Octavia 1.8 TSI vs BMW 330i GT vs Audi S5 Ola everyone, I have been driving my diesel Fluence for close to 6 years now and it has started to show its age and Renault lack of proper service and care are a part of the problem.
Although I had started to look for a replacement quite a while back I could not find a good alternative in the SUV/Crossover segment. On paper the Hyundai Tuscon seemed quite good but in reality the space inside is in line with Creta/Compass/etc. On top of that the 170mm GC with a soft suspension does not help and it bottoms out at larger speed bumps. So I dropped the idea of buying a SUV all together and started looking into other categories.
Enter the RS, I must confess I love turbo diesels they offer economy and other aspects of ownership which titillate me but the RS was something else I saw it drive by and overtake two "car carriers" trucks in a few seconds. It sounded like a expensive German and given Skoda roots I was instantly interested in a RS.
I tried for a few weeks to get my hands on a new RS but since I could not get my hands on it and my recent test drive with it was not exactly great "Lower GC let to it bottoming out on uneven roads and I think its AoA is even less than the normal model also the stock rubber needs an upgrade asap" so I let the RS be and now I am now looking at these four cars:
1. Skoda Style TSI AT
2. Skoda L&K TSI
3. BMW 330i M Sport GT
4. Audi S5
For the Skoda's I want your opinion on the gearbox since its the infamous DQ200 "DQ250 for the RS?" unit and although the problems that I used to hear about earlier have died down but still I am not sure. The car would be driven in Himachal extensively so there should be less of a temperature issue but yes it would take trips to Delhi and around once in a month. Secondly the maintenance and other costs after the 4 year pack is over with how high do they go for an AT unit and since I plan to keep the car for 12-15 years to justify the costs I would like to have an idea of the cost of maintenance. Thirdly what is covered in this 4 year promise?
For the BMW GT I found it a awesome performer and has a lot of space but still I could not make out if the space inside was more than the Octavia. The maintenance costs for this is also a question mark but the dealer told me the petrol has cheaper maintenance than the diesel. Overall the boot space is a little smaller than the Octavia and again it also has soft suspension like the Tuscon.
The Audi S5 was suggested by the Skoda dealer whom I was bugging for the Octavia RS and since they own a Audi showroom as well they suggested the S5. I have yet to take a test drive but I saw it in the flesh and what I saw did not appeal a lot to me its lower on cabin space to the Octavia and GT. There is also a problem with the thirsty engine which was highlighted by the dealer himself.
The financial breakup is a tedious one for each of these cars I will have to take a loan and for the S5 its working out to be a bit of a problem but the BMW and the Skoda's are well in the loan criteria I have from the bank. Also have to consider how do they age because I plan on keeping it for 12-15 years min I have seen old Octavia's not looking that great after 8-9 years but that might be because of bad service provided for the 1st gen Octavia's.
So there you have it my whole dasata, car gurus kindly guide me into the light. |