re: Dilemma: Mercedes GLC vs GLE vs BMW X3 Firstly, thank you all so much for your very kind responses - I really appreciate the feedback and input. This is very helpful.
Let me attempt to address the points (in no specific order) on some other options that all of you have recommended, based on responses received: - We didn't like the shape of the X4 (just personal), and didn't consider it seriously;
- We found the NX300 smaller and again, like the X4 didn't like the shape and the looks. I completely agree with your point on the maintenance costs though, having had three Honda Accords over the last 18 years in the US and India. The Japanese cars are fantastic and so easy to maintain. I know the shape / looks argument sounds flimsy / petty, but I guess I don't have a better explanation on this one;
- We are not majorly into speed as I said, so didn't get so kicked by the Macan and also found it a bit cramped;
- We loved the Volvo XC60 and the V90 too actually, but were worried about the after-sales service and spares as we don't know what kind of a network Volvo has in India. We could be mistaken, but the Germans seem to have many more service centres in places we go to, because they've likely been around longer. The XC60 is a terrific car and we were blown away. Also, I personally loved the V90 too (my wife didn't as much), as we have the A6 allroad in the UK, that we adore and the V90 reminded me of that car;
- We did like the Q5, but even though it is the latest generation and had the digital cockpit + very good features, we preferred the feeling of the X3 and the GLC/GLE from a driving perspective. The Q5 felt a bit light - could be mistaken here again - I wouldn't call myself a car expert, by any stretch of the imagination;
- The X5 is out of our budget;
We have never bought a new car before and this will be our first new vehicle. So, our priorities are possibly as follows: - Reasonably spacious luxury SUV (for ground clearance reasons) with great driving comfort for both city and long distance journeys and up to date features; Bangalore city trips often take longer than long-distance journeys due to the traffic here, as most Bangaloreans will attest to;
- Under 65L OTR, with reliable after sales service and spares as we are likely to keep it for 6-8 years (based on our track record with cars);
- Reasonable space - we don't have children and don't expect to be in the back seat often. This is for self-driving and our parents are likely to sit in the back, maybe occasionally the dogs when we go on a long trip;
Based on the above, let me try and also answer some other very good points raised wrt these three cars. - Any car including the X3 costs significantly more in Karnataka because of the road tax. So even though it might be available cheaper in Gurgaon and other parts of India, we will never get it at that price point. I think we can bring the dealer down to 64-65L, but it is unlikely to be less than that, unless I am terribly mistaken. I'd be happy to stand corrected;
- I loved the feel of the X3 from a driving perspective and it felt solid with road presence and real driving pleasure. We loved the looks of the new X3 as well and of course the pick-up and handling were sensational as most BMWs are;
- The GLC drove well and has surprisingly good space at the back, but seems a notch lower in terms of features than the X3. Also, while clearly nicely fitted out, it doesn't seem to have the same interface on the digital side as the X3. Also, the fact that the spare tire is not planned for properly is a problem, given the condition of the roads in Bangalore and where we are likely to drive - Chennai, Goa, Corog, Kodai and Ooty;
- The GLE is very spacious and has an amazing feel in terms of comfort when we drove it, but it seems very dated, with the digital systems seem really seeming prehistoric. Plus, we prefer a petrol option for a range of reasons;
So, as of now, the X3 30i seems the preferred option, although maybe we should look at the Q5 TFSI more seriously, and maybe take another look at the Lexus too.
If we do go for the X3 30i, are there things we should keep in mind with respect to after-sales servicing, warranties and maintenance? This is an office-leased car, with the option to buy after three years.
Thank you all so much. As I said before, much appreciated. |