Putting the car in neutral reduces the sound, so maybe you are right about the noise originating from the transmission.
There have been some other posts regarding this on another thread which really wasn't meant to discuss this problem. So I am just copy/pasting some of them here and will try to answer them.
Quote:
CPH:
I don't know whether your power steering is electric or hydraulic. If it is hydraulic it might be the cause, which might stem from engine removal.
|
The car has a Power Steering fluid reservoir so I think it's hydraulic. I am unable to understand how the power steering could produce a whining noise at high speeds. Also what exactly do you mean by the last part of the sentence?
Quote:
Shan2nu:
It could be the wheel bearings that are making this sound after a certain wheel speed.
|
If it's the wheel bearings, would the sound be heard at lower speeds too? Specially after a year of observing this phenomenon, the car seems to run just fine till the 100kmph mark.
Quote:
ghpk:
Same as your case i was too having some noise at high speeds, Got wheel bearing checked twice, and later found it was a WIND Powered LED Light who's dynamo was giving the whining noise : EEEK
|
The car is pretty much stock, no LED or other fancy stuff. The only aftermarket accessory are the fog lights. But I have been observing the noise even before the fogs were installed, so that's not the cause of the problem.
Quote:
ilangop:
While driving at higher speeds momentarily shift to neutral and let the engine idle while the vehicle still moving. This way you can isolate the engine noise from the wheel bearing noise. My doubt is, had it been due to engine running at higher rpm, you should be able to hear the noise when ever the engine reaches a similar speed. You may also hear such whinning noise through minute air leaks. So check if all windows panes are raised and ensure there is hardly any gap for air to leak from outside.
|
I can hear the noise irrespective of whether the windows are closed or open. Also if the windows aren't completely closed, you would hear a sort of whistling noise with which I am familiar. I am sure it's not the wind noise. And the noise is noticed only when the speeds are above 110kmph. But then, I seldom revv the engine at lower gears.
Quote:
sgiitk:
Also, as the whine is speed dependent it should not be too difficult to run at the same speed into two different gears. It will immediately tell a lot.
|
I am not comfortable to shifting from fifth to fourth when I am going at 110+kmph.
Quote:
aargee:
@Honeybee - Boy!!! if you're so concerned about this issue, take it to a good H.A.S.S after consulting with our fellow BHPians & I'm confident you'll get this issue sorted out in no time.
|
The problem is with a good HASS which is so hard to find. I would have to take the service adviser onto the expressway and demonstrate the problem first hand. And then expect him to find the correct solution and fix it.
Many thanks to each and everyone for their suggestions. From the discussions and after comparing it with my driving experiences, I am guessing the noise may be due to one of these two factors:
1. High engine RPM: I high-revv the engine for long periods mostly in the fifth gear and that too when cruising on the expressway. I have high-revved it just a few times in the fourth or third gear to overtake a stubborn truck or so, so I haven't observed very diligently if the engine made a similar whining noise at high rpms in these two gears. I shall try and do that the next time I am on the expressway.
2. Transmission/Gear box: Again, the noise is only noticed after 110kmph. Assuming the gearbox is prone to making noise, wouldn't it be manifest other times as well? I usually am in fifth gear from 70kmph onwards. So if the gearbox made any noise, it should be heard even at 100kmph. Please correct me if I am wrong.
So right now, high rpms seems to be the cause of the whine. Also even after more than a year of this whine, I haven't experienced any deterioration in the engine performance, so there are chances that I may just have to live with this whine as normal behaviour.