Quote:
Originally Posted by rr_zen I advised him to stay away from the Mobilio and go in for a new Innova instead (though I personally dislike the looks of the latest gen Innova) for am sure that the Mobilio may not match the comfort levels of the Innova. Of course, the other option I gave him was to wait for the 2015 Innova launch. |
Mobilio is no match for Ertiga or even hatchbacks at that price point. Innova will continue to be comfort king, defeating even Fortuner thanks to a bumpy ride in Fortuner.
Quote:
Originally Posted by KedarB Thought of sharing this - Autocar India has just published an article questioning the Mobilio pricing vis-a-vis the Ertiga.
This is the first article I found, outside of team-bhp forums, criticizing or questioning the pricing of the Mobilio, that too, after a week of the official launch! |
Its probably the first article on ACI where they are questioning Honda. Else, almost everytime Honda has emerged out as a king in ACI comparos.
Its a very honest question they have asked and IMO, if ACI is questioning Honda, its time for the Jap manufacturer to revisit its strategy, specially the pricing one.
Quote:
Originally Posted by blacksport Maruti owners should now be heaving a sigh of relief. After being hounded for a long time for owning "tin boxes", now there is a new manufacturer to take that crown. While Maruti is improving the build of its cars with each iteration, Honda is fast dishing out cars with shoddy quality, while still charging a premium. Maruti at least had the decency to sell their cars are competitive prices. Now the Maruti owners can point at a Honda and say, "there goes an expensive tin-box". How fast things turn around. |
Maruti has certainly improved over a period of time and this time around, starting with Brio, Honda has consistently taken a step backward in the segment below City. I wonder what is actually wrong with both, Honda and Toytoa. They seem to have lost VFM tag in lower end of the market. Hyundai and even Suzuki have stepped up. A firm like Tata has also improved, but Toyota and Honda have simply lost it in under Rs. 7/- lakh market. Not only are the products sub par, even the overquality have taken a royal beating. Out of City, Amaze and Mobilio, only the City felt nice.
Quote:
Originally Posted by hyper-VTEC She being a total novice asked me who on earth designed these and call them cars I told her it was the Mobilio. She started walking to our car and asked me to drive off without uttering a word. Thank god. |
Somehow, when I practically saw Mobilio, it did not look smashing. The low profile robs it of any presence, people from the front mistake it for Brio/Amaze and its more "Estate" than "People Mover"
Quote:
Originally Posted by paragsachania It will confuse the buyer on choosing over Engine Size Vs Space Vs Build Vs Quality Vs Sitting position. But price becomes the biggest differentiator. A difference of a whopping ~2Lacs between the two and I am sure a lot would give a thought about it before booking one. |
I appreciate your comparisons. It really takes more than a bit of time to actually compile a post with such comparison.
But, I would disagree with you. Reason is : SEATS. The seats in Mobilio are simply useless. When one has to travel longer distance, something more and more Indians are doing, the real shortcomings would show up. I weight in at around 90 kg and stand around 5'10" tall. For somebody who is more than 5'6" or so, the second row of seats are going to get uncomfortable. Lack of thigh support shows up. Ertiga, IMO, has a nice combination of much better seats and less space as compared to Mobilio.
The front seats of Brio, err Amaze, errr..Mobilio have fixed head restraints. Width is less and I was not fitting in. Back support was also not good. In today's age what I cannot digest is : Fixed head restraints, narrow and uncomfortable seats.
My grand i10 also has fixed head restraints ( the export versions get adjustable ones and we Indians are cheated once again ) but overall the seats are not uncomfortable.
The emerging trend of thin seats and fixed head restraints is disturbing to say the least. Celerio in international markets has adjustable head restraints, but in India what we get is pathetic seats and fixed head restraint. Hyundai does not fare any better. Old M800 we had from 1992 had a better seat than what Grand i10, Celerio, etc. have. I had driven M800 for more than 40K Kms.
Quote:
Originally Posted by a4anurag Space 'IF' is the main priority then Mobilio wins hands down else it doesn't for me.
I cant pay 2L premium for a car made with cost-cutting as a main motto. Not a good move from Honda. Seeing the pictures under thigh support is low and moreover thin seats spoil the feel even further.
Many would give a thought before the cheques are signed.
. |
I think that the feeling of space will not survive for long. Seats are bad, and the width of car is very less as compared to Innova/Xylo. I doubt that space will sell Mobilio, the car brand craze will bring in number, but certainly not space. Rear legroom of even Wagon R is nice and has a more comfortable seat at rear. Mobilio should have its base in Jazz, not Brio. I think a Jazz based MPV will be next Honda creation pitted against Innova, with similar set of engines that propel Amaze/City/Mobilio.