|
Search this Thread | 30,345 views |
4th December 2018, 09:59 | #46 |
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Apr 2011 Location: Dubai/Bengaluru
Posts: 3,550
Thanked: 11,033 Times
| Re: October 2018: Two Wheeler Sales Figures & Analysis Thanks for your well thought out analysis. This is what makes TBHP so enriching. My two bits on the matter; A comparative strategy is a staple for a late entrant. The way to do it is to highlight a feature of existing brands that customers do not like or identify a new segment altogether and then give it all. That explains the 'Haathi Mat Paalo' jibe at the Enfields! Bajaj had a lot of strategies going for their motorcycles. Discover was doing well as a 125 offering, but launching too many variants diluted the brand. This is the learning Bajaj got from the episode and did not want to repeat it with the Pulsar portfolio. Dominar has all the making of a new brand. New shape, a new heart, new features and your average 'motorcycle buying Joe' will not care if the engine is KTM derived or Pulsar derived as long as it meets his expectations of smoothness and other efficiencies. Don't forget that Bajaj has Avenger firmly entrenched in the cruiser segment. So Dominar couldn't have taken that positioning. The more I think of it the more things are apparent, and Bajaj's mistakes with regards to positioning/strategy just stand out. Another thing I'm not clear about is the Vikrant bike. Did it add to Bajaj in some way or was it pure emotion? Another probable mistake was withdrawing from the Scooter segment where it was 'generic' for decades. They gave up too fast. Look at Hero Destini 125. It does all things Activa, but better...with improved suspension and features. Now it's too late to re-enter the scooter segment for Bajaj. |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks Sebring for this useful post: | neil.jericho |
|
4th December 2018, 10:53 | #47 |
Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: Cochin
Posts: 3,796
Thanked: 19,201 Times
| Re: October 2018: Two Wheeler Sales Figures & Analysis Sebring, you bring out some excellent points in your post. Sharing my thoughts on some of them - With regard to Bajaj's overall strategy, yes they have a lot of brands, each with its own story but to an end consumer like me, what does Bajaj stand for? We have the CT100, Boxer and Platina brands at the lower end of the segment, the Discover in the mid segment, the Pulsar, Avenger, Vikrant at the upper end and the Dominar at the top end. That's a lot of brands and to confuse things even more, Bajaj's innumerable variants of each bike mean that the segments overlap with each other on and off. End result is each brand is diluted which in turn dilutes the Bajaj brand as well. That said, I havent been in a Bajaj showroom in ages and havent seen if, and how, the variants of each brand overlap each other on price. -I liked how the Vikrant brand spun a patriotic and strong message from day 1 but at the end of the day, it was fated (doomed even?) to compete against the Discovers and Avengers and Pulsars within Bajaj's own stable. If you wanted a 150 cc Bajaj, at one time in 2018, you could choose between the Boxer 150, Avenger 150, V15 and Pulsar 150. All in the same showroom! There is a very real problem of offering too much choice as well. - Coming to the Dominar, Bajaj made the mistake of bringing themselves down to a me too competitor by targetting the competition too early in its lifecycle. If I were a late entrant into the washing powder market and my product had no differentiation, my first step would be to show how I clean clothers 10% better than the rest. Bajaj didnt need to follow the same strategy because the Dominar is a strong product in itself. With say 4 - 5 years of steady sales under its belt, it could have gone ahead and said hey, our bikes go around India faster and easier than the competition. That credibility and track record was missing when it went after the competition. - Sticking to the Dominar, my big question to enthusiasts and Bajaj is what next? Build the brand by going down to 220 cc only? Or 220, 200, 180, 150 and 125 cc? And try to exist against the other brands in Bajaj showrooms? Or wait for the KTM 790 to launch and then Bajajify (not a real word but you know what I mean) the platform to launch the Dominar 800? But that would mean that the Pulsar would be the #2 brand and will have to remain below the Domainar 400 in terms of engine capacity. That could be a terrible move for Bajaj. - Back to the Pulsars, again what next for Bajaj? Its been stuck in the 150, 180, 200, 220 cc segments for far too long. As the company and brand that virtually created the affordable performance segment, its been relatively lethargic in the last few years. It needs to go up in displacement to survive in the long term. Why not the 250cc engine from the Duke 250? Maybe the RS250? Followed the NS / AS 250? Bajaj is unfortunately being held down by the sales success of the ageing Pulsar 220 and that cannot be a reasonable long term strategy. |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks neil.jericho for this useful post: | Sebring |
