Re: Tata Zest : Official Review Went to a Tata showroom to have a look at Zest. Liked the car much, so asked for TD which I was granted without any drama. I drove the top end version with Manual Transmission.
For sake of clarity, I am putting down my views in 2 sections, one for car and other for the factor which might make or break this car after the relatively competitive pricing, i.e. Dealer Experience.
Dealer Experience :
The dealer I visited was Miles motors, Atladara, Vadodara.
Went into it and nobody was to talk to. 3 men were winding up what was a grand launch ceremony for Zest. I went upto Zest and started to have a look. Nobody bothered me, which I something I like as it gave a nice window to get feel of the car.
Later on, a lady comes from somewhere in the office when I have the hood open. She started to talk about features, engines, etc. Under the hood was reventon 1.2.
I asked for price list, got a hand written from her for XM diesel. Its around Rs. 7.2 OTR in Vadodara.
Also, a Safari Storme was there so could not resist myself and went upto it. The lady quickly asked me to have a seat at sofa. This was because the Storme was a delivery to someone. I really liked it. She tried her level best to keep me away from a car which was to be delivered. Max I could do was sit in driver's seat and get down.
Negatives were : very low staff due to holiday, no water, etc. serving which nowadays is the norm. The entire dealership was as if it has just opened or was to be closed down, this could have been better.
Got the TD without much hassle. The TD guy was also trying to explain to me all the things and tried to impress me with music system and AC at lowest setting. Quickly asked him to reduce AC ( and eventually did it myself ) and to shut the music system down. He obliged.
Overall, as compared to my Honda showroom visit, this one was much better, though Maruti, Toyota and Hyundai are better in that order.
The ZEST!
I am damn impressed! On this independence day, I feel proud that an Indian firm has moved very forward. A brand which now owns British firms like JLR. Very nice TATA.
1) Zest has excellent seats. After i20, this was a very positive and pleasant change.
2) Excellent space, more than new i20. Dzire, Xcent, i20 and Amaze are no match for Zest for space. Front and rear space is simply outstanding for the segment it belongs to. Headroom is not in short supply even at rear.
3) The feel of switches like power window switches, etc. have improved. Felt better than Amaze, Mobilio. Hyundai tops this parameter with Maruti coming in for close second.
4) Contrary to what others say, boot space is actually usable, that is what I felt.
5) Two metal rods to prevent luggage from entering or rear seat/cabin. Nice protection.
6) The seating makes one feel like driving an SUV or rather a crossover. A very big positive.
7) Excellent visibility. One can even look at the hood if seat is set high.
Makes driving this car comfortable.
8) Either there was something horribly wrong with speedo or the car is excellent in masking speeds. At 55 I thought I am doing less than 40. Would be on my toes on same stretch of road in my Grand i10 at 55.
9) Nice ride.
10) Balanced,mature handling. Very few nasty surprises as far one is not pushing the car too hard. Mild spirited driving is not an issue. Where my Grand i10 would make the driver tense, Zest was at ease.
11) The diesel engine (in 90 bhp format) driveabiltiy is one area where Tata has managed to beat down Suzuki and Fiat ( Fiat as such is beaten down by all who are using its engine ). The same motor in Ertiga ( I am also factoring in that Ertiga would be heavier than Zest, though the exact figures are not with me ) feels lively only after 2000 rpm. In Zest, the motor will pull from 1000 rpm in 4th gear without any complain. And a small push after 2000 rpm. Gearbox was smooth overall and slots were easy to find.
12) Brakes on top end version made my Grand i10 brakes feel wooden. Excellent brakes on Zest. No wooden feeling, progressive pressure put on pedal results into equally progressive bite. In my Grand i10, after the initial pedal push, small push further makes no difference at high speed.
13) Steering was nice to hold. This is the car which I would love to do a 1000 km drive in a day.
14) I am not an audio expert and by end of my TD the sales guy accompanying me started to boast of it and informed me that even at high volume, the quality of audio wont suffer. It did not for a layman which I am in audio systems. Felt better than Innova, Wagon R and my current system in Grand i10. Audio system is something I never give any attention to in any car. This one seems to impress me.
Negatives :
1) Fit and finish in some places needs to be improved.
2) Rubber and plastic quality has improved, not segment best which is led by Hyundai and Maruti.
3) No bottle holder on doors. A small but irritating oversight. If they were going in for new tooling, they should have given bottle holders.
Overall :
Amazing combination of ride, handling.
Space is outstanding.
Quality of interiors can give depression and inferiority complex to Amaze, Mobilio and Etios twins.
Features like projector lights add upto the value and actually help in driving.
MID was not overtly catchy which is practical.
Meters were too small. A larger speedo at center would be my personal preference. Atleast larger dials would have been more practical.
High stance is also very useful on Indian roads.
A very practical, quality alternative to segment leaders. Step in right direction for Tata. Makes Toyota and Honda offering in this segment look like shameless shortcuts. Better alternative to pricey (IMO) hatches, mainly i20 and in future the Jazz.
Last edited by aaggoswami : 15th August 2014 at 19:45.
|