Quote:
Originally Posted by pgsagar Clevermax, you are spot on. What I meant was simple. Will we ever see a Swift beater in show ( I mean looks ) and go ( performance)? Period. In my view people are taken in so much by its looks and go that in spite of lack of several features, it is outselling all other hatches. Romeo, my considering of other factors are in the light of its ability to outsell others in spite of lack of several features.
No I neither love Maruti nor hate. And my focus of discussion is Swift alone and not MUL. And IMO Swift is a success for its looks and go and not for its badge. If Maruti badge was so potent, why did Estilo, A-star failed to do the trick?
As of now, there isn't a Swift beater 3 years on ( since '07 ) and that is a fact however unpalatable or boring it may be. I expected more from Punto and Vista because they also share this "national" engine. But both these cars fall short of Swift's performance. Period.
Ok, let me say---to hell with sales figures, badge, features, driveability, FE. Can we see a Swift smoker in near future? One which can show a clear pair of heels to a Swift D on highway? Now please don't say Elantra/Magnum/Verna. |
Going by only the performance, I think we should put aside our expectations of a better diesel hatch in a similar price bracket for atleast another couple of years. So my thats my answer to the current discussion.
But lets deviate a bit make an assumption here...
i.e. a comparo between two assumed cars :
"Maruti Suzuki Grande Punto" Vs
"Fiat Swift".
I am not able to predict which one would have sold more??
But I assume that the rattling issues of the Fiat Swift would have been criticized more harshly then, and the initial turbo-lag, would have been written about as a turn off on every forum. The ride and handling would have lost the war against the Maruti Punto. The slightly higher pick-up would then seem to be a very minute advantage. Overall in comparison to the Maruti Punto the cons would have out-weighed the pros.
So, if i were a potential customer, I would have chosen a Maruti Punto and would have been satisfied with the thought that even though my car has a slightly lower pick up on highways, i still have a much better product, and above all I have a peace of mind that the fiat-swift owners can only dream of.
This is what the Manufacturer(Maruti) has earned through its consistent efforts and serious attitude towards its business. And, boy do respect it!!! And this respect has done wonders to the swift. People might be referring this aspect as the maruti Badge.
No product is flawless, but the badges play a crucial role during a comparo. Badges give us a pre-coceived notion that makes us lineant towards a few flaws of one product where as stringent towards the flaws of the other.
I saw a comment earlier, that the swift has a peace of mind associated with it. I would like to mention that this is not an attribute of the product as a stand alone object. It is rather an attribute of the Manufacturer, that it has gained via its quality service and customer satisfaction over time. Its not that swift owners never faces issues with their cars, but they can be laid back that there are 99.99% chances of the issues being sorted out on the first visit to the M.A.S.S.
But just comparing
"debadged" products, someone would prefer the swifts pickup, some would love the puntos ride and handling and some would love the figos VFM and rear bench comfort. So requirements of individual makes a particular product look like a winner to him. And it is unfair to just ask if some product could beat the other or not on a general basis.
I have a keen ear towards all disagreements to this theory, but please dont hunt me down as I am also a swift fan and I really appreciate it.