4th December 2018, 11:45 | #48 | |
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: Bengaluru
Posts: 1,168
Thanked: 2,121 Times
| Re: October 2018: Two Wheeler Sales Figures & Analysis Quote:
Quite simple: Q: What are they buying instead? Ans: CLASSIC 350 Q: Why? Ans: What else gives you more Street Cred/Visibility/Audibility at Rs. 1.7 Lakhs in India? (that ear splitting exhaust mod helps a great deal as well) Smoothness, Reliability can all go down the drain.. also the DOMINAR being extremely difficult to make out from the rear that whether its another Pulsar on the road, doesn't exactly help. Customers don't think of BRAND VALUES and BRAND ETHOS. They don't think so deep. All they want is the Best Bang for their Buck. And at Rs. 1.7 Lakhs, the customers definitely want to stand out/get noticed in a crowd. Last edited by payeng : 4th December 2018 at 12:07. | |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks payeng for this useful post: | neil.jericho |
4th December 2018, 12:03 | #49 | |
BHPian Join Date: Nov 2015 Location: Pune
Posts: 121
Thanked: 230 Times
| Re: October 2018: Two Wheeler Sales Figures & Analysis Quote:
IMO the Dom is a great VFM product but should not be compared to the FZ25 which probably appeals to someone looking for a different product. Last edited by bevivek : 4th December 2018 at 12:20. | |
(2) Thanks |
The following 2 BHPians Thank bevivek for this useful post: | Balaji31582, neil.jericho |
4th December 2018, 18:33 | #50 | |
BHPian Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: chennai
Posts: 265
Thanked: 200 Times
| Re: October 2018: Two Wheeler Sales Figures & Analysis Quote:
1) Common people are not OK to buy Bajaj's costing more than 1.5L. In case of Bajaj, People see KTM to be the premium segment rather than Bajaj as an offering. 2) Look at P220 sales vs RS200 sales. Its few thousands more, but still the value offering is enormous. A well faired, liquid cooled, 6 cog, triple spark, ABS, etc with all new chassis (or platform) compared to not so modern engineered machine with specifics mentioned for RS200. I understand these two should be looked at different segments considering even the pricing. But my observation is that, when the pricing goes beyond a threshold, people are not able to attach it to the "brand value". 3) If R15 with its ergonomics can make 15K per month, RS200 could go above atleast 8K consistently. I am not sure all the people buying R15 knows about VVA, the new language of Yamaha R breed, etc, etc and then chose this. They see value/branding attached to R15 even when it goes well over 1.5L. If we get exact breakdown between P180, ns200 & RS200, we can understand this better.One more case could be Duke 200. Duke 200 for the first time crossed 3K numbers, Dominar couldn't do half of it at similar pricing. 4) We have seen hyundai verna older version didn't click but the new gen become superhit. That could be a good case study for bajaj to see how they can bring in premium branding to their logo. Till then, I see, Bajaj has to keep their offerings less than the magical 1.5L-1.6L under cutting the Duke 200. Last edited by Balaji31582 : 4th December 2018 at 18:40. | |
(2) Thanks |
The following 2 BHPians Thank Balaji31582 for this useful post: | jpcoolguy, neil.jericho |
4th December 2018, 19:45 | #51 |
Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: Cochin
Posts: 3,796
Thanked: 19,201 Times
| Re: October 2018: Two Wheeler Sales Figures & Analysis
Wow, those are excellent perspectives indeed. I think you have hit the nail right on the head when you talk brand perception and pricing comfort when it comes to the low sales figures for the RS200. And now that you bring it up, I could not locate the RS200 numbers in the sales figures, I wonder if it is clubbed with the Pulsar 180 and NS200. The R15 V3 is a good but not great product in itself. Fit and finish is not too good. There is no ABS. These were widely acknowledged by automotive journalists at the time of the bikes launch. There is the question of the tank being not sturdy and flexing with pressure, as reported by many users. Like you said, it does 15,000 units a month at that price which is very impressive and most owners I see, are young (early 20s) but still dont know to ride it properly (arms straight as an arrow with no comfort). This used to be the crowd that lapped up the Pulsars without a second thought say 5 years ago. The other aspect is, incomes have gone up and the middle middle class and lower middle class is very comfortable taking a two wheeler loan and buying a near 1 lac bike if they perceive value in it. For example, I see the assistant to a painter we know (the house wall painting kind, not the arty farty types) come to work on a Pulsar 200. That was unimaginable 10 years ago but they see value in a 200cc bike they perceive is priced right. If Bajaj has shoehorned themselves into this Rs 1.5 - 1.6 L price range, how will they move up the ladder with more expensive (and profitable) offerings? Or will they have to concede that to the other players and hope the KTMs draw enough to keep their bean counters happy? |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks neil.jericho for this useful post: | Balaji31582 |
