Quote:
Originally Posted by sachinayak XUV, I understand. But Rexton? There is 4L+ cost difference in the ex-showroom cost of the top-end Storme and the base-version Rexton. Translated into an on-road pricing, this gap widens even more. Rexton being superior on Features, Specs, Technology etc is understandable, but on the topic of Rear Seats
Sharing an image from another thread here. |
I test drove the Rexton - and have the following observations:
1) Interior quality is pretty good, better than Fortuner. Feel it is quite good looking as well
2) The engine is a gem, the vehicle feels top heavy, is weighty
3) The manual version (only version that gets the low range box) is deprived of many important features, like ESP, Traction Control, ASR, Roll-Over Protection, HDC, extra pair of airbags, powered seats, leather seats, etc and is still 21.70 Lacs on road in Mumbai. It is more cramped than Storme or XUV5OO from the inside in spite of being a bigger vehicle.
So compared to that the Storme is not that bad a deal (only on the basis of features and what you get vs. the price you pay, as I cant comment on the driving behaviour as I haven't driven the Storme yet). And lets not forget, the Rexton is also a pretty old platform.
Also, Mumbai folks waiting to look at the Storme, I just got a call from Concorde motors for the Mumbai launch (12 Noon, 11th Dec at the prabhadevi showroom). So finally we can test drive it I presume. And as with all things Tata motors these days, they obviously made it most inconvenient for interested folks to be there at the launch - its on Wednesday at noon - bang in the middle of the work week!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Vikhyath When Tata really OWNS Land Rover, why not use some of those engineers or know-how to improve product design. A similar analogy would be what Bajaj managed to do with the Pulsar 200NS.
_______________________________________
On a different note, I think they could have mated the interiors of the Storme to the exteriors of the Xenon somehow to make it more appealing. |
And that is the problem with the JLR acquisition. By itself, JLR is a fantastic company, great brands, great tech, great reputation and Tata has enriched JLR with their support (monetary and otherwise) and the success is there for the world to see. But as an acquisition, it is still very difficult to identify how it fits in the Tata Motors portfolio. But having bought the company and probably setting it on a path where the breakeven would have happened or in sight, one might wonder if a dispassionate but practical and effective Tata manager might take the view that the traditional Tata Motors UV and Passenger Cars platform (especially this!) is just a piece of junk, more so when you compare with what they have in their portfolio with JLR - and needs to be junked appropriately. A long term view might see the Indian car market evolving to a point where a very highly localized LR model can see significant volumes (5 years back who would have thought that a 16 lakhs on road XUV will have 5 k sales per month and still have weeks long waiting period). Maybe that's what Tata should be working at. And just maybe, that's what Tata is actually working at and hence the apparent lack of interest/aggression in the current UV and passenger cars portfolio. There are no all new models planned for either the UV or the passenger market and they are just milking existing platforms with new variants (Storme, Manza Club Class, the mythical Nano Diesel). And if that is the case, one has to admit, it is smart thinking from Tata motors, aimed at the future. Of course, those who have loved Tata Motors products will find such a turn of events disappointing as given everything and all said and done, Tata Motors products have always been cheaper and VFM. That is a worthy reason to love the company!
~And nevertheless, like a Tata fanboy, here is my Christmas wish list for Mr. Behram enriched Tata motors: A 4*4 with a proper low range box, diff locks, an uptuned version of the 2.2 Varicor, good GC, good interiors, stock AT tyres made on a shortened version of the X2 platform (no 7 seater)!