related to trivial issues but if I remember correctly all my initial posts in the thread you have mentioned were based on facts provided by both the Manufacturers and ACI.
I talked about ARAI figures for FE, acceleration figures from ACI, and power figures from the manufacturers. And its a Fact, mind you, not an assumption that Dzire has marginally better FE and acceleration compared to Manza. My later posts regarding cramped footwell and other minor niggles was after I test drove the car and that too I had mentioned clearly.
My only assumption was regarding the A.S.S. of TATA not being as good as Maruti's and that may or may not be true depending on the location.
Quote:
but you look to be taking specific pride in punching holes in every tata related thread.
|
Why are you bent upon getting personal? How would you feel if I say you look to be taking specific pride in being dismissive about Maruti and supportive of TATA in every TATA Vs. Maruti thread? Quote:
Your posts are mainly based on assumptions.
|
Kindly explain what makes you feel so. Also, show me one post of mine on this thread which does not have FACTS about both the cars. Also, the only assumption I have made are not baseless. (Ex- People opting for roof-racks for lack of boot in Nano.)
If you don't have anything left in support of Nano atleast spare the fellow bhpians of statements like "content in your posts is asumed", its sounds like a more polite wayof saying "your posts are false".
Atleast 500 kms in the city and around 200 kms on Lucknow-Kanpur highway.
Quote:
More variants of nano are to be released.
|
Maybe, but
why are you not concentrating on present scenario?
Why always "800 will be discontinued"/"better Nano will be launched" etc.?
Well why not leave future issues to be discussed in future itself and concentrate on present issues?
I can quote atleast a handlful of posts where you have written about "you can't buy 800 " (even when its on sale all over the country save for 13 cities) , " TATA will launch a better Nano" and stuffs. Isn't all these 'assuming'? Quote:
Would you agree that Nano is a more practical car if the next variant comes with a boot and is priced less than M800.
|
No.
But it gets as much power as 800, a boot, better brakes my answer will be
YES even if its priced a bit at par with the 800.
Quote:
How can you assume that all the short comings you have pointed out won't be resolved in the future editions/variants?
|
Show me one post of mine where I have mentioned anything like it. As for assuming bit its you who assumed that I assumed.
And again as for future, let it happen, and I'll react to it accordingly.
Quote:
others@
Well, who decides who is the winner? Market.
|
Really?
By that logic, and I wasn't in mood to bring this in between but still, Dzire sells far more than Indigo Manza (and a bit more than all indigos together).
Its a fact and you may consult any data and correct me if am wrong.
S
O, you accept that Dzire is better than Manza because its demand in market is more? Are you ready to withdraw your comments regarding manza being a better product that you made in that thread?
Quote:
The game is over guys. Nano has won. M800 sales say that.
|
M800 sales have been falling ever since Alto's price had fallen.It has been dying a slow death since last 4 years. More than the Nano, its the Alto which has over-taken 800 in every aspect. Instead of consulting data from last few months, consult the data and 'pattern' of last few years.
Quote:
If there's anything to compare Nano with it's the Alto not M800.
|
Why not? Let's start Alto Vs. Nano and see for ourselves. It will be one hell of an interesting comparo.
Quote:
Don't cheer for something you can't buy.
|
Are there only 13 cities in India? Do you want a written clarification from some MS dealer that he still sells 800?
And you say I don't talk about facts and merely assume things. Come on!
And finally, what makes you think that cheering a product that is no longer in production is not a wise thing?
Do you think people are wrong if they still cheer cars like Zen,Baleno,OHC-Vtec,Ikon 1.6,etc.?