An oppurtunity presented itself when a relative came to visit us in his 35k kms run Swift VDi.
Although comparing a diesel against a petrol doesn't make any sense, comparing a mid-version with the top end version of its competitor doesn't make any sense- its also relevant that the DZire offers an automatic variant only in this trim.
Went ahead and clicked a few comparison pics -
1. Exteriors (front end) -
Xcent - The toned down fluidic styling adds an European touch to the car. Wont offend anyone. There is little to distinguish the Xcent from the Grand i10 save for the thin chrome strip on the front mustache.
DZire - Old design still looks very pleasing to the eyes. I prefer the Swift to the DZire when it comes to the front bumper design and also the grill - which looks rather awkward on the DZire. More width and height lends it better road presence than the Xcent.
2. Exteriors (Rear) -
Swift - The tables have turned here, and the Swift looks better when viewed from the back. The design masks the bulk of the car rather effectively. The V variants (And even the top end Z variants for that matter) lack goodies like reversing camera and parking sensors - hence after-market accessories like the ones on the above car are pretty common.
Xcent - Has the better road presence thanks to a bulkier boot which feels much better integrated than that of the DZire. Hyundai has toned down their styling elements significantly - evident from the minimalist design with much less chrome than that on the Swift.
3. Interior - Rear Legroom
Xcent - Very spacious interior for four people. Picture shows the legroom for a 5'11" person with the front seat adjusted to his comfort. Not only the legroom, the ease of entry / exit gets better as well thanks to the B pillar being located further apart.
DZire - Comfortable rear bench although legroom is just about adequate for someone my height. The car is wider than the Xcent, but the same is not reflected in the interiors. Width is about the same as Xcent - a four seater.
DZire is wider than the Xcent, but the same is not reflected in the interiors. Width is about the same as Xcent - a four seater. Also - another point to note - Xcent offers more space than the DZire even with a rear a/c tower in place.
4. Boot space.
We can safely conclude that the Korean has better space management than the Jap after seeing the above rear seat comparison pics, but incase you are not convinced - the boot capacity will reassure the Korean supporter. Its a significant difference between the two cars in terms of size and useability. If thats not all - the Korean even comes with features like remote boot release etc to make the package sweeter.
What makes matters even worse for the Dzire is the ultra thin sheet metal used on the boot. The Korean fares better, even though it is not in the league of the Europeans.