Quote:
Originally Posted by amit This thread has been hijacked into a Jap v/s German thread which was not the objective at all! |
This i agree it shouldnt have become, but I would like to comment on few things you said..
Quote:
Having gone through the comments, all i can say is, the average Indian's fascination with anything that starts with HO and TO continues! Most seem to have taken the comments that are not so flattering towards the Japanese personally! It's not like Honda and toyota are flawless. Both have had recalls in western countries, just that somehow the japs always manage to put to rest news of any recalls better then GM/ford etc. Fact remains, japanese cars are not a patch to drive compared to european cars. Also the build quality, and materials used even in luxury japs are not as good as ones used on lowly european cars like VW Lupo!
|
Well I am not like your average India there, after living in states, I have come to realise there is no car manufacturer whoes reliability comes close to that of the Jap manufacturers, but I personally hate Hondas and Toyotas or HOs and TOs like you put them...They surely arnt flawless, but they have recalls that are less in number than most other manufacturers of the world..Germans are known for the worst reliability in the US..i can tell you with personal experience, my friend owns a 330, it had a habbit of dropping the windows to the bottom of the door and would cost 500$ per window to fix, the same issue with his dad's 7 and his mom's 6, all there cars rattle as if they are american sub 10k cars..the 7 series door handle came into his hand when he was opening it..I mean I can go on and on ...but wouldnt, I know german cars are awesome design, but to say they are better made in terms of quality is pretty naive...We have owned and still own 2 mercdes at home, the S and the E and I would sadly compare them to my lowly G, yes the build quality of a 80k and 50k car to my 35k jap and let me not get intot he drive, my car is a far superior ride to both in terms of handling...I dont hate german car, I infact love most until they start showing their true colors, I think japs are getting better and will probably have better cars with more luxury, fit and finish than most germans..they just need to expand their lineup..(and i am only talking higher end japs)
Quote:
BTW, the Nissan 350Z is considered to be a unreliable car here in Canada.
|
I dont know how canadians drive, but surely in the US the 350Z is not considered unreliable, actually far from it...I can say all VWs are more unreliable than some american cars today..
Quote:
German's started getting unreliable from the time they started using too much of electronics on their cars. Their cars now are heavily laden with hi-tech electronic stuff. Funny thing is people expect German cars to be at the forefront of any new technologies. When Mercedes showed off the new S class in Frankfurt, everyone wanted to know what new innovation the car had. No-one expects any such stuff from lexus, Acura or Infiniti.
|
Sure, but that is no excuse that since you are putting high tech gizmos in the car they become unreliable..if you cant produce it to spec, then dont bother putting it in, and if you are putting it in, then bother to make it closer to flawless than flawed..
I agree people mostly look towards mercedes for new high tech equipment and why not, they can afford to spend that kind of money since they do rip off their customers, if you think any of the germans are worth their price tag think again..but its just that their status and appeal around the world have achieved a status that even after knowning its probably going to be flawed, I want my dad to get the new S....its an X factor which is keeping the mercedes brand name alive and as for BMW, only some driving dynamics, thats about it..as for luxury go see some new higher end japs, their materials used are of higher grade..
Quote:
Anyway, at the end of the day noone makes bad cars today. There are some strengths that Japs have and some strengths that Germans and other europeans have. If you are the sort who likes solid build, superb ride quality and handling, classy and quality interiors and mateials, supreme ergonomics, fun to drive and such stuff go for germans. If you want a point A to B car go for Japanese.
I have already had 2 guys who test drove a Japanese car and then drove a VW and ended up buying the VW cuz they said the Japanese cars were no patch on the German VW's.
P.S. One of the japanese cars was a Acura TSX.
|
I think this presumption of yours is like many other around the globe no wonder flawed germans are still busy counting the $$
and your friend really made a poor deal I would say, I wouldnt even pick a phaeton over a TSX...(not really, but still you know what i mean) TSX is a great car and the only car probably you can compare it to in the VW lineup is jetta and that is such an ugly car, with hardly a better drive if that...
actually this is the reason why people still consider 911 to be a better drive than a vette, when it really isnt, until you compare the interior quality and that too with 1/2 the money saved could be made to look like the bentley..