Re: Tata Safari Storme : Official Review I don't know who introduced this misconception about Tata Motors being reliable, because this is nothing more than misconception! Case in point are not one but two September 2010 Tata Safari 2.2 Dicor in their VX trim. One being a 4x2 done 13k kms. and the other being a 4x4 having done 31k kms. Both these vehicles were scheduled to be taken on a 7k+ kms. road trip and were handed over to the local TASC for regular and preventive maintenance. Both these vehicles spent a good week with the TASC and all regular checks were done. Voluntary oil changes were carried out for both vehicles. For the 4x4, there was a complaint that the air conditioner was in-effective and as such, the ac gas was refilled and this I am told, took care of the cooling. Bushes were changed. All-in-all, the vehicles spent a good week with the TASC.
The first breakdown happened on the 1st day of the road trip when the Cam shaft on the 4x4 broke. Thankfully, I was in a major city but even then, I had to ask my Service Advisor (and friend) to drive down from Shillong along with a few spare parts to get my problem fixed on priority at the largest TASC in Guwahati. This because the local SAs and SMs were unwilling to show an urgency to get my vehicle road worthy again. I was delayed by 8 hours but was still thankful that I was back on the road again.
By the time I was about 500 kms. into the road trip, we could feel the ac again loose its cooling on the 4x4 on which the ac gas was refilled but we decided to continue since we had already lost enough time and were behind schedule.
Somewhere around Gopalganj (small town in Bihar before UP Border), about 1000 kms from home, the clutch on the 4x2 (14k kms. on the odo) gave way. There were no TASC which could cater to passenger vehicles in this town which had not one but three TASC for Commercial Vehicles. I had to literally spend the night (from 7PM till 2AM) on the highway before Tata Motors sent me a tow van, which was nothing more than a Toyota Qualis with a nylon rope which we use to hang our clothes on! After 5 hours and 3 instances where the tow rope snipped, we reached Gorakhpur. The TASC opened at 10AM and it was discovered that they did not have the clutch plate in stock. The spare arrived at 2PM. When done, it was discovered that the clutch cylinder too would need replacement. That too was not in stock. After speaking with the spares manager and explaining my situation, they had pity on me and agreed to open a working clutch cylinder from another Tata Safari which had come there for service! Also, while the 4x2 was worked upon, I asked them if they could check the ac on the 4x4 and as expected, they too "discovered" that the ac required gas refilling! Another incident I can report here is that the SA wanted to fleece an extra 1500/- from me for this as he claimed that he got a hose pipe replaced which was not in stock! I refused and threatened to complain to his superiors and he disappeared and was not seen till I was at the TASC. Left the Gorakhpur TASC after clearing a bill of 17xxx for the 4x2 and 4x4 vehicles.
Reached Agra the next morning, already a day behind schedule, and realised that the ac on the 4x4 had again stopped working! Decided to continue to Delhi and get it checked there.
In Delhi, I was recommended a TASC at Gurgaon by a very close friend whose another close friend worked as the Manager. Here, I was told that the ac was going bad every time as the cooling coil was damaged. Got this replaced and cleared a bill of 11xxx and since then, the ac has been working well.
That's TASC for you! Not at all reliable and with zero quality control and checks.
And hey, after having owned 4 Tata vehicles since 2009 and having two top of the line Tata Safaris which were purchased on the same day, I have never ever been provided with any privileged service. If anything, the SA who is a friend comes to the rescue. I don't know what will happen if he decides to leave Tata Motors. I will by then, sell off all the Tata vehicles we have or simply stop using and driving them!
Last edited by SumitB : 22nd May 2013 at 18:28.
|