5th December 2018, 02:41 | #52 | |
BHPian Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: chennai
Posts: 265
Thanked: 200 Times
| Re: October 2018: Two Wheeler Sales Figures & Analysis Quote:
2) The evolution of TATA for sometime now makes us to think that they are finally here where most of us expected them to be at No.2 right from the start (early 2000) given the wealth of resources they had. Hence this case study falls under gradual evolution. Whereas, hyundai's transition from santro, getz lineup to i10, i20, verna, creta is seen as superhit because it happened as quick as possible and in more predictive ways. I wish bajaj goes by the hyundai way as they remain the trendsetter for us so far. 3) When I had the first gen DTSi P180, bajaj used to have the probiking center. I still remember that probiking centers were unique and not across all the showrooms. If I got a model from probiking, it meant some added value of performance. P150 was never sold as part of probiking. P180,P200,P220 were sold. I was 23 at that time and I know even people with 40+ brought P180 as it was just 3K more than P150 but the value offering was more in terms of performance. These centers were converted to KTM dealerships slowly. What Bajaj lost in that transition was the brand it created for its aura for performance oriented segment. Launching Pulsar 135 further added to misery. Atleast for me, Pulsar at one point of time was a bigger brand than Bajaj itself. They should bring back ProBiking with all ns 200, RS200, Dominor lineup alone. Launching NS160 will dilute this. I don't see our people going for performance with less cc bikes. The common mindset of our market is to associate performance with cc's except for REs and the RXs This could change if more models similar to Duke 125 gets introduced but with correct pricing. | |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks Balaji31582 for this useful post: | neil.jericho |
5th December 2018, 03:35 | #53 |
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Apr 2011 Location: Dubai/Bengaluru
Posts: 3,550
Thanked: 11,033 Times
| Re: October 2018: Two Wheeler Sales Figures & Analysis To me, Bajaj has always been a maverick. If I were to advise them on the future course of things, I'd say do the unexpected. Don't ignore scooters. Launch KTM branded performance scooters. NTORQ and Aprila kind of performance scooters are right up their alley. Launch cruiser scooters with new branding, (like the Burgman), in that segment. These are all vacant pockets they can fill. Scooters are 50% of the market and growing. |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks Sebring for this useful post: | neil.jericho |
6th December 2018, 00:05 | #54 | ||||
Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: Cochin
Posts: 3,796
Thanked: 19,201 Times
| Re: October 2018: Two Wheeler Sales Figures & Analysis Quote:
Quote:
The only challenge is I dont see anything in the pipeline for Bajaj right now. Surely they cannot introduce another brand in the sub 1.5 L category. Sharing engines like they have done has backfired. They have to slowly push their way up the ladder and move to the Rs 1.5 L to 2 L segment with newer and better offerings. Hence the RS 250 suggestion. Or at a later point in time, even the RS 400 which can be placed slightly above the Dominar to move higher up the price range. And as much as it appears as though Im picking on Bajaj, I really do want them to thrive. And I say this not just as a Gen 1 Pulsar 150 owner. A successful Bajaj will make the competition pull their socks up and as customers all of us will benefit. Quote:
Once again you are bang on target when you say the value that the Pulsar 180 brought was perceived to be more because of the low price differential. Today that value perception stops at the Pulsar 220 as customers look up the ladder of offerings from Bajaj. P.S - I think the R15 has pushed the market acceptance of what a low capacity motorcycle can successfully command (admittedly on the back of 10 years of R15's success). I think Aprilia can swoop in with its mini RSV4 styling and relative success of the sporty SR150 scooter, push the 150 cc performance market upwards in price and sales. Quote:
| ||||
(2) Thanks |
The following 2 BHPians Thank neil.jericho for this useful post: | Balaji31582, Sebring |