Quote:
Originally Posted by santosh.s Posting here after a loooong time. Good to see that I am not the only one to still drive around in a 15+ year old Baleno (and a 10+ year old Palio). Have been thinking of replacing one of them with a SUV, but its Palio which will go first so will most likely keep using Baleno for another few years.
My Baleno's suspensions have been making khad-khad sound for quite some time (especially front ones and only on bad roads), but are otherwise still good. Didn't want to spend hefty SGP prices and therefore searched online and came across dirt cheap bushing sets available on amazon similar to what you have used.
Front: https://www.amazon.in/dp/B08DTDHP7F/...v_ov_lig_dp_it
Rear: https://www.amazon.in/dp/B0831GGRJ6/...v_ov_lig_dp_it
Authorized service center folks won't do the job (of course) and another local mechanic is also quite reluctant to do the replacement work. He told me that quality of these sets won't be good, especially metal parts in a few of them which he thinks may worn out or crack in as little as an year! You seem to have used similar sets for over an year now, so your feedback would be valuable. Do you recommend buying these bushing kits based on your experience? |
Just an update for the benefit of people who might browse this thread for similar issues: I did find a local mechanic who did suspension job for my car. It was only for front suspension, rear suspension is pretty much intact, no repairs needed. (even though I have used it for 16 years now, my running is very low, just shy of 1L km as of now
). Details of the job done (terminology may not be accurate!) -
1. Rubber bushes from a new suspension bush kit (from Amazon) were used as needed. The one with metal part was not replaced based on mechanic's recommendation as he said old bush is still in very good shape and that just greasing it is enough and would be much better than replacing it with the inferior bush from that kit. Major problem was with other big bushes used for lower arm and stabilizer bar (significantly worn out), which were replaced and generously lubricated.
2. Tried to replace damaged ball joints and rods, mostly bought online from boodmo . Major one was the joint connecting stabilizer bar (it was totally worn out). Replaced with original MGP part. Lower arm ball joint could not be replaced because it seems to be casted in the arm itself and hence not removeable. The old one itself is fine as per the mechanic. Steering link rods were replaced with after market ones (though supposedly of good quality). I didn't feel any need to change it, but gave benefit of doubt to his opinion. Another similar rod/ball joint was to be replaced with new one, but it didn't fit in spite of being MGP. This one again was in good to replace category but not really necessary.
Unused parts were returned. Total damage was around 8k including other work like a/c gas refilling (for the first time in 16 years!), thorough cabin cleaning/vacuuming, installation of cabin filter, rat mesh below wipers to avoid dried leaves and other garbage entering into a/c ducts, installation of led bulbs wherever possible along with electronic flasher (cost of bulbs and flasher not included above), and a few other petty jobs.
I have been using the car for several months since then. Suspension noises are almost gone (say more than 95% at least), ride and steering feel is perfect, no issues noticeable to me. Steering was normal anyway even before this work. My gut feeling is that suspension should work fine for another few years easily, given that my running is still low and my usage is far from rough. I would recommend similar repairs for the suspension if anyone is contemplating.
After a few months, a/c gas leaded out and was diagnosed to a minor leak in condenser, around a pipe joint. It is supposed to be the most likely location prone to developing leaks in this car, over time due to vibrations. The solution is to replace the condenser. SGP cost was about 20k just for the part! I wanted to replace it with a reputed aftermarket brand instead (like denso or so, don't remember exact names of options given), but it wasn't available. So settled for another no-name brand as the mechanic vouched for it's quality and I felt the same based on my own visual inspection. Another expenditure of about 8k for this job too, but the AC is as good as before now.
On a lighter note, considering costs of new cars/suv's I am thinking of switching to and yearly insurance itself running into 1-2L range, above costs seem next to zero.
You have to pay in terms of time and efforts though.