Re: Bengaluru: Dealer auctions old Yamaha RX135s for 1.5 lakh! Ok. For all the people who speak that 2-stroke engines are oil spitting dinosaurs, let me give you a small lesson in automobile engineering.
In cars, after you drive for 1000kms, you do a top up of engine oil. Do you ever wonder why? It is because the engine oil evaporates under high heat. The oil vapours are not condensed. Instead, a pipe runs from the engine cover into the intake manifold. This is found even in modern cars. The oil vapours are sent into the engine to burn along with petrol/diesel and exit through the tail pipe. So, even modern cars with their hi-tech less polluting engines spit oil vapours from exhaust.
Now comes the debate of the quantity of oil vapour from 2-strokers vs 4-stroke. In an 2-stroke auto or a chain saw or old scooter, 2T oil is mixed with petrol as 2.5ml of oil/liter of petrol. So, invariably, all the oil is spit out. But, in hi-tech bikes of the era like KB100, RX100, Max100R, they have a separate oil reservoir. It has a 2T oil pump which sprays fine and controlled quantity of oil. And so, the oil consumed is quite less than the 2.5ml/liter. I can confirm this because I have a KB100 and I have used it for some time.
In the end, no matter how low oil they spit, 2-strokes give out more oil than 4-stroke. True. But the pollution caused by the plants that make the new bikes, the pollution by all the allied plants like steel manufacturing plants that give raw materials, the workers transport pollution, them causing congestion so that other cars are also stuck in traffic jam and so the pollution because of them, just think about the expenses.
The UK govt was criticized a lot for introducing incentives to scrap old vehicles just because of the argument that I made above. And that is a developed nation where environmental laws are far more stringent. The indian bike produced today complies with BS-II standards and not the latest BS-IV as of cars. So, really if you are suggesting getting a new bike than using these oil spitting dinosaurs, you must have a brain the size of a nugget.
If you really are concerned with pollution, stop diesel trucks that are plying intra-state transport because they are more than 15 years old and even the new ones with stricter emmission standards are overloaded and so the engine works overtime and pollutes more. And also ban turbo-diesel cars like delhi govt did. Because, point 1, even though they give out lesser CO2 emissions, they give preposterous amount of NOx emmissions which is ridiculously high. And for that reason, Paris decided to stop allowing diesel cars into paris by 2020.
The second reason why diesels should be stopped is because of clogged up EGR valve. The car still works fine with some less power. Diesels are less polluting because a portion of exhaust goes back into engine and burns so better burning of waste and lesser emissions. The problem is that this re-use is governed by EGR which gets clogged up and so there is no re-circulation. So, now, the diesels are far more polluting in this fashion. What is worse, the EGR is not magic to eat away all soot, it barely re-circulates it. So, soot forms finer particles and sprays into the air which go undetected. Another icing on the cake is that EGR only functions when the engine is fully warmed up and has been running for sometime. And we use diesels for in-city short distance commutes. So, EGR is closed causing pollution. Let me put another cherry on top of it. The diesel cars, as exposed by VW scandal, work well under testing conditions. But in real driving with hard acceleration, they spit smoke like rolling coal.
And let me take it one step further. People don't drive their diesels in turbo-zone. Diesels in their turbo zones are efficient and cleaner. But when there is lag, the engine is slow to respond. TO have a linear torque curve, the ECU is tuned so that it spits marginally more diesel at lag zone to make the lag less noticeable. So, they are polluting a lot.
And let me make one thing clear. Just because you get more mileage does not mean you are less polluting. Now tell me, are these 2-strokes really that important or are other things higher up on your list